Welp, I've seen it. Can't say I loved it, can't say I hated it.
I really, honestly dug a lot the world-building. There really are a lot of cool ideas in there. The way concepts like immortality and reincarnation play into the story in a "believable", pseudo-sciencey sort of way is really clever . The world definitely feels like it came from the same minds of the guys who hatched The Matrix universe and it feels good to see those minds playing in a new sandbox.
Acting-wise, Tatum and Bean kind of saved the movie for me. I enjoyed them together. And yes, air-skating Tatum is quite the sight to behold, lol. Kunis..nothing against her, but idk...something about her in the lead made the movie hard to take seriously at times. And you know what, when I thought about it, I'm sure plenty of people could be the same thing about Keanu and The Matrix. My girlfriend can't into The Matrix because she just can't take Keanu seriously as an actor, and for years I've always been like, "But...but...it's
The Matrix!!" Now, in a weird way I think I sort of get it. Just like Neo in the first movie, Jupiter is something of a vessel character who goes around kind of confused, blankly asking question after question before finally taking a more active role in the story in the third act. So as much as I wanted to criticize the writing of Jupiter and Kunis' performance, I realize that anything you could level against that could easily be leveled against Keanu/Neo in the first Matrix...so....idk. Redmayne, certainly hammy and campy, but I didn't mind it too much. If you've seen the trailers, you've basically seen the performance, minus the odd bit of shouting. You really can't help but hate his character, so it served the story.
I don't think this is paced as well as the first Matrix, and it lacks that great moment of catharsis that might've taken it to greater heights. Visually, at times it's stunning. The Wachowskis definitely still know how to do action. However, there was a little bit too much of it for my taste and I felt myself getting a bit restless towards the end. By the time the credits rolled I just felt kind of frustrated, because it wraps up in such a typical "origin story" way, and there's the sense that there's a well thought-out universe here that could go in some interesting places and we'll never see it.
Also, I know this is sacreligious to a lot of people, but I find Giacchino overrated and not the second coming of John Williams that a lot of people hype him as. Wasn't too impressed with his score. I miss Don Davis.
Overall, 7/10. Glad the Wachowskis tried something original again. I'd watch it again and re-evaluate that because it's fairly dense, though I think density + a lot of weirdness and goofy elements doomed this from ever having a real chance to succeed. Hopefully they land on their feet.