As for how Id have done Mandarin,its quite simple-
1. Kingsley Mandarin wld have been the real Mandarin.
2. Kingsley Mandarin would have been a super-soldier who ingested Extremis-
thus making him a SUPER-Extremis soldier.
That could have been awesome, but where would the Super Soldier serum have come from that would have allowed Kingsley's Mandarin to become this SUPER-Extremis soldier versus just the standard Extremis Soldier? Also, while a cool idea my only concern would be that I wouldn't want it to seem like every Marvel character out there has the Super Soldier Serum as it kind of takes away from Cap being special. As it stands currently there are already 3 people (Captain America, Red Skull and Abominatation).
Personally, I liked the idea of the twist and I thought it was clever, but I just wish they could have come up with a way to better honor the embodiment of the Mandarin character then what we got.
To me I see the embodiment of a character as breaking down into 4 parts and this holds true to some degree even in real life, although it may not be equal parts, but for the purpose of this post we will consider all 4 equal.
Look - 25% - It is the first sign of somebody being who they are, I mean in life we cut our hair, change our clothes, but there are certain facial features that will always identify us to others. Now with comics facial detail at that level of identifying characters is very difficult. Don't get me wrong they try with different color hair, different lengths of hair, different style facial hair, different shaped faces, but there is only so much they can do to identify someone's face when they have thousands of characters. Therefore, in the comics the costumes and or clothing play an essential role of identifying characters as being who they say they are. This is not to suggest that artists don't mix it up and draw different renditions of a character, because they do, but readers looking at this new version of the character for the first time might take some getting use to it to accept it.
Attributes - 25% - What you can do in life helps define you. If you are able to type 100 words a minute, and then all of a sudden stopped being able to do so people wouldn't necessarilly question who you are if you looked like yourself, but if you stopped being able to do everything you normally are able to do some people might start looking at you oddly or wondering if you are okay, because you don't seem like yourself. As with the look category comics accentuate characters attributes and break them down into a series of skills and powers to define them. If a character in the comic does not possess the same skills or powers you are use to seeing them with, then you might also be left feeling like they are not themselves.
History - 25% - A person's actions, choices and what they have done or gone through in the past reflects greatly on who they are as an individual and it is generally these experiences we use as a basis for making decisions moving forward. For example with Spiderman you have the whole "with Great Strength comes great responsibility" line, it's a moment in this characters life that changes everything for him and it all of a sudden becomes clear to him the hero he needs to be.
Psyche - 25% - I see this as being a series of qualities and traits that one possesses (in part by experiences) and it is generally a reflection of who they truly are deep down inside as a person, and it is often shown through the form of their personality, but not always as one can act the part, which actually says as much about who they are as anything. While this may be the truest form of a person or character it is also the most difficult to show, because people are layered like an onion and complicated, so it can be hard getting to the core of what makes someone tick. Also, it is the characters Psyche and History that will generally decide the motive or direction of the person or character. A great example in the comics would be Loki, he always has an angle and he just loves making mischief plain and simple. His character just lives for it.
So that is how I see the embodiment of a person or character. Now with that said this is how I would rate Iron Man 3's interpretation of the Mandarin[BLACKOUT] (2 versions)[/BLACKOUT] out of a possible 25% in each category.
[BLACKOUT]Trevor Slattery as Mandarin
Look - 20 out of 25 - I am giving him this because I felt they did a very good job of translating his look from the comics while trying to avoid racial overtones. However, there is part of me that would have still prefered the more comic accurate interpretation of his look, but of course I say this while meaning to offend no one.
Attributes - 0 out of 25 - Didn't have any.
History - 0 out of 25 - There was none.
Psyche - 0 out of 25 - No motives here, except for drinking and women.
Total score - 20 out of a possible 100
NOTE: This version would have been dramatically raised in the history and psyche area if they didn't put in the twist, but they did so..... [/BLACKOUT]
[BLACKOUT]Killian as Mandarin
Look - 5 out of a possible 100 - I am giving him this because of the dragon tattoo and the comic picture that shows him shirtless and wearing pants was similar to the movie.
Attributes - 5 out of a possible 100 - I am giving him this because he did have powers in the movie, although I didn't feel they were remotely similar to his powers in the comics.
History - 15 out of a possible 100 - I am giving him this because despite the history being a lot different from the comics, I did like the fact that they suggested he was responsible for everything that happened back in Iron Man 1 and 2.
Psyche - 20 out of a possible 100 - I am giving him this because I thought his personality was great, highly intellectual and does lots of strategizing to take out his targets. I would have given him a 25%, but I felt like he spent to much time worrying about his appearance.
Total Score - 45 out of a possible 100 [/BLACKOUT]
So far with the exception of the Mandarin I would rate all of the other Marvel Cinematic Universe Heroes and main Villians with total scores of somewhere between 70 and 90. I realize much of this is interpretation on my part, but still I feel I need to say, in my opinion this was not a very good start for Phase 2 (at least in terms of translating a villian to the big screen).
To me the movie was excellent in many ways, but the villian use was disastourous. I apologize to those of you listening to me, who liked what Marvel did with the character, I am really still just venting.
and I'm done! Lol
Surfer