Octoberist
point blank
- Joined
- May 13, 2005
- Messages
- 46,465
- Reaction score
- 17
- Points
- 33
Stephen Sommers and Chris Columbus don't get CGI. in their movies, the CGI is always cartoony.
what is wrong with the effects in I Robot. the translucence effect on the robot was amazing.With ILM and WETA it's more about the fact that they their creations have made a huge impact on the audience. Lately look at their work.
WETA obviously has the LOTR movies , King Kong and of course Avatar.
ILN regained their "lost" status with their work on the POTC sequels and afterwards getting the photorealism right with Transformers and Iron Man.
And fanboys always believe in absolutes
Hence why they always focus on the positive things of ILM and WETA and always forget the mediocre or outright bad stuff that ILM and WETA also created. ILM was responsible for the "genius " VFX shots of Mummy Returns and Van Helsing. And Weta did also work on the 2nd Fantastic Four movie or I,ROBOT. And The Day the Earth Stood Still & Eragon.
And after the genius work Domain did on Benamin Button , i can't believe they sunk so low with GI Joe. Truly craptastic VFX.
I fully believe that the directors are the ones who can make a movie's VFX excellent. You can give Spielberg ILