The Official Spider-Man 3 Critics Reviews Thread

[The Caped Knight]

This thread is only for movie critics reviews on the film SPIDER-MAN 3. Please posted the link of the source and if it from The newspaper, post the news article if possible .

First up

review from TOKYO (Reuters) newspaper

"Spider-Man 3" shows soul-searching superhero
By Sophie Hardach
Mon Apr 16, 2007 8:26am ET163

Even superheroes get the blues, as "Spider-Man" discovers in this latest sequel during which he confronts a mutant made of sand, a vengeful former friend and, ultimately, himself.

"Spider-Man 3" is packed with stunning special effects such as the crumbling, morphing Sandman and an evil black suit with a life of its own that brings out a person's dark side, but the characters also show a complexity rarely seen in action movies.

In the sequel, Peter Parker, played by Tobey Maguire, is finally enjoying life with the beautiful Mary Jane Watson, played by Kirsten Dunst, when he discovers a mysterious suit that enhances his power, but stirs hidden feelings of bitterness and revenge.


The ensuing battle between good and evil, revenge and forgiveness, is played out in airborne superhero fights as well as more mundane rows with friends and colleagues.

"To see Spider-Man cry so much was different," said Gerry Penacoli, a critic for Extra entertainment magazine, after seeing the "Spider-Man" preview in Tokyo ahead of the evening premiere.

"It's more intense -- you still have great action but certainly it's the deepest of the three. Kids and adults will learn so much more from this than from a movie that's just wham-shezam," he added.

The special effects were also a reminder of the production cost of slightly more than $250 million, making the movie a huge financial gamble for Sony Corp.'s Columbia Pictures.

The gamble paid off for "Spider-Man" and "Spider-Man 2", which grossed $822 million and $783 million, respectively.

While sequels tend to do less well than the original movie, "Spider-Man 3" could draw new fans with its sophisticated plot.

Launching the sequel in Japan, home to a huge community of superhero comic fans, rather than the United States is also seen as a shrewd push into the faster-growing international market that could help box-office revenues.

SCREAMING TEENS

Dunst, dressed in a floating pink chiffon gown, and Maguire were greeted with screams of "kawaii" ("cute") by hundreds of young Japanese at an open-air fan event before the premiere.

Fans braved cold weather and rain to listen to Maguire describe what he called "the darker side of Peter Parker" at the futuristic Roppongi Hills complex, where the movie was shown.

Maguire also named Tokyo as one of the few cities in the world that was suited to "Spider-Man" -- a reference to the superhero's habit of swinging from skyscraper to skyscraper, weaving webs between towering buildings.

"If we do a fourth movie, we might need Spider-Man to come to Tokyo," he said, prompting another round of enthusiastic screams.

In a clever marketing move, Sony announced during the event that the launch date would be shifted forward to May 1 in Japan, the second-biggest "Spider-Man" market after the United States.

The movie debuts globally on May 4. The movie's makers travel to London on April 23 and then Rome, Berlin, Madrid, Moscow, Stockholm and New York.

Initial reaction from Japanese viewers was positive.

"It's better than 'Spider-Man 2'. He's more human, there's more tension between Peter Parker and his Spider-Man character," said Kumiko Hayashida, a critic who writes for entertainment Web sites.

"The story is better, more psychological. And Japanese people like animation, so they like this story because of the comic."

"Spider-Man" originated as a comic book hero and Marvel Entertainment Inc. holds the rights to the character.

"Japanese women and girls like the male characters in comics and superhero films because they are cool and strong, and men feel that way too because they identify," said Yuki, a 20-year-old who shivered as she waited for Maguire's appearance.

Scenes such as Parker and Watson lying on a giant spider's web, watching the stars, are likely to please fans of "Spider-Man's" romantic side -- and yes, there is a reference to the hero's signature upside-down kiss as he dangles from a thread.

And if "Spider-Man 3" is a success, will there be another sequel? Maguire has not commented on whether he would slip into the Spider-Man costume a fourth time, but critics did their own guesswork after the preview.

"I can't believe they'll leave it at that, it's left wide open for another one," said movie critic Penacoli.




RETURNS

 

[CrashNburn]

great thread and great news. Thanks Kal-el 8!

