The Official DC Comics Recommendation Thread

Lobo

Cap 2.14.25
Joined
Jul 16, 2002
Messages
38,215
Reaction score
1,976
Points
103
I did a search and couldn't find one, so I made this thread. If one already exists a mod can merge this.

So go ahead and recommend your favorite books and trades. What are your must reads?

Personally I'm a big fan of

Superman Unchained
Superman Grounded
Superman Earth One
Batwomam Hydrology
Batwoman Elegy
The Power of Shazam by Jerry Ordway
Supergirl Woman of Tomorrow
Superman Birthright
Teen Titans the Terror of Trigon
Kingdom Come

There's a start. Obviously I like JMS Superman. I only read the first Earth One, though. I'll add more later.
 
Last edited:
JSA: The Golden Age. One of the ABSOLUTE best Justice Society stories ever told. More specifically, it's one of the best Paul Kirk Manhunter stories. The twist is one of the best things about it, to me atleast. It's Prime James Robinson writing with absolutely sumptuous artwork by Paul Smith. It's a book incredibly endearing to the subject matter, and for me, does more for the JSA than Johns did.

Starman. James Robinson's masterwork. It's a lightning in a bottle series that DC has rarely ever been able to recapture. Like with The Golden Age, it piles on respect for those characters of old while celebrating better than any book barring the Flash the legacy aspect of DC's characters. Jack Knight is such a great character. A true working man's hero with so much personality. Seriously, the nuances Robinson imbues Jack with is a rarity in superhero comics. I've always considered this book a superhero reconstruction story. Robinson breaks down what a hero is and gradually rebuilds, and dare I say, rehabilitates the concept. It's such a great book and I'm happy that DC released the whole series across two compendiums after being out of print for so long.

Sandman Mystery Theatre. Matt Wagner, Guy Davis, and Steven T. Seagle telling profoundly lurid pulp stories about the Golden Age Sandman? You can't go wrong. The artwork is brilliant. The stories themselves reflect the world's seedy underbelly, all it's vices and sins, right back in its face to pretty astounding results. If you read and enjoyed (or even didn't) the recent Wesley Dodds: Sandman mini series, Sandman Mystery Theatre is all that and more, and a thousand times better.

Jonah Hex vol. 2. Jimmy Palmiotti and Justin Gray with a rotating stable of some of the medium's best artists telling done-in-one Western comics with the best Western hero of them all. It's 70 issues, along with a graphic novel and another 35 issues under the All-Star Western title during the New52. I'm in the middle of re-reading the whole series, and I gotta say: this run never misses. The stories range from typical revenge stories, grittier Spaghetti Western style rampages, and some moving romances. We get art from the likes of Luke Ross, Jordi Bernet, Moritat, and Daryn Cooke amongst others. Well worth the deep dive.

Hawkworld. Timothy Truman writes and illustrates this supremely intelligent and a-typical reboot of the Katar Hall Hawkman. I loved it almost immediately. The story's politics go pretty hard and feel relevant even today. The artwork is a masterclass in storytelling. The story is pretty moving. This book really joins the ranks of fellow 80s reboot stories like Batman: Year One, Blackhawk and The Long Bow Hunters as a story that feels like anything but a superhero comic. By breaking free of those shackles, it becomes so much more and so much better. Nerds will get up in arms about what it, and the subsequent ongoing that stemmed out of this book, did to continuity. Put those people on mute. The ongoing is just as good, and just as intelligent as the mini series, because John Ostrander is a great writer and Graham Nolan is a great artist.

This last one goes without saying: Alan Moore's Swamp Thing. 45 issues of pure brilliance. For the first year and a half that Moore is on that book, he, Bissette, Totleben and Veitch are firing on cylinders the medium has never seen since. I own this run in floppy, TPB, HC and absolute. It's my favorite comic book run of all time.
 
JSA Golden Age is so great.

Anywho. Without any further delay, My list:

Superman:

Up in the Sky
Warworld
For the Man Who Has Everything
Emporer Joker
Superman Smashes the Klan
Superman & Lois by Jurgens


Batman:

Birth, Bride & Son of the Demon
Strange Apparitions
Night of the Stalker
Where were You the Night the Caped Crusader Died?
Joker’s Five Way Revenge

Batgirl: Year One

JL:
Tower of Babel
Darkseid War
Forever Evil

Swamp Thing:
Anatomy Lesson
Len Wein’s original run

Kirby’s Fourth World, specifically Mister Miracle 1-15, Forever People and New Gods


Action Comics 419, 420 for the first appearances of Christopher Chance/The Human Target by Len Wein

Richard Dragon: Kung Fu Fighter by Denny O’Neil. (A guilty pleasure of mine)

Green Lantern/Green Arrow: Hard Traveling Heroes
 
Last edited:
Agreed on Golden Age it's fantastic.

