Steel (Shaq) vs Catwoman (Halle)

[godisawesome]

We had Superman Returns vs Green Lantern.

So how about a rumble between the panned spinoffs that don't feature their "parent" heroes? The sports star trying to be a movie star vs the Oscar winner trying to make a franchise? The movie that clearly did adapt comic storylines and features vs the one trying to be Spiderman? The spinoff that took over a decade to arrive versus the "rookie" hero making it to the silver screen?

Which of these films is at least somewhat worthwhile? Steel.....or Catwoman.

You decide.

 

[Fallen Angel]

Steel all day long dude. Catwoman was horrific though Halle Berry looked mighty fine in that outfit.

 

[KevanG]

Having seen neither I shall give my opinion on both like many on these boards do. Catwoman was worse because of other peoples opinions I've heard about it. Steel was better because I have heard very few people say bad things about it.

 

[The Joker]

Steel by default of being less terrible.

 

[Kahran Ramsus]

Steel at least has some small charm in its badness. Catwoman is agony to watch.

 

[Jason Kane]

Both sucked balls!

 

[batfreakforever]

Catwoman. Just because of the batman returns catwoman cameo picture.

 

[Spiderine]

That Catwoman movie was absolute BS. It wasn't even the Catwoman we all know and love. Who in their right mind would even make that ****. Its pretty damn bad when I have to choose a Shaq movie over Catwoman.

 

[Urich Leeds]

Steel at least had some resemblance to his counterpart; Halle Berry's Catwoman had jack and **** to do with the comics.

Steel, while low budget and poorly acted, was still a pretty ok attempt. Just okay. It just has no business existing. Especially without Superman being a part of it.

And I have to give credit to them for making the suit decently accurate to the comics. At least, compared to Catwoman..... which again had jack and **** to do with the comics.

 

[Keehar]

Steel should steal the poll here.

 

[spiderman2]

While nether are great ovlisely steel easily in this one. It I very rare that I hate a movie has much has a lot of people do. Heck I don't think green later in really that bad like people say but when it comes to catwoman yes it really is that bad. The only thing that could have made catwoman worse is if it didn't have a sexy halley in a sexy suit other then that there is no way to make the movie worse. Steel is like a ascore movie compared to this lol.