 

[spiderguy89]

yah!!!...wide open for another one!

 

[Immortalfire]

Be forewarned, this could end up merged into an all out Spidey 3 review thread.

 

[Brown]

Spider-Man III Review from AintItCool.com

*****WARNING CONTAINS SPOILERS********** - i started to read them then had to look away, lol.

Hi Harry, big fan of AICN, so you’re the only one I’m going to share this with. If you want to post it you can, but I have to stress with you that I CAN NOT under any circumstances tell you how I saw this movie but let me tell you, it was almost as bad as going through airport security, I will say one thing. I was able to catch the movie in Japan, where it is currently being prepped for its premier on the 16th, cant say anymore and if that hurts my credibility then it is unfortunately a risk I have to take. Just read what I have to say, and when the movie rolls around, you will see that I was indeed telling you the truth, and that I wrote the first review of a little film a lot of people are excited about called SPIDER-MAN 3.

So I can’t say that I have ever really written a full review before, so I’m going to try and just type whatever comes into my head. By the way, I’m an avid Spider-man fan and the 2nd film is among my favorites, so keep that in mind while reading.

A BRIEF RUNDOWN: Main titles begin, same flipping marvel logo, same brilliant Elfman theme (this time composed by Chris Young, but more on that later). No Alex Ross paintings, but there is some great CGI which focuses a lot on black webs, which is a hint at things to come, the composition of the titles is similar to that of the first movie, as opposed to the second. So at this point the film has just begun and already I feel like I’m visiting an old and treasured friend for the first time in 3 years. I can’t really describe how ecstatic I was at this point. The first shot of the movie is footage from spider-man’s final swing in Spider-Man 2, at least I’m pretty sure it was, we here a voice over from Peter, more of the same, but this time he notes how things are finally going his way, and the camera zooms out and we see Peter and a group of kids watching the clip of Spidey swinging on a big screen suspended over the streets of New York. The first 20 minutes is basically that, just the viewer watching Peter, and its so odd to see things going right for him, it’s a good feeling, but thankfully it doesn’t last. We are introduced to Sandman early on, and ironically he’s the biggest surprise in the movie, he is being played off as the typical thug who kills in the movies promotion but he is very similar to Doc Ock actually, he’s a family man who I believe is a good man at heart, and he has a great scene with Cliff Robertson, his character teaches Peter that the past is the past, and if he really is going to be a hero, he has to be able to forgive someone who has done a wrong, and that revenge will do nothing but make things more painful.

We are also introduced to Harry’s sub plot as well and let me tell you; it’s great, and also focuses on revenge, this time on Peter (the movies main theme is revenge if you havent guessed). Wilem Dafoe returns for more hallucinogenic fun and Harry’s scenes were among my favourite in the new movie. I really don’t want to go into the actual plot because I don’t want to spoil anyone, but the second act is basically Peter’s fall and the third act is the redemption of both Peter and Harry. 2 major characters die at the end of this one, one good and slightly expected, and one that I didn’t expect to bite it at all, so it was an actual shock to see it happen, I think it might piss off some fans but now that I think about it, I dont know how it could have ended differently. It’s a long film, it’s 2 and a half hours give or take, so there’s no doubt that this film is very much more epic than the first 2. There are 7 major action scenes however they are all additions to the core plot, and like the second film they are all bonus as opposed to the main event:

1. Harry vs. Peter
2. Peter vs. giant crane (you will get it when you see the movie)
3. Peter vs Sandman
4. Peter vs Sandman in the subway.
5. Peter vs Harry rematch
6. Birth of venom (debatable as an action scene, more just kick ass)
7. A 4 way battle on a construction site which guarantees this film a special effects Oscar.

So what did I think? Here are some views on the different aspects of the film.

Symbiote: This was great because it arrives right in time to finish Peters ascent into arrogance, it’s very symbolic to show what Peter is turning into and it is an addition to the character as opposed to a 2 dimensional plot device, which is great because I had some fears that the whole black suit would be a tacked on subplot like the cure was in X-Men 3, and it’s not. This is a good time to point out that a lot of people have been saying that this film is overstuffed, but it really isn’t. It never loses its focus and deals with one plot thread at a time, and the long running time gives everything breathing room, and at the end when all the plot threads tie up, it’s a great feeling.