Nice lists guys :)

I want to add for Wonder Woman:

The Hiketeia
Perez Wonder Woman
Rucka's :ww:

Justice League The Nail
 
Last edited:
Superman: American Alien
Superman: Birthright
Superman: Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow?
The Death of Superman

Batman: Year One
Batman: The Long Halloween
The Dark Knight Returns

Green Lantern: Secret Origin
Green Lantern: Sinestro Corp War
Green Lantern: Blackest Night
Green Lantern: Emerald Dawn
Green Lantern: Emerald Twilight
Green Lantern: Rebirth

The Flash: Rebirth

Justice League: New Frontier

Watchmen
 
How did I forget one of the best reads I’ve had in the past year?

The Flash:
The Return of Barry Allen
 
I'll second Superman: American Alien. I was sorting through comics I was looking to sell off and I found this in one of my boxes and re-read it. Needless to say, I'll be keeping that one. One of the best Superman stories of all time.

@Karelia, The Return of Barry Allen is one of THE best Flash stories. Waid's whole run is the poster child for classic style superhero comics, but that arc especially (and maybe the Dark Flash Saga) is quintessential Flash.
 
The Return of Barry Allen is perfection. It’s great for someone like me who is a big Wally West fan. Max Mercury is great in it as well.
 
What are some good Nu52 Superman trades?
 
What are the best books currently?
 
What are the best books currently?

Tbh, Jeremy Adam's Green Lantern has been solid. Gail Simone just took over on Action Comics, I thought the first issue was good. Joshua Williamson's Action Comics before it were really solid. Not currently enjoying Chip Zdarksy's Batman. I'm not sure what characters you fancy, but I have heard Green Arrow has been great lately.

Also, the recent "The Penguin" comic has received some praise.
 
Tbh, Jeremy Adam's Green Lantern has been solid. Gail Simone just took over on Action Comics, I thought the first issue was good. Joshua Williamson's Action Comics before it were really solid. Not currently enjoying Chip Zdarksy's Batman. I'm not sure what characters you fancy, but I have heard Green Arrow has been great lately.

Also, the recent "The Penguin" comic has received some praise.

Thanks. Superman is my favorite fictional character over all.

I'm also a big fan of in no particular order

Green Arrow so I'll check that out
Wonder Woman
Nightwing
Zatanna
Huntress
Green Lantern but I mostly like Kyle
The rest of the Super family
Fourth World characters

It's been awhile so I'm trying to get back into it. Sold my collection a few years ago.
 
Thanks. Superman is my favorite fictional character over all.

I'm also a big fan of in no particular order

Green Arrow so I'll check that out
Wonder Woman
Nightwing
Zatanna
Huntress
Green Lantern but I mostly like Kyle
The rest of the Super family
Fourth World characters

It's been awhile so I'm trying to get back into it. Sold my collection a few years ago.

Have you read any of Tom Taylor's Nightwing? He's actually about to finish his run with the character (the last issue may have came out this week.) It's another pretty well received run. I just started reading the final arc, it's been good but not as great as I hoped.

Green Lantern actually has brought in Kyle a few issues back, I think he's going to end up playing a big part in fixing whats going on with the emotional spectrum. They also introduced a new spectrum (Sorrow Lanterns, haha.) I have my theories on that one. But it's been a fun read!

I think there is a Zatanna series currently releasing, but I haven't checked it out.
 
Thanks. I've not read Taylor's Nightwing. I think I might be aware of it though. Is it the one with Heartless where Dick is framed and Bruce dons the costume?

Thanks for the heads up on GL and Kyle. Uh... Sorrow Lanterns :huh:
 
Thanks. I've not read Taylor's Nightwing. I think I might be aware of it though. Is it the one with Heartless where Dick is framed and Bruce dons the costume?

Thanks for the heads up on GL and Kyle. Uh... Sorrow Lanterns :huh:

The Emotional Spectrum is out of wack. If I had to guess, that's why I think the Sorrow Lantern has become a thing. I wouldn't be surprised if more pop up before Kyle brings balance to the emotional spectrum haha.
 
The Emotional Spectrum is out of wack. If I had to guess, that's why I think the Sorrow Lantern has become a thing. I wouldn't be surprised if more pop up before Kyle brings balance to the emotional spectrum haha.
Thanks. I'll keep an eye out for these.
 
What are the best books currently?
Currently Currently? Im not sure, ive been laying low quite a bit with the Absolute Power event.
The stuff i mostly read is Detective Comics from Ram V which is still so incredible, and The Penguin comic.

Most of the other books currently are part of the big Absolute Power Event.
Before that, oh boy could i recommend pretty much everything.

The Superman Books on all corners are fun, the Batman and Batfamily books have been great.
The New Frontier books Era is absolutely full of great books.

It comes down to what your a fan of.
For Superman fans the Era is fantastic, Batfamily fans get a lot of good things, Shazam is fun, Green Lantern, The Flash.
The Wonder Woman book under Tom King is good.

Im bad at keeping track but i think i said it in the DC comics Thread a ton of time how the New Frontier Era is the Era in which i bought the most variety of DC Comics...ever.
 
The best current comics are Zdarsky’s Batman and Taylor’s Nightwing for me. Taylor’s Nightwing has been absolutely sensational. Zdarsky’s Batman started out with a bang in the Failsafe arc, then lost its footing a bit before ending the Zur en Arr arc really strong.

I’ve enjoyed Williamson’s Superman run, but it’s not close to an all time great run. PKJ’s run on Action from a couple years back, however, was amazing. And if you haven’t read Warworld Saga, you really need to. It’s one of my all time favorite Superman stories.

Mark Waid has been great (as expected) in his return and his World’s Finest was great for its first year or so, even if it has been a bit pedestrian since he took on the challenge of trying to write a Kingdom Come prequel in it. Waid also started The Last Days of Lex Luthor and put out the first issue, but hasn’t had another one come out for months. Whenever that drops, it is a must buy as the first issue is amazing.

Finally, it concluded, but I cannot recommend Williamson’s Robin comic enough. It was a limited series featuring Damian Wayne in a Bloodsport-esque fighting tournament to the death. And it was so much fun. It was the surprise hit for me.

I’d also recommend Batgirls, which also concluded its run, but was loads of fun as well.

Now if only we can get Absolute Power concluded and get some of these books back on track…
 
Thanks. Superman is my favorite fictional character over all.

I'm also a big fan of in no particular order


Fourth World characters
Do you prefer Kirby or Morison take on Fourth World?
 
Do you prefer Kirby or Morison take on Fourth World?
From what I've seen we have pretty similar tastes so recommend some Morrison stuff. I've read Kirby New Gods, Forever Peope and The Hunger Dogs

Mr Miracle is my favorite New God and I loved Walt Simonson's Orion series.

Edit

Last week I ordered a mystery Superman comic grab bag that comes with 30 comics for 10 bucks. The package arrived this morning. It came right before work this morning. Can't wait to see what's in there.
 
From what I've seen we have pretty similar tastes so recommend some Morrison stuff. I've read Kirby New Gods, Forever Peope and The Hunger Dogs

Mr Miracle is my favorite New God and I loved Walt Simonson's Orion series.

Edit

Last week I ordered a mystery Superman comic grab bag that comes with 30 comics for 10 bucks. The package arrived this morning. It came right before work this morning. Can't wait to see what's in there.
I’m a Kirby man, through and through. I love Mister Miracle, Forever People, Newsboy Legion and Kirby’s Fourth World when it comes to New Gods.

Morrison did all right with Final Crisis. But it’s not my favorite take on Fourth World.

If you are a fan of Kirby and of Superman, there is a story that I read in my son’s Kamandi: The Last Boy omnibus which was really great. Kamandi comes across a group of sentient apes in the post apocalyptic world who have found Superman’s cape and use it as an object of worship. They refer to Superman (who it is implied is dead by the time the story takes place) as “The Mighty One” and they build a religion around his cape and the hope that he will come back and restore order in their world one day. It’s a pretty cool read in the classic Kirby, Bronze Age style.
 
Last edited:
Definitely prefer Kirby

Final Crisis wasn't my favorite. Found it okay, though.

That Kamamdi story sounds interesting.
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"