Days of Future Past The Ranking the X-Men movies thread

[Mutant 77]

According to the general consensus:

1- DOFP (previews, tweets and early reviews)
2- X2
3- FIRST CLASS
4- X1 or X-Men: The Last Stand (not as hated as you think, I like it)
5- The Wolverine
6- X-Men Origins: Wolverine (regarded as the worst)



http://x-continuity.blogspot.com

 

[psylockolussus]

I say wait until the movie officially comes out and once we get a critics consensus from Rotten Tomatoes.

 

[lofoa82]

Going by the hype and so... I´d say...

1- X-Men: Days Of Future Past
2- X2: X-Men United
3- X-Men: First Class
4- X-Men
5- The Wolverine (the final act was too much damage for the film, since it was going on a great direction)
6- X-Men: The Last Stand (I liked it... but waaay below the ones above)
7- X-Men Origins: Wolverine (I blame Jackman, Shuller-Donner for not raising their voice on what was being produced)

 

[lofoa82]

This thread should be a poll... It´s an interesting one.

 

[darkcajld]

I'm not going to include DOFP as I didn't see it so it's strange to include something just basing on hype.

So ...

1. X2 (great directing ... script ... loved it because some characters had a little to more development than in first one and the story was nicely paced)
2. The Last Stand (no comment)
3. The Wolverine (I must say I wanted to put Origins in this place but this one was pure ''I only can remember Wolverine in it'' movie with every single character that was non Wolverine was so forgettable ... Strange reason I know) / X1 (good movie and good introduction but not that great mostly because some great characters were a backup to Wolverine and this movie is called X-men not Wolverine and X-men)
4. First Class (well written movie but ... the villain was meh ... choices for backup characters were meh ... and the biggest sin : January Joneses acting ... just pure awfulness ... comparing to her acting Origins was a masterpiece tbh)
5. Origins (I mean I like it like I love TLS but still the biggest sin was that it was crowded with too many great characters that shouldn't be there as this was Wolverine movie .... that's why I loved The Wolverine as all those backup characters were there to back up and were honestly forgettable as it should be when you have a star of the movie that should leave the biggest impression on someone who is watching it ... strange logic I know)

 

[Sexy Magician]

I am gonna rank the first movie when they reboot X-Men,
I really hate what they have done with the X-Men movies, loved X1 and X2 but everything since just didn't cut it for me, first class was a decent movie but just makes no sense time wise and DOFP looks like it makes even less sense time wise, we had Emma Frost in origins as a teenager which also featured a teenage Cyclops, so I can only assume this film takes place 80's/90's, but then we have an adult Emma in First Class which is in the 60's, origins also had a young quicksilver but DOFP set in the 70's has an older looking Quicksilver, there are more I can add.

I just really want a reboot. A reboot without Wolverine I might add.

 

[BlackFox]

I guess I disagree with the general consensus, hehe

 

[Mutant 77]

I guess I disagree with the general consensus, hehe

Me too.

My NON-general consensus ranking:

1- DOFP (I'm sure, hopefully)
2- FIRST CLASS
3- X2
4- X3
5- X1
6- ORIGINS

Not watched The Wolverine yet

 

[hoy-small-fry]

I imagine post-DOFP mine will be

1) DOFP
2) X2: X-Men Uni---- nope, X2
3) X-Men: First Class
4) X-Men
5) The Wolverine
6) X-Men: The Last Stand


100) X-Men: Origins

 

[Lord]

Stop ranking DoFP so high before it's even released, that brings bad luck

 

[hoy-small-fry]

We're number 1! We're number 1! We're number 1!

 

[Lord]

We're number 1! We're number 1! We're number 1!

That's what The Amazing Spider-Man 2 said

 

[hoy-small-fry]

That's what The Amazing Spider-Man 2 said

No, that film always looked bad

 

[Lord]

No, that film always looked bad

It did, but it still had various fans talking about it as if it was the second coming

 

[marvelrobbins]

I always had concerns on ASM2. So the final film wasn't a shock to me.

I have always thought DOFP would be good and trailers,clips,and twitter reaction are proving me right. Just like first trailer said to me winter soldier would be better than
Iron Man 3 and thor The dark world.

 

[Lord]

Iron Man 3 was great though. I also have some worries about DoFP, but Bryan Singer behind X-Men usually gives me many hopes.

 

[TeeKay]

Why are people ranking DOFP before even seeing it?

Anyways, here's my list for now:

1) X-2
2) First Class
3) The Wolverine
4)X-1
5) X-3
6) X-Men: Origins

 

[The Batman]

1. First Class
2. X2
3. X-Men
4. The Wolverine
Very distant 5. Last Stand
Very distance 6. X-Men Origins: Wolverine

 

[BoredGuy]

yeah ranking the movie so high prematurely is asking to be let down by it

for me
1- X2
2- X-Men
3- The Wolverine
4- First Class
5- X3
6- XO:W

 

[def28]

First Class
The Wolverine
X2
X3
X1
X-Men Origins

 

[BlackFox]

Yeah not even tempting fate with DOFP without seeing it, karma and all that but going in this is my list of X:

1. The Wolverine
2. X2
3. X1
4. First Class
5. X3
6. XO:Wolverine

 

[Figs]

I still can't decide which film should take the #1 spot. X2 or First Class.

After those two, I would rank the others like this.

3. The Wolverine
4. X-men
5. X-men: The Last Stand
6. XO: Wolverine

 

[henzINNIT]

yeah ranking the movie so high prematurely is asking to be let down by it

for me
1- X2
2- X-Men
3- The Wolverine
4- First Class
5- X3
6- XO:W

This is my order too.

 

[Weather Witch]

I still can't decide which film should take the #1 spot. X2 or First Class.

After those two, I would rank the others like this.

3. The Wolverine
4. X-men
5. X-men: The Last Stand
6. XO: Wolverine

Same for me.

 

[kedrell]

x2>xmfc>x1>tw>xmtls>xmow