Comics The SSH Spider-Man Comicbook Awards 2006

[Dangerous]

Well its that time of year again.
2006 is almost over and we can now evaluate nearly the entire years worth of published Spider-man comics! Fun huh?
You can wait till you have December’s issues, or you can jump in right now.


Best Writer ?

Best Pencils ?

Best Inks ?

Best Colours ?

Best Arc ?

Best Cover ?

Best Single Issue ?


Best Fight ?

Best Supporting Cast Member ?

Villain of the Year ?

Best Spider-title ?


Worst Writer ?

Worst Pencils ?

Worst Arc ?

Worst Cover ?

Worst Spider-title ?

 

[shinlyle]

Best Writer: Roberto Aguire-Sacasa

Best Pencils: Mark Bagley

Best Inks: Art Thirbert (is he still inking USM?)

Best Colours: Clayton Crane

Best Arc: The Deadly Foes of Peter Parker

Best Single Issue: I (heart) Marvel: Web of Romance

Best Cover: Sensational Spider-Man #23


Best Fight: Spider-Man vs. Stegron (yeah, it's the only one he actually won)

Best Supporting Cast Member: Mary Jane

Villain of the Year: Iron Man

Best Spider-title: Sensational Spider-Man


Worst Writer: JMS

Worst Pencils: Ron Garney

Worst Arc: Mr. Parker Goes to Washington

Worst Cover: Amazing Spider-Man #531

Worst Spider-title: Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man

 

[CConn]

Best Writer: Roberto Aguire-Sacasa

Best Pencils: Mike Wieringo

Best Inks: Karl Kesel

Best Colors: Clayton Crane

Best Arc: Feral

Best Cover: Sensational Spider-Man #31

Best Single Issue: Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #5


Best Fight: Spider-Man vs. Stegron

Best Supporting Cast Member: Black Cat

Villain of the Year: Iron Man

Best Spider-title: Sensational Spider-Man


Worst Writer: JMS

Worst Pencils: Ron Garney

Worst Arc: Mr. Parker Goes to Washington

Worst Cover: Amazing Spider-Man #529

Worst Spider-title: Amazing Spider-Man

 

[gliderpilotgirl]

Best Writer ? Aguire-Sarcassa. Honestly, he gets my vote entirely based on the fact he used Liz and Normie..wow an actual supporting cast. And the stories have been top notch. Normally I'd vote Bendis, but USM has been a slow slump ever since Warriors, even with the Clone Saga.

Best Pencils ? Bagley, hands down.

Best Inks ? John Dell, other than USM 97. Some of the earlier 2006 stuff like Silver Sable and the early Deadpool was beautiful.

Best Colours ? The people who do USM.

Best Arc ? Deadly Foes of Peter Parker. USM lost my vote entirely because of the end of USM 101, or the Clone Saga would have been a shoe-in.

Best Cover ? Sensational 32. Absolutely Amazing.
Best Single Issue ? USM 97. Perfect Drama/Fighting ratio.


Best Fight ? Tarantula vs Kaine.

Best Supporting Cast Member ? MJ.

Villain of the Year ? The guy behind the USM clone Saga. ( unrevealed so far ) He has messed up Peter's life supremely.

Best Spider-title ? Sensational.


Worst Writer ? JMS.

Worst Pencils ? Garney.

Worst Arc ? USM Deadpool.

Worst Cover ? Any ASM cover.

Worst Spider-title ? ASM.

 

[Kirk Langstrom]

oooh i LOVE these things!

Best Writer: Sacasa
Best Pencils: Bags
Best Inks: Kesel
Best Colors: Crane
Best Arc: Deadly Foes
Best Cover:SSM #23
Best Single Issue: FNSM #5
Best Fight: Spidey vs Cap
Best Supporting: Aunt May
Villain Of The Year: Chameleon
Best Title: Sensational
Worst Writer: PAD
Worst Pencils: No Opinion
Worst Arc: Uncle Ben Returns
Worst Cover: No Opinion
Worst Title: FNSM

 

[Citizen_Kaine]

Best Writer: Aguire-Sarcassa.

Best Pencils: Bagley

Best Inks: Sal Buscema

Best Arc: "If Death Be My Destiny" Spider-Girl/"Clone Saga" USM

Best Cover: ASM 535

Best Single Issue: "My Science Teacher is Spider-Man" Sensational 28

Best Fight: Jumping the gun here, but probably ASM 536. Spider-Man vs Iron Man

Best Supporting Cast Member: Peter Parker, The Invincible Iron Man's Poodle

Villain of the Year: Iron Hitler

Best Spider-title: Ultimate Spider-Man

Worst Writer: JMS

Worst Pencils: Pat Lee

Worst Arc: Spider-Man THE ARTRAD

Worst Cover: Marvel Knights 21 (What the bloody **** is that!?)

