• Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.

the serious potential of robin and batgirl

rainingcrow

Civilian
Joined
Feb 17, 2009
Messages
212
Reaction score
0
Points
11
the concept of robin and batgirl in the nolan universe isnt seen as a positive note... but if they considered it, what about the serious potential?
 
Last edited:
btw I know this is a can of worms, but that is the idea, lots of discussion
 
ok well this discussion started over on deviantart, and I'll start by posting what was there.
a_movie_we_will_never_see_pt1_by_rainingcrow.jpg
 
Derrick9592 8 hours 51 minutes ago Hide Report Spam
A Batman and Robin remake!
biggrin.gif
Lol
Reply
~rainingcrow 4 hours 33 seconds ago Hide it could potentially work if done right. the chemistry and premise need to be closer to the way the cartoon "the batman" portrays robin and batgirl... basically meaning that at the beginning of their "hero" careers, batgirl should be no older than 16 and robin should not exceed 15, these characters are supposed to start young and grow up doing this essentialy... no chris o donnells or alicia silverstones.

and in my opinion, if they ever did robin... bruce needs to adopt him around 7, and he shouldnt even know bruces secret until like 10, and become "robin" only after at least four years of training... And the relationship between him and bruce needs to be very clearly a father son type of relationship not a buddy partner thing.(hence the very teen design of robins costume, implementing colors and stylized differences from bruces... batman is like his dad... have you ever tried to get a teenager to wear what you wanted them too?)

batgirl, should have attitude, so basically i see her this way. Her old man is the police commisioner. Shes lived in a city where her family has been abducted, and threatened, her dad has been targeted and the streets arent safe at night. She thinks batman has the right idea. She's fed up, and is going to do something about it wether its acceptable or not.

Barbara gordon as batgirl shouldnt start out as this full fledged sidekick figure, she's a stand alone crusader with strong motives and actions. She simply used the batman as inspiration because she saw that it worked. She gets her own supplies, she creates her own suit, and shows tremendous inginuity.

when she goes out at night its sneaking out a bedroom window with no back up to call... eventually bruce feels he has to accept her pressence and work with her because she is as devoted as he is, and will not give up or back down. So he figures at least if he works with her, it will make things less dangerous.
Reply
~rainingcrow 3 hours 53 minutes ago Hide actually I think batgirl should kinda have her own movie, that eventually leads to a tie in with batman...

and ideally the dick grayson storyline would have to be spread out over like three movies for him to become robin... I think that the development of bruce basically becoming a father and how that leads to him appenticing robin would have to be explored properly.
Reply
~Derrick9592 1 hour 45 minutes ago Hide Report Spam I like it and you do have a point. As long as they don't make it too corny as the early Schmacher Batman movies.
Reply
~rainingcrow 1 hour 19 minutes ago Hide oh yeah those sucked balls
Reply



~michiganj24 7 hours 8 minutes ago Hide Report Spam No offense to you but I really hope its never made because I like Nolan on the films and he said if they ever put Robin in the films he walks as it so does not fit his vibe
Reply
~rainingcrow 4 hours 17 minutes ago Hide whic is exactly why it will never be made... bale said he would walk if they did robin too
Reply
~michiganj24 3 hours 50 minutes ago Hide Report Spam And quite frankly I agree. the best Batman stuff has been the darker stuff and robin immediately makes everything lighter. Burton did wonders as Gothic Schumacher sucked with glitz then Nolan went dark again and we love
Reply
~rainingcrow 3 hours 30 minutes ago Hide a robin storyline could be dark honestly... just treat his training and growth simmilar to bruces, except he has a mentor who stands by him.

