Yeah, the Hot Toys figure is disappointing. Obviously they ran into difficulties duplicating this particular costume at that scale, which is too bad. I have the Hot Toys Robocop, which is basically a perfect representation of that character, so it's unfortunate to see they didn't knock this one out of the park, too.
I missed the boat on their 1989 Batman (now if I were to get it on Ebay it would cost twice as much), and was considering picking up the BvS Batman... until I saw it.
Maybe I'll get the Batman Returns figure instead. Or Captain Phasma.