Brock: Topher Grace portrays the Brock from the ultimate universe in terms of personality, but his background is more along the lines of 616, so I guess it’s the best of both worlds, but Grace plays him wonderfully, and he is a great addition.

Gwen: Now this is perfect casting, every time Gwen is on screen its bliss (which isnt all that much unfortunately). Such an amazing character being handled with such grace. She has both purpose in Peter’s life and Spider-man’s life, so she is not tacked on in any way, however I must say
she is underused, which is my only real complaint with the film. The unspoken hostility between her and M.J is so subtle but both actresses really pull it off well..which brings me too..

Mary Jane: This isn’t the M.J of the first film, and by the end of this film she’s lost a bit of her sweet touch that made her so lovable in the 2nd film, and it is Peter’s fault, but the last scene really ties up the Peter and M.J thread very nicely, and we know they will be happy. For the first half of the film, Dunst plays M.J the same way she did in 2, and it’s a beautiful performance. She goes through more **** in this one, her play gets a bad review and she is pretty much restricted to singing in a Jazz club, and Peter doesnt make things much better, and uses Gwen in a pretty assholish way against her. M.J does get captured in the end but it adds to the tension of the final battle so it's all good.

Peter: We saw him make the choice to honor that with great power comes great responsibility in the first film, and in the second film he learned that he didn’t have to face it alone, and the third film is very much about Peter learning to keep a balance of both worlds, and he realizes by the end that it is not enough to simply swing in tights each night and save someone, its about keeping those that he loves happy, as well as being a role model to a city that really does need him, it is a hard lesson but Peter learns it in the end, and Tobey plays him even better than in 2.

Venom: I’ll leave him a surprise but don’t worry, I don’t think anyone will be disappointed with this bit, big thanks to Raimi for including him, if there is a 4 its hard to say if venom will be the villain, he’s pretty much “dealt with”.

I already gave my thoughts on sandman so that leaves

Harry: His is the best plot line in the movie his arc is Shakespearian in nature and by the end of this film he really proves that he is not his father, and in the end he puts everything on the line to save his friends, you will love how it turns out, very emotional.

The score of the film by Chris Young is more of the same; he basically rehashes Elfman’s themes, and makes new themes for new characters. His new themes are good, and Sandman’s in particular is quite catchy and similar to Ocks, but they probably are not as good as if Elfman had done them, but the score doesn’t disappoint if you liked it the first 2 times around.

Raimi has proven himself a spider god thrice over now, and really I want this film to be the last one. It ends every major plot line and doesn’t leave much open, albeit it doesn’t really zip things shut either, but really this is a great ending. This is the most emotional, and epic entry in the series, and like its predecessors, it never loses sight that action is a bonus to the character drama, and not the main attraction, it really is amazing.

I loved this film and I think critics will too, and it will probably be the fan favorite as well, don’t worry guys; Raimi hasn’t let us down yet.

My scores for all three movies:

Spider-Man: 8/10
Spider-Man 2: 9/10
Spider-Man 3: 9.5/10

That’s right folks 3 is my favorite, the trilogy curse is broken at last and we finally have a complete vision of a comic book character, which was yet to be done until now.

My hat is off to the whole crew for giving us this gift of a trilogy.



We were also sent a link from a Chinese website where they have their own first review up now, and they translated it for us so you can see what they ahd to say about it as well:

Hi there! This is Adam from moviesoon.com, one film fan news site in China. We love AICN a lot! And now, here's a world exclusive review for "Spider-man 3" from an inside man.

You know, according to the film importing policy in China, all the foreign films must be sent in to local distributing partners and the State Administration of Films for censorship a few weeks before releasing in China. Especially thanks to this honest guy working for local distributor of Sony Pictures, we got a chance to take a glimpse at one of the biggest blockbuster in this summer, even earlier than world premiere in Tokyo on April 16.

Keen and I've translated main ideas of the review into English in order to share something in that you guys may be interested. Anyway, if you don't like spoilers, please do ignore it.

