Teacher punished for slavery film clip

SoulManX

The Inspector!
Joined
Oct 20, 2004
Messages
11,028
Reaction score
1
Points
58
FORT WORTH, Texas - An elementary school teacher was disciplined for showing her fifth-graders parts of the R-rated film "Amistad" during a lesson on slavery.

On Jan. 25, Larue Washington showed her Ridglea Hills Elementary class clips from the 1997 Steven Spielberg film depicting slaves en route to the Americas, including a scene in which a character was stabbed, district officials said.
Washington failed to follow school board policy requiring commercial movies to be reviewed and approved by the school principal, the district said.



Washington failed to follow school board policy requiring commercial movies to be reviewed and approved by the school principal, the district said.
The policy also prohibits showing any portions of an R-rated movie, and the principal would not have approved the film, district spokeswoman Barbara Griffith said. Letters explaining what happened were sent to parents this week, Griffith said.
Washington, who has taught for 27 years, declined to comment. The school district did not disclose what disciplinary action was taken.
"Amistad," released in 1997 and starring Morgan Freeman and Anthony Hopkins, is based on the true story of the 1839 revolt by Africans aboard the slave ship Amistad and the ensuing court case against them.
Larry Shaw, executive director of the United Educators Association, said Washington was trying to give students a sense of what life was like on a slave ship. He said it's not uncommon for teachers to forget to submit movie clips for approval since they are not showing a whole movie for entertainment.
Last May, officials in the Alvarado school district apologized after teachers showed fifth-graders a clip from "Saving Private Ryan," another R-rated Spielberg movie, this one about D-Day. Also last year, a teacher in the Birdville district was suspended after showing the Gulf War movie "Jarhead" to a high school class.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070202/ap_on_re_us/teacher_disciplined_film
 
Yet I remebember of hearing teachers showing kids "The Passion of the Christ" and being commended on it.
 
Eh. It makes sense. When I was in elementary, middle, and high school, my teachers kept giving us permission slips that our parents had to sign before we were allowed to watch certain films in class. That school has a procedure. The teacher didn't follow it.

Where's the news?
 
Big deal. My year 8 class watched Schindler's List which was an age 15 film in the Uk and no one complained.
 
yes, that's right, let's teach kids about horrible historical events, but NOT express to them that bad things happen

Let's just skip over the holocaust, slavery, the civil rights movement, the conquest of the native americans, the red scare, and every single war so our kids won't know the world can suck sometimes. This is an amazing idea all our schools should implement.

Next, let's have sex ed but omit all references to genitals!
 
i remember seeing a slavery film in school, it was history class
 
but if we watch an r rated film everyone has to get a slip signed
 
yes, that's right, let's teach kids about horrible historical events, but NOT express to them that bad things happen

Let's just skip over the holocaust, slavery, the civil rights movement, the conquest of the native americans, the red scare, and every single war so our kids won't know the world can suck sometimes. This is an amazing idea all our schools should implement.

Next, let's have sex ed but omit all references to genitals!

Its 5th Grade, this is like standard in every school I've ever gone to. Some parents dont want kids watching R rated movies without their permission. I dont see whats so wrong about that.
 
Hey kids, let's bury our heads in the sand about history! :)
 
Hey teachers, just throw out the rulebook when you want to make a point
 
Hey teachers, dont bother teaching just show movies and hope they learn!
 
Hey teacher, I just realized I forgot to pay you for the past 3 months. Oh well
 
Hey teachers, just throw out the rulebook when you want to make a point

Like the rules are infallible and should never be bent or broken for educational reasons. Scopes Monkey Trials anyone?
 
yes, that's right, let's teach kids about horrible historical events, but NOT express to them that bad things happen

Let's just skip over the holocaust, slavery, the civil rights movement, the conquest of the native americans, the red scare, and every single war so our kids won't know the world can suck sometimes. This is an amazing idea all our schools should implement.

Next, let's have sex ed but omit all references to genitals!

Did you read the story? The teacher was punished because she showed an R rated movie without getting it approved, not because she was teaching the kids about slavery. If she was just teaching about slavery it wouldn't have been a problem, if she got the movie clip approved by the school board it wouldn't have been a problem. However, showing a movie clip from an R rated movie without prior approval to a class of 5th graders. Maybe she should've used Roots as an example instead, it was on network TV therefore unrated, but still a very powerful mini-series, during 6th or 7th grade history, my teacher used to show Roots every friday.
 
Keyword, keyword.:o

We don't have any pictures from back then, children usually understand something better by seeing it. I have no problem with the teacher showing a clip from a film.
 
Like the rules are infallible and should never be bent or broken for educational reasons. Scopes Monkey Trials anyone?

If the teacher wants to use a movie clip as part of her lesson on a particular subject, get the damn thing approved.

If the teacher thinks it won't be approved, how about they have more than one movie.

Tough **** for the teacher.
 
If the teacher wants to use a movie clip as part of her lesson on a particular subject, get the damn thing approved.

If the teacher thinks it won't be approved, how about they have more than one movie.

Tough **** for the teacher.

Would John Scopes have gotten approval for teaching evolution?
This isn't The Transporter, this is an accurate film based on one of the biggest crimes against humanity ever. I'll go with not letting a kid see Die Hard but this isn't violence for the sake of entertainment.
 
We don't have any pictures from back then, children usually understand something better by seeing it. I have no problem with the teacher showing a clip from a film.

Good for you, if I was a parent, I would have problems with a teacher showing my 9-10 year old kid an R-rated movie without approval. I must be an uptight ******* or something.
 
Would John Scopes have gotten approval for teaching evolution?
This isn't The Transporter, this is an accurate film based on one of the biggest crimes against humanity ever. I'll go with not letting a kid see Die Hard but this isn't violence for the sake of entertainment.

I don't give a damn about kids, nor do I give a damn about humanity.

If some *unty teacher can't understand the simple concept of submitting movies for approval before showing in class, why the hell should I care if she loses her job or faces other repurcussions?

That's what it's about, and why I see no reason to join in the boo-hoo circle jerk
 
The teacher should have known better for the sake of his job. But I'm willing to bet that the teachers and parents and teachers are the only one's that give a ****. Do you think the children have been tramatized?
 
The teacher should have known better for the sake of his job. But I'm willing to bet that the teachers and parents and teachers are the only one's that give a ****. Do you think the children have been tramatized?

It's their job to give a ****.:whatever:
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"