the emotions and depth that a robin storyline could potentiall bring are something that most creators in previous film incarnations have chosen not to explore. Imagine if you will; Bruce adopts dick basically because he cant help it... he looks at him giving his report in the police station... he sees him talking to gordon, and he sees himself. he remembers the feelings... but when he first adopts him, robin dosent speak... he's a 7 yr old kid who's scared and angry and mute. Him and bruce kind of co exist in the same world, but neither one of them knows how to deal with his being there... but he comes home from school with a black eye... through bruce teaching him how to defend himself, they connect. The bond grows over the years and the self defense classes have now become training, ***** sadness has now become anger... and bruce finds himself dealing with a young teenager before he knows it.

what happens in a father son relationship when the son decides he wants to put himself in harms way? As he grows and matures, eventually knowing bruce is batman...he wants in. He has legitimate arguments, and while bruce never saw it before he essentially has molded his protege... and now robin is ready to be born.

treat it simmilar to what happens in second generation cops, or multigenerational military families.

and during all of this emotional story and struggle you have the issues of bruce beginning to have someone else he has to take care of. A reason he can't let himself get killed or hurt. He has a personal stake in keeping the streets safe again but he also has to balance this openess with his secracy. He puts dick to bed with a story about knights in shining armor, and then goes downstairs and puts on his own.

A great way that this could be worked into the action is what happens when one of batmans villains takes a schoolbus hostage, with dick inside.

I also think dick and barbara should meet at school early off. she should be about four years older than him, and a little protective and sympathetic... eventually they could form a kind of brother sister bond before either of them even know what the other has been up to.
 
My fear is that Christopher Nolan may try to stop that once he starts filming his third Batman film.
 
Would be interesting to see batgirl and robin in the nolan series, he would probably so much them much better then what joel S did in batman forever and batman & robin. But we know we are likely not ever going to see them again in a batman movie untill nolan's series is over since he wants his bats to be a loner hero.
 
alot of people have said that nolan will probaly stop the series after the third flick and I could see that happening, but warner brothers would really wanna push it if the money was good...



Personally I would think it would be awesome to start a new batman live action tv show. It would have to be recast of course (hey it worked for sg1) But set the same type of seriousness and tone as say... the new battlestar galactica. (as opposed to smallville or something)





NO campyiness, no designed toward tweens smallville or buffy stuff, just imagine a full on totally serious drama action tv show one hour a week based off the dark knight...





it's kind of unprecedented. BSG is the best comparison I can even begin to think of.



anyway, that would be the perfect venue to take this type of approach with both robin and batgirl.



We all pretty much realize it'll never happen, but it's still really fun to talk and dream.
 
i doubt wb would ever want to do a live action show since they see the character being more a film series then tv series. plus it would be a pretty expensive show to produce.
 
Personally, I'd rather have no sidekicks at all in the DC movies with the exception of Wally West. Leave Robin, Speedy, Batgirl, Supergirl, Superboy, Wonder Girl, Aqualad, and Aquagirl in the comics and TV shows.
 
Robin's backstory has what I like to call 'risky' potiential. On the one hand, provided the arc is handled with expert care, it can show a great degree of strong character development on both Dick and Bruce's part. On the other hand....we could get Batman Forever again.
 
yeah it would have to be handled appropriately... and alot of people would potentially screw it up royally, but sidekicks have real potential in a movie atmosphere, they have just been mishandled for sooooo long that re-imaging the general perception would be tough.

I mean the mention or concept is just so immediately bashed and discarded because usually they just equal bait, bad jokes, or complete tools.

but on the mention of a tv show budget... omg WB could afford a bigger budget than BSG and that show is downright amazing on effects and action!
 
turn batgirl into a three picture deal, and have her grow up throughout them... the only problem would be that by the end of a second one, her and batman would have to actually be working together... and I dont see that happening.
 
a batgirl spinoff movie could be good too though

turn batgirl into a three picture deal, and have her grow up throughout them... the only problem would be that by the end of a second one, her and batman would have to actually be working together... and I dont see that happening.

Didn't work for Supergirl back in the day. I can't see Batgirl doing much better. Most people just look at them as side-characters.
 
thats why it would be neccesary to change the perception.

she has the potential to be extremely badass. I mean even after she got shot through the spine she went on to become oracle. And even in her wheelchair she has still continued to kick ass.
 