"Spider-man 3" is no doubt another visual feast, even more brilliant than the second film. You know, more characters and scenes, more challenges. They make Sandman really incredible, which must be one of the most difficult parts in my thought. Hit as a man, flow as sand. The final two-vs.-two fight is absolutely huge. (We'll talk about it later.) You'll find it almost impossible to catch up with all the fantastic scenes.

I've no ideas whether you care about Gwen Stacy. However, she didn't seem to be a very important role in the film, even a little unnecessary. I think most of us won't go to "Spider-man 3"for love stories. Forget it. Remember J. Jonah Jameson? We don't like him very much as he seeks nothing but profits and carries a personal vendetta against Spider-Man. You'll LOVE him this time 'cause he is the guy making you laugh…with his severe wife.

Here's five major action scenes:

1, Spider-man vs. New Goblin

Yea, we have seen most of it in the 7-minute preview clips. But here's what happens next: Harry Osborn fell in a faint, and suffered from a short-term memory loss (temporarily forgot what happened between Peter Parker and his father). He and Peter became friends again.

2, Spider-man vs. Sandman

Sandman escaped from prison for saving his daughter from serious illness. The police chased and forced him into a laboratory where he turned into Sandman later. And he encountered Spider-man when trying to rob a cash truck. They fought for the first time in the truck. Sandman fled at last.

3, Black Spider-man vs. Sandman

The symbiote from outer space crashed down to earth with a meteoroid. It attached itself to Peter Parker as we saw in the trailers. The new black Spider-man was much more powerful than ever before. And he fought against Sandman in an underground tunnel as taking revenge for his uncle. Definitely, Spider-man was the winner, but Sandman was flushed away and survived fortunately.

4, Black Spider-man vs. New Goblin

The shadow of Harry's father still lingered on and reminded him to revenge, which restored his memory. He made mischief between Peter and his girl, and Peter was badly hurt. But it was not that easy to defeat Black Spider-man. New Goblin failed again, and half of his face got disfigured.

5, Spider-man + New Goblin vs. Venom + Sandman

Yea, that's the final fight. We know, Venom a.k.a. Eddie Brock was a journalist. He once made fake news and got exposed by Spider-man. Losing his job and his girl who fell in loved with Spider-man; he blamed Spider-Man for ruining his life. He went to a church to pray that God could help him with getting rid of Spider-man. At the same time, Peter was trying to tear his black costume at the top of the church bell-tower. Intense sonic was lethal to the symbiote that Peter got the creature separated from himself when the bell rang. Unfortunately, it got a new host soon - Eddie Brock. The merger became Venom.

Venom and Sandman then united. They kidnapped Spider-man's girlfriend, and beat Spider-man with absolute superiority. As Spider-man was dying, Harry got stung by conscience and turned to stand by Spider-man. Then the battle became two-vs.-two. At last, Spider-man [SPOILERS DELETED BY AICN -- I MEAN, COME ON, I AM PLANNING TO SEE IT IN A FEW WEEKS!]. It's a happy ending, sorts of.

"Spider-man 3" must be the best visual action blockbuster ever and outdo all its predecessors. It is really rare to see a better sequel these days, right?

"Spider-man 3" is going to hit big screens in China on May 2th.

That's all. Thanks a lot! Hope you like our news tips, guys! Pleaaaaaaase keep in touch!

 

[The Caped Knight]

Be forewarned, this could end up merged into an all out Spidey 3 review thread.

If you could, Could you do that now and sticky it at the top of this forum and save us the trouble later . Immortal ?

If so I'd be very greatfull .

 

[Secret_Riddle]

I like that review alot, very promising.

 

[Spider-ManHero12]

the reviews have gotten me even more excited to see this film and the fact that AICN said this movie will teach us a lesson is very good no doubt.

 

[Cristo]

Come on! This already premiered!

There has to be more reviews than that!

 

[DyeLorean]

I loved this film and I think critics will too, and it will probably be the fan favorite as well, don’t worry guys; Raimi hasn’t let us down yet.

My scores for all three movies:

Spider-Man: 8/10
Spider-Man 2: 9/10
Spider-Man 3: 9.5/10

That’s right folks 3 is my favorite, the trilogy curse is broken at last and we finally have a complete vision of a comic book character, which was yet to be done until now.

