World Superman Elimination Game (round 6 -writers)

[Red]

Superman Writers Elimination Game​

After the fifth round to find the best alternate Superman. The next round is Superman Writers.

The basic rules are:

You just take a point off a writer you don't like and put it on a writer you do like. The last writer left wins! All writers start with 10 points and you must wait one hour before reposting.

So if you were to take away a point you would put a (-) next to that writers points and reduce its point by 1. If added a point to a writer you would place a (+) next to their points and raise their points by 1.


> Writers (In no particular order):

Special thanks to Mister J.


John Byrne 10
Jerry Siegal 10
Joe Shuster 10
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 10
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 10
Roger Stern 10
Louise Simonson 10
Mark Millar 10
Jeph Loeb 10

 

[Mister J]

Per Red X's approval, we have the inclusion of Dan Jurgens, George Perez and Marv Wolfman as well.

John Byrne 10
Jerry Siegal 9 (-)
Joe Shuster 10
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 10
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 10
Roger Stern 10
Louise Simonson 10
Mark Millar 10
Jeph Loeb 10
George Perez 10
Dan Jurgens 10
Marv Wolfman 11 (+)

 

[Mister J]

John Byrne 10
Jerry Siegal 8 (-)
Joe Shuster 10
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 11 (+)
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 10
Roger Stern 10
Louise Simonson 10
Mark Millar 10
Jeph Loeb 10
George Perez 10
Dan Jurgens 10
Marv Wolfman 11

 

[Red]

John Byrne 9 (-)
Jerry Siegal 8
Joe Shuster 10
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 11
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 10
Roger Stern 10
Louise Simonson 10
Mark Millar 11 (+)
Jeph Loeb 10
George Perez 10
Dan Jurgens 10
Marv Wolfman 11

 

[Mister J]

John Byrne 8(-)
Jerry Siegal 8
Joe Shuster 10
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 11
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 10
Roger Stern 10
Louise Simonson 11 (+)
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 10
George Perez 10
Dan Jurgens 10
Marv Wolfman 11

 

[Mister J]

John Byrne 8
Jerry Siegal 7 (-)
Joe Shuster 10
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 11
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 10
Roger Stern 10
Louise Simonson 11
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 11 (+)
George Perez 10
Dan Jurgens 10
Marv Wolfman 11

 

[TheFalcon]

John Byrne 8
Jerry Siegal 7
Joe Shuster 10
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 11
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11 (+)
Roger Stern 9 (-)
Louise Simonson 11
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 11
George Perez 10
Dan Jurgens 10
Marv Wolfman 11

 

[Mister J]

John Byrne 8
Jerry Siegal 6 (-)
Joe Shuster 10
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 12 (+)
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 9
Louise Simonson 11
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 11
George Perez 10
Dan Jurgens 10
Marv Wolfman 11

 

[Iceman]

John Byrne 8
Jerry Siegal 5 (-)
Joe Shuster 10
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 12
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 9
Louise Simonson 11
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 11
George Perez 10
Dan Jurgens 10
Marv Wolfman 12 (+)

 

[Mister J]

John Byrne 8
Jerry Siegal 4 (-)
Joe Shuster 10
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 12
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 9
Louise Simonson 11
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 11
George Perez 10
Dan Jurgens 10
Marv Wolfman 13 (+)

 

[Iceman]

John Byrne 8
Jerry Siegal 3 (-)
Joe Shuster 10
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 12
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 9
Louise Simonson 11
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 11
George Perez 10
Dan Jurgens 10
Marv Wolfman 14 (+)

 

[Mister J]

John Byrne 8
Jerry Siegal 2 (-)
Joe Shuster 10
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 12
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 9
Louise Simonson 11
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 11
George Perez 10
Dan Jurgens 10
Marv Wolfman 15 (+)

 

[Prognosticator]

John Byrne 8
Jerry Siegal 1 (-)
Joe Shuster 10
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 12
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 9
Louise Simonson 11
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 11
George Perez 10
Dan Jurgens 10
Marv Wolfman 16 (+)

I'm more puzzled at who to vote for in this?? In my opinion, Superman doesn't have as many stand-out writers for his stories?? I recognize all of their work, but I don't have a clear favorite right now... Opinions?

 

[Mister J]

Maybe you could go by the writer in your favorite story Prog.

John Byrne 8
Jerry Siegal 0 (-)
Joe Shuster 10
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 12
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 9
Louise Simonson 12 (+)
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 11
George Perez 10
Dan Jurgens 10
Marv Wolfman 16 (+)

 

[Prognosticator]

John Byrne 8
Joe Shuster 10
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 12
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 8 (-)
Louise Simonson 12
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 11
George Perez 10
Dan Jurgens 11 (+)
Marv Wolfman 16

Still a tough decision. Only 1-2 major stories stand out for me from each writer...and i'm only thinking of Superman Titles, not JLA or S/B

 

[Mister J]

John Byrne 8
Joe Shuster 9 (-)
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 12
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 8
Louise Simonson 13 (+)
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 11
George Perez 10
Dan Jurgens 11
Marv Wolfman 16

 

[Iceman]

John Byrne 8
Joe Shuster 8 (-)
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 12
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 8
Louise Simonson 13
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 12 (+)
George Perez 10
Dan Jurgens 11
Marv Wolfman 16

 

[Prognosticator]

John Byrne 8
Joe Shuster 8
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 12
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 8
Louise Simonson 13
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 12
George Perez 9 (-)
Dan Jurgens 12 (+)
Marv Wolfman 16

 

[Mister J]

John Byrne 8
Joe Shuster 7 (-)
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 13 (+)
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 8
Louise Simonson 13
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 12
George Perez 9
Dan Jurgens 12
Marv Wolfman 16

 

[Iceman]

John Byrne 8
Joe Shuster 6 (-)
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 13
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 8
Louise Simonson 14 (+)
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 12
George Perez 9
Dan Jurgens 12
Marv Wolfman 16

 

[Mister J]

John Byrne 8
Joe Shuster 5 (-)
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 13
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 8
Louise Simonson 15 (+)
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 12
George Perez 9
Dan Jurgens 12
Marv Wolfman 16

 

[Ebil Gig]

John Byrne 8
Joe Shuster 5
Jerry Ordway 10
Geoff Johns 13
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 7 (-)
Louise Simonson 15
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 12
George Perez 9
Dan Jurgens 12
Marv Wolfman 17 (+)

 

[Mister J]

John Byrne 8
Joe Shuster 4 (-)
Jerry Ordway 11 (+)
Geoff Johns 13
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 7
Louise Simonson 15
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 12
George Perez 9
Dan Jurgens 12
Marv Wolfman 17

 

[Ebil Gig]

John Byrne 8
Joe Shuster 4
Jerry Ordway 11
Geoff Johns 13
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 6 (-)
Louise Simonson 15
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 12
George Perez 9
Dan Jurgens 12
Marv Wolfman 18 (+)

 

[Ebil Gig]

John Byrne 8
Joe Shuster 4
Jerry Ordway 11
Geoff Johns 13
Grant Morrison 10
Alan Moore 10
Mark Waid 11
Roger Stern 5 (-)
Louise Simonson 15
Mark Millar 11
Jeph Loeb 12
George Perez 9
Dan Jurgens 12
Marv Wolfman 19 (+)