I think it was repetition without anything else what was critizised. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory was that. Burton style yay, but nothing else. What to say about Planet of the Apes. But I am a Burton fan, I still like his Batman 89 more than Batman Begins; I liked Big Fish and thought that Sweeney Todd was very good. But I dare to say that Alice won't bring anything new but his visual style (which I like). And he needs to leave Johnny Depp alone for a while.
I'll try to express my opinion here, without running the risk of sounding like a rabid, ''hes the best eva director in the world, I love him soooooooo much'' Tim Burton fan...
It's a little unfair to condemn him for having a particular style. It seems so annoying and petty to say, ''ooh look theres a new Tim Burton film out, but F**K it cause it LOOKS like a Tim Burton film''
Alright... so he's made one bad movie (Planet of the Apes) where he was handcuffed by the constraints of the studios. Otherwise... he's been nothing but an independant mind working within a system of money mad dictators.
And hey perhaps Leonardo Di Caprio and Martin Scorcese should lay off one another... No one's forcing Depp to work in Tim's movies.
They are great friends, enjoy working together, and Depp always produces some of his most intriging and different work under Burton. No one character has been the same.
To top it off... Burton has already surprised me visually with this movie. It certainly doesn't look as dark as i thought he would have had it. Not to mention that if visuals where vital to getting me into a movie theatre, I wouldn't have looked at Half of Steven Speilberg's movies.
So lay of Burton's style untill you have at least seen
Wonderland in motion.