My hat is off to the whole crew for giving us this gift of a trilogy.

That's it, I can't wait anymore. I need a time machine NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

D!

 

[Secret_Riddle]

Im also very excited, but after waiting 3 years, through immence anticipation, and many late nights waiting for trailers and such, now that the film is among us, and the word is that it is great, and it has an awesom running time...why does it all feel anticlimatic?

Anyone else feel the same way?

I almost think i dont want the movie to actually get here because then all the anticipation will be done and we will enter a 3 year + wait for the next one.

 

[pjspider1C]

Im also very excited, but after waiting 3 years, through immence anticipation, and many late nights waiting for trailers and such, now that the film is among us, and the word is that it is great, and it has an awesom running time...why does it all feel anticlimatic?

Anyone else feel the same way?

I almost think i dont want the movie to actually get here because then all the anticipation will be done and we will enter a 3 year + wait for the next one.

I kinda felt the same way shortly before Spider-man 2 came out. A couple weeks before it's release, I was just kinda like... eh, whatever. And then I saw the movie - which made me feel tons, tons better! I do not expect Spider-Man 3 to be a let down by any means whatsoever. We're reaching the peak of the anticipation, and the end of the wait is within sight - and it's going to be well worth it!

 

[The Guardian]

SUP GUYS, THIS SOUNDS AWESOME, I CAN'T WAIT!!!

 

[Cinemaman]

Great news

 

[McVenom]

it says venom is "dealt with" maybe that means he only goes to jail or somethong

 

[Secret_Riddle]

i think he was just beating around the bush so he didnt spoil venoms ending...but yah Im pretty sure he was one of the 2 characters that dies..

 

[SLYspyder]

yeah, i think this should be marged withe the AICN review thread

 

[batman11]

Im also very excited, but after waiting 3 years, through immence anticipation, and many late nights waiting for trailers and such, now that the film is among us, and the word is that it is great, and it has an awesom running time...why does it all feel anticlimatic?

Anyone else feel the same way?

I almost think i dont want the movie to actually get here because then all the anticipation will be done and we will enter a 3 year + wait for the next one.

I somewhat feel the same way. Its like there is so much hype building up towards the film, what do we done when it comes out? Its not like I'm not excited anymore, its just I'm over EXCITED! Its taking over my life, and I won't know what to do after its "over". lol t:

 

[Secret_Riddle]

Yah, im almost dreading not anticipating it anymore. and it feels like everything is slowly coming into place, great reviews so far, great running time...it all seems perfect, and its the first time this has really happened with a superhero movie so its all sort of surreal.

 

[The Caped Knight]

I somewhat feel the same way. Its like there is so much hype building up towards the film, what do we done when it comes out? Its not like I'm not excited anymore, its just I'm over EXCITED! Its taking over my life, and I won't know what to do after its "over". lol
t:

I Do Start the Countdown until the release of The Dvd for SPIDER-MAN 3 . t:

I know i'm going to do that for sure .

 

[CAH]

All the reviews sound great...can't wait.

CAH

 

[TheCaretaker]

I somewhat feel the same way. Its like there is so much hype building up towards the film, what do we done when it comes out? Its not like I'm not excited anymore, its just I'm over EXCITED! Its taking over my life, and I won't know what to do after its "over". lol t:

when its over see it again again and again multiple times haha, i know i am.

 

[Spider-ManHero12]

when its over see it again again and again multiple times haha, i know i am.

me to, I will see it 5 or 6 time's. I will also be anticipating the DVD release of Spidey3 like Kal-El 8 is.

 

[batman11]

I Do Start the Countdown until the release of The Dvd for SPIDER-MAN 3 . t:

I know i'm going to do that for sure .

when its over see it again again and again multiple times haha, i know i am.

me to, I will see it 5 or 6 time's. I will also be anticipating the DVD release of Spidey3 like Kal-El 8 is.

Yeah, I'll see it many, MANY times too. And yeah, I agree with what you guys are saying, but it just won't be the same...the anticipation and all.

 

[MarvelXI]

I´m sure that Gerry Penacoli in his reviws said that the ending lets open a fourth movie someon ecan post it???