Worst Spider-title: FNSM

 

[Kraven]

Best Writer ? Roberto Aguire-Sacasa

Best Pencils ? Mark Bagley, but I did also like how Todd Nauck drew his stuff in his FNSM arc.

Best Inks ? Karl Kesel

Best Colours ? Clayton Crain

Best Arc ? "The Clone Saga" in Ultimate Spider-Man

Best Cover ? Sensational Spider-Man #23

Best Single Issue ? Sensational Spider-Man #28

Best Fight ? Sensational Spider-Man #28, Spidey vs. Doc Ock

Best Supporting Cast Member ? Aunt May

Villain of the Year ? Not sure on this one, but if we're going actual villain (not Iron Man ) then I might say Mysterio or Chameleon.

Best Spider-title ? Sensational Spider-Man

Worst Writer ? No comment

Worst Pencils ? Pat Lee

Worst Arc ? Jumping the Tracks, from FNSM

Worst Cover ? Amazing Spider-Man #531. This is the one where he's eating popcorn right?

Worst Spider-title ? On the whole, FNSM has been a let down, but the last arc was great.

 

[The Schweitz]

Best Writer ? Roberto Aguire-Sacasa

Best Pencils ? Mark Bagley

Best Inks ? John Dell

Best Colours ? Clayton Crane

Best Arc ? Clone Saga USM

Best Cover ? USM 100

Best Single Issue ? My Teacher is Spider-Man


Best Fight ? Probably Spidey Vs. Iron Man

Best Supporting Cast Member ? MJ

Villain of the Year ? Iron Man

Best Spider-title ? USM


Worst Writer ? Peter David

Worst Pencils ? Garney

Worst Arc ? Everything in Civil War

Worst Cover ? Civil War #2 resolicit with Spidey unmasked.

Worst Spider-title ? Friendly Neighborood

 

[Norman Osborn]

Best Writer ?

Bendis (so shoot me)

Best Pencils ?

Bagley

Best Inks ?

Meh

Best Colours ?

Meh

Best Arc ?

USM Clone Saga

Best Cover ?

Be right back...gotta check SAmruby
Sensational Spiderman 23 Feral Part 1

Best Single Issue ?

The one shot with Doc Ock....Peter Parker is my teacher or something like that

Best Fight ?

None come to mind....against Cap I guess

Best Supporting Cast Member ?

MJ In the Ultimate Universe

Villain of the Year ?

None come to mind....Iron Man considered a villain?

Best Spider-title ?

USM by a landslide


Worst Writer ?

JMS refer to landslide above.....although Peter David has given us the wrestling man, a female time travelling Gobby and a psycho Ben Parker so he's closing in.....


Worst Pencils ?

meh


Worst Arc ?

Dumbest arc = jumping the tracks,

Worst Cover ?


The feral cover when he's looking in the Lizard's mouth....can't remember the #

Worst Spider-title ?

ASM followed very closely by FNSM

 

[Venomfan]

im shocked nobody has said "The Other" for worst arc

 

[Kraven]

Well, the bulk of that arc did take place towards the end of 2005 really...

 

[Omega214]

Best Writer ? Brain Michael Bendis

Best Pencils ?Mark Bagley

Best Inks ? Art Thirbet

Best Colours ? Clayton Crain

Best Arc ? Current civil war arc

Best Cover ? USM 100 Variant

Best Single Issue ? USM 100


Best Fight ? dont know

Best Supporting Cast Member ? Ultimate aunt may

Villain of the Year ? iron man

Best Spider-title ?USM


Worst Writer ? peter david

Worst Pencils ? -

Worst Arc ? ult. morbius

Worst Cover ? civil war 2

Worst Spider-title ? The Other

 

[The-Arachnoid]

Hmm, I going to look bk through my issues then Il let ya know.

 

[Electro UK]

Best Writer ? Hmm not sure, I guess (shock horror) that I'm with JMS this year. (Get's in running position) Waitwaitwait, lemme explain myself. I've personally loved ASM ever since Pete's been unmasked. Don't get me wrong, I'm 100% AGAINST the unmasking, but I think Spider-man's aspect on CW has made it the best CW side title.

