The Dark Knight Rises The TDKR General Discussion Thread - - - - - - Part 138

[georgec]

Every one of your posts I see is always argumentative and confrontational. Why you mad, guy?

I ain't mad. I just disagree with some of the complaints. Because I seem to be a minority on these discussions, I stand out. I haven't shown anger in my posts.

Sigh...

 

[Reek]

Every one of your posts I see is always argumentative and confrontational. Why you mad, guy?

Good question, some how I got thrown into a group of people I have zero to do with

 

[KalMart]

well thats where the food issue comes in... i mean its the dead of winter... probably not getting grade A food... no hygiene. realistically, there would be sickness, starvation, and its not like they are down there working out in the gym.

lol were there even any female cops??? and with all those people, I'm sure they could have dug themselves out or found a sewer lid somewhere in that huge circle of rubble

How many of them had full beards by the time the big fight came?

 

[Reek]

How many of them had full beards by the time the big fight came?

the male cops or lady cops?

 

[DoomsdayApex]

well thats where the food issue comes in... i mean its the dead of winter... probably not getting grade A food... no hygiene. realistically, there would be sickness, starvation, and its not like they are down there working out in the gym.

lol were there even any female cops??? and with all those people, I'm sure they could have dug themselves out or found a sewer lid somewhere in that huge circle of rubble

Nolan could've likely explain all these illogical 'holes' but then we would had fanboys stating that Nolan was being too literal, on-the-nose and overly-complex again.

 

[KalMart]

the male cops or lady cops?

How hilarious would that be?


Hell hath no fury like a woman bearded.

 

[Reek]

I don't really care bout it... but it just doesn't seem like Nolan had any hand in the film lol ... there is too many 'uh really?' moments...

Its like when Michael Jordan tried playing baseball

 

[KalMart]

Nolan could've likely explain all these illogical 'holes' but then we would had fanboys stating that Nolan was being too literal, on-the-nose and overly-complex again.

Or just another soliloquy by one of the sergeants or the like

 

[Reek]

How hilarious would that be?


Hell hath no fury like a woman bearded.

but seriously, were there really NO female cops? other than Selina and Miranda, i don't recall seeing any females except as maids.

 

[KalMart]

We've been down here so long, even the women have grown beards!

 

[DoomsdayApex]

Or just another soliloquy by one of the sergeants or the like

 

[venus_ice]

Nolan could've likely explain all these illogical 'holes' but then we would had fanboys stating that Nolan was being too literal, on-the-nose and overly-complex again.

Bingo. Just look at how some people reacted to Inception. Nolan can't win this battle either way.

Whatever, I'm not looking too deep into this film any longer. Headaches

 

[rashad]

I'll be taking my mom to see this next week! My sister saw it with me opening night and loved it as well.

 

[The Guard]

Whew, wrong comparison to make. Gangs of New York was Rated-R, and what made the war scenes memorable was the gore and brutality that went into them.

Yes, but what made THAT work was the build up and the execution of it.

This movie just kind of thrust the idea of cops VS Bane’s mercenaries running at each other into the film. There was no decent buildup, no strategy…it was just really poorly handled for being a climactic element.

lol were there even any female cops??? and with all those people, I'm sure they could have dug themselves out or found a sewer lid somewhere in that huge circle of rubble

The female cops were the first to go.

Nolan could've likely explain all these illogical 'holes' but then we would had fanboys stating that Nolan was being too literal, on-the-nose and overly-complex again

Eh.

Half the “logic” issues aren’t even logic issues. They’re issues of pure stupidity.

"Let's send all the cops underground at once!"

 

[DoomsdayApex]

Bingo. Just look at how some people reacted to Inception. Nolan can't win this battle either way.

Whatever, I'm not looking too deep into this film any longer. Headaches

Yep, Nolan can never win.

Nolan left more up to imagination (and was a bit more subtle in his execution with various scenes this go-around) but now people want to dissect his 'errors'.

*shrugs*

 

[Reek]

Guard, are you being serious or did I miss something with the female cops

 

[Reek]

Yep, Nolan can never win.

Nolan left more up to imagination (and was a bit more subtle in his execution with various scenes this go-around) but now people want to dissect his 'errors'.

*shrugs*

hey you were the one wanting to go into detail

 

[Deserana]

I don't really care bout it... but it just doesn't seem like Nolan had any hand in the film lol ... there is too many 'uh really?' moments...

Its like when Michael Jordan tried playing baseball

Gotta slightly agree with this.

I NEVER thought I'd se the day when a Nolan film included the line "Get the president on the line". There is epic. Then there is Michael Bay.

The last battle was also underwhelming. I mean the whole final battle and not just Bane/Batman.

 

[KalMart]

Man...imagine how much it had to suck for the cops that had families at home that worried so much while they were trapped for five months...then as soon as they get out, they're one of the ones that gets shot.

 

[The Guard]

Guard, are you being serious or did I miss something with the female cops

Nope. Joking.

Apparently there just weren't any.

 

[Reek]

Man...imagine how much it had to suck for the cops that had families at home that worried so much while they were trapped for five months...then as soon as they get out, they're one of the ones that gets shot.

at least there is no grooming or clothes changing necessary for the funeral.

 

[Reek]

Nope. Joking.

Apparently there just weren't any.

I dont think any females were in banes army either... so if you are a female, you are either catwoman, miranda, or one of Waynes maids.

wow.

 

[KalMart]

Nope. Joking.

Apparently there just weren't any.

There were.




But they got eaten.

 

[The Guard]

Or used up by the League of Shadows. Or Bane.

He used to have sex with women and then kill them in the comics. Maybe that's what happened.

This glaring oversight is really just Nolan being subtle about comic book source material.

 

[kvz5]

There were women at the dance ball. And then there's that random chick that entered the stock exchange that made you think she was someone important and then that other one that Bane smacked.