The Classic Battle of Lindsay and Hilary

[PyroChamber]

I don't know why I was thinking about this, but we all know that a few years ago there was this whole debate about who was better, Lindsay Lohan or Hilary Duff. Now, around that time (when it came to overall hotness) Lindsay was clearly considered better; but ever since then she's lost some of her hotness, gone to rehab, and pretty much gone the route of a lot of young stars in Hollywood.

Duff, on the other hand, hasn't really gotten is to much trouble like Lohan has, except for talks of an eating disorder. And it looks like she's got her **** together until like Lohan. So, between the two of them, has Duff become the winner of this debate?

 

[The Chairman]

They both suck.

 

[Golgo-13]

Hilary Duff is definately cutier than Lohan to me.

Besides, after Lohan's comment "Blacks guys just seem to love me, they're always hitting on me", she comes off like she thinks she's gods gift to men...Black guys like all kinds woman....we just like pu$$y. ya dumb *****

 

[PhotoJones]

of the tweener-singer-actor breed, i'll take mandy moore.

 

[PyroChamber]

Hilary Duff is definately cutier than Lohan to me.

Besides, after Lohan's comment "Blacks guys just seem to love me, they're always hitting on me", she comes off like she thinks she's gods gift to men...Black guys like all kinds woman....we just like pu$$y. ya dumb *****

With the way she's been looking and acting she should be lucky anyone's hitting on her. And the way she says that, she makes it seems like black guys hitting on her is a bad thing.

 

[Golgo-13]

Well she actaully said it in a bragging type tone, a few years back. It was when she hosted the Mtv awards and her dancing on stage had somehow earned her 'black points'..

..but i hear what ya saying Pryo

 

[PyroChamber]

Well she actaully said it in a bragging type tone, a few years back. It was when she hosted the Mtv awards and her dancing on stage had somehow earned her 'black points'..

..but i hear what ya saying Pryo

Oh, I see. I saw Duff's new video and she's actually looking pretty good now. I didn't even notice the teeth this time.

 

[Catman]

"Remember when we used to debate who was better, Michael Jackson or Prince? Prince won."
-Chris Rock

 

[PyroChamber]

"Remember when we used to debate who was, Michael Jackson or Prince? Prince won."
-Chris Rock

Now that there IS true.

 

[OverMyHead]

"Remember when we used to debate who was better, Michael Jackson or Prince? Prince won."
-Chris Rock

I spit juice all over my keyboard.

 

[Manic]

"Remember when we used to debate who was better, Michael Jackson or Prince? Prince won."
-Chris Rock

Does that make Ashlee Simpson the El Debarge of this situation?

 

[PyroChamber]

Does that make Ashlee Simpson the El Debarge of this situation?

Or probably Chico Debarge.

 

[Shifty]

of the tweener-singer-actor breed, i'll take mandy moore.

Fez defiled her though.

 

[jaydawg]

Despite all her problems, Lohan has some semblance of talent. Duff cant act, she sure as hell cant act and isnt even hot. And shes dating that guy from Good Charlotte. If that doesn't say loser, I dont know what does.

 

[PhotoJones]

Despite all her problems, Lohan has some semblance of talent. Duff cant act, she sure as hell cant act and isnt even hot. And shes dating that guy from Good Charlotte. If that doesn't say loser, I dont know what does.

please tell me...when has lohan ever displayed "some semblance of talent"?

 

[Mr. Smash'n Bash]

I put my money on Mr. T

 

[Manic]

Lohan is a former child actress who's pretty much never done a serious movie. Up until recently, she's basically been one of Disney's little go-to b****es. Now that's she's finished that horrid comedy "Just My Luck," she has a series of dramas and romance films coming up. We're about to find out whether or not she really does have talent.

 

[fu manchu]

Who's better? Depends. Let me compare the two:

Look wise: I would pick Lindsay. Although, they are both pretty, I still think Hilary looks like she is still 16 years old. Plus, I see some really sexy photos of Lindsay more than Hilary.

Acting: I would pick Lindsay. I just don't like any movie with Duff in.

Singing: Although, they both suck, I would give the edge to Duff. Her songs just seem to grow on me. Lindsay's song are forgettable.

Personality: From what I heard about in the tabloids about Lindsay, Duff is the choice here.

So, for me, its a tie.

 

[jaydawg]

please tell me...when has lohan ever displayed "some semblance of talent"?

She was pretty good in Mean Girls, Prarie Home and yes, The Parent Trap. Lohan can act, its just that she either picks a pay check or Disney has her under contract. And the fact that shes a probably a mean spirted ***** in real life.

 

[PhotoJones]

She was pretty good in Mean Girls, Prarie Home and yes, The Parent Trap. Lohan can act, its just that she either picks a pay check or Disney has her under contract. And the fact that shes a probably a mean spirted ***** in real life.

mean girls was a good movie, but not because of her. you could replaced her with anyone, and it wouldn't have made a difference.

i haven't seen a praire home companion yet, but i'm guessing it's the same deal with mean girls.

as for parent trap, i'll give you that one. she was good, but that's probably because she was a cute little girl at the time, and that's all the role really demanded. i do remember her british accent being pretty good, if i'm not mistaken, though...

 

[dpm07]

Lindsay is attractive and so is Hilary. That said, Lindsay has waaaay more baggage. Hilary has also lost a lot of baby fat which made her cute, but now having lost that excess I find her more attractive.

I do still think Mandy Moore trumps all of them in terms of looks and personality. I met her once at a fund raiser, and can say she is genuinely nice, and very pretty. She really does come off as the type you'd want to take home to meet the 'rents.

 

[heypapajinx]

is this a joke?!!
as a hater of ALL teenie boppers everywhere that make it famous and rich i can CLEARLY state that Hilary is the winner.
and that is saying a lot that i ACTUALLY like her.
although i don't like that she has finally given into the pressure to lose weight, i think that she is by far the overall better person.
now Amanda Bynes.
she takes the cake.

 

[Neptune]

Linday has the potential to be way hotter. When she still had red hair and meat on her bones she was gorgeous. Hilary is also badly underfed but even with meat on her bones she just looks like a weird 13 year old girl.

 

[Kritish]

Lindsay used to be the definition of jail bait before she went skank on us. Hilary still looks good. So I'm going with Hilary.

 

[04nbod]

classiness- Duff
acting- lohan
singing- lohan released one song in the UK that bombed duff has released a few and i like her 'fly' song- so Duff