I remember awhile ago hearing that if they did robin they would just skip robin and use the name nightwing. I feel like if they did use robin i'd want to see him turn to nightwing
 
The best potential Dick Grayson has is in a live action, weekly hour long series titled "Nightwing". All you need to do is establish the Batman backstory in the pilot and open the show with Dick moving to Bludhaven, joining the police force, and becoming Nightwing. Seriously, if done right, it would work.
 
I don't see Robin or Batgirl working in the Nolan universe. Though, I can totally see Nightwing as someone who is inspired by Batman & is actually good at fighting.
 
I'm telling ya, a gritty Nightwing series is the way to go. Nightwing, or Wally West as The Flash, have the best potential for 5-7 season television shows.

Like I said, lay out the backstory in the pilot and have Dick set up shop in Bludhaven as both a cop and Nightwing.
 
didnt Nolan already say "no" to Robin?

Robin and Batgirl in their own movie, like a Teen Titans flick or a Gotham centric The Outsiders group would most likely work. and truthfully, if they're gonna use Robin, they might as well use Nightwing as well.
 
Didn't work for Supergirl back in the day. I can't see Batgirl doing much better. Most people just look at them as side-characters.


It didn't work because the movie wasn't the best quality. Doesn't mean Supergirl and Batgirl aren't viable options, put them in a movie together! They are 2 of DC's most used trademarks. If a little girl gets supergirl PJ's would she not want to see a Supergirl movie? Same with Batgirl. And Robin. Any superhero movie that is taken seriously, has good promotion, has a good script and a good budget will do well. Just look at stuff like Watchmen, everyone is excited about that and they are nobodies, do you think half the people who will go and see it know the source material or cares? I'd say Batgirl and friends already have have something invaluble...recognisability.

I actually think Wonder Girl would be invaluable to a Wonder Woman movie. WW whole thing is sisterhood between women and how power shared between women is power gained. Supergirl and Batgirl have never been sidekicks like the robin, aqualad, speedy or kid flash mostly because boys wanted to read about boys, the girls got separate stories where superman or batman would sometimes feature. Wouldn't fight together that much though. Superman and supergirl would usually play with the pets or she would get a superman related problem to fix without superman really being there and of course there were the legion stories.
 
Last edited:
Personally, I'd like to leave Robin and Batgirl back with Schumacher and let them be done with now, but I do think Robin deserves a film of his own in the form of something like the fanfilm Grayson. The one where its set not so far in the future, Dick's married to Barbara, Bruce dies on the job and Dick puts the suit back on to get revenge. That'd make a good film I reckon. Funny when he squares up to Superman as well :yay:
 
It didn't work because the movie wasn't the best quality. Doesn't mean Supergirl and Batgirl aren't viable options, put them in a movie together! They are 2 of DC's most used trademarks. If a little girl gets supergirl PJ's would she not want to see a Supergirl movie? Same with Batgirl. And Robin. Any superhero movie that is taken seriously, has good promotion, has a good script and a good budget will do well. Just look at stuff like Watchmen, everyone is excited about that and they are nobodies, do you think half the people who will go and see it know the source material or cares? I'd say Batgirl and friends already have have something invaluble...recognisability.
Exactly if the Dark Knight and Iron Man taught us anything it's about quality. These characters have been around for decades they are loved and well developed especially the batman villians and sidekicks. I would love to see Robin added. Don't worry about Nolan I think he'll be done after 3 Bale too. I would like to do it like rainingcrow said a slow progression. Let people not see robin all they see is a hurt kid named Dick Grayson that Bruce is trying to help let them care about him first then it won't matter if you make him into Robin or not people would be cheering for it.

Oh and RC you should write a script I know it could work I would even help you if you wanted.
 
I hope Nolan realizes if ANYONE ever brings a serious Robin/Batgirl to film it will be him.
Those who come after won't have the balls
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"