Best Pencils ? Wieringo without a doubt. I LOVE his classicy Spidey look. The ASM artist's been good but I've really gonna off Medina past few SSM issues

Best Arc ? The ASM CW arc. Been loving it even with the horrors of the unmasking

Best Cover ? SSM 23 (or which ever issue Feral started)

Best Single Issue ? I liked that single issue straight after the unmasking where Pete fought Ock in SSM, that's probably gotta get it. Unless Cable and Deadpool 24 counts.

Best Fight ? Spider-man vs Deadpool, Cable and Deadpool 24. More of a scruffle, but still bloody great. Shame Spider-man vs Electro in SSM lately wasn't too hot.

Best Supporting Cast Member ? Mary-Jane... yes just because of that panel with her in the shower in the last Road to Civil War issue

Villain of the Year ? Been a bad year for villains, they've been scarce so I guess I have to go with Quinten Beck's return

Best Spider-title ? ASM

Worst Writer ? Peter David. Issue 5 has been the only enjoyable FNSM issue so far. Mysterio's arc was RUINED in the last few pages by Ms. Arrow and the Uncle Ben crap is more damage done to Spidey than JMS has ever done imo.

Worst Pencils ? Medina. I've gone waaaaaaaaaay off it since Feral, just plain ugly to me now.

Worst Arc ? Hobgoblin 2211. Worst. Arc. Ever. Evil alternate Uncle Bens, boring future characters no one cares about and Iron Spidey suit.

Worst Cover ? Latest SSM by Crain with Pete on the front, just meh.

Worst Spider-title ? FNSM without a doubt. PAD can't end an arc without ruining it atm.

 

[The Bruce]

Seeing this really makes my realise what a crap year this has been for Spidey

 

[Venomfan]

Best Supporting Cast Member ? Mary-Jane... yes just because of that panel with her in the shower in the last Road to Civil War issue

this should probably be scanned and posted for all to see

 

[CConn]

Worst Writer ? Peter David. Issue 5 has been the only enjoyable FNSM issue so far. Mysterio's arc was RUINED in the last few pages by Ms. Arrow and the Uncle Ben crap is more damage done to Spidey than JMS has ever done imo.

How is it worse than what JMS has done? I mean, The whole Uncle Ben this was an alternative universe story. It's not like it affected absolutely anything in Spider-Man's 616 world. Unlike turning Gwen Stacy into a ****, unlike turning Peter into a mutated Spider-God.

 

[Electro UK]

How is it worse than what JMS has done? I mean, The whole Uncle Ben this was an alternative universe story. It's not like it affected absolutely anything in Spider-Man's 616 world. Unlike turning Gwen Stacy into a ****, unlike turning Peter into a mutated Spider-God.

That was all LAST year dude.

I'm putting PAD down because I haven't ended one his arcs without cringing yet.

Wrestling- Well just wtf? Who the hell wanted to read a story where a Wrestler tries to kill Spider-man?

Hobby- A bad arc turned even worse by the ******ed "oMGf!!11 Evl Oncle Be lOL!!!1111" ending. I haven't read anything worse than those final couple of pages in the history of Spider-man

Mysterio- Was going pretty smoothly, until The Other came back into it (either that or Ms Arrow is Marrow) and made me almost eat the comic.

Meanwhile THIS year, JMS is slowly getting back on form imo. ASM has gradually getting back from the lowly state it was in at the start of this year, sure there are bad things about the book still (unmasking and Iron spidey) but JMS is not to blame for either of those, so I don't think he deserve's 2006's Worst writer.

 

[CConn]

Dude, you specifically said PAD did more damage with Alt. Uncle Ben than JMS "ever has".

That's what I was addressing, not why you think PAD's the worst writer this year.

 

[Norman Osborn]

im shocked nobody has said "The Other" for worst arc

I did....in 2005

 

[Electro UK]

Dude, you specifically said PAD did more damage with Alt. Uncle Ben than JMS "ever has".

That's what I was addressing, not why you think PAD's the worst writer this year.

Oh right, sorry... now I'm embarresed.

I guess it was because the whole incident of those final pages was coffee spitting out bad. JMS's stuff has always been Ugh... why? to me, this is WTF!?!?! That's ridicuolous. It did damage to Spidey because I beleieve Ben being back, Alt or nay is the worst sin you can commit to Spidey.

 

[fangrl06]

Best Writer: Brian M. Bendis

 

[Kevin]

i'll wait

 

[Doc Destruction]

Best Writer: Brian M. Bendis

For me to poop on.

 

[Kevin]

Okay, guys, If I'm correct, all of the spidey titles are either done or just about done for the year of 2006. I don't know about you, but I think we can ALL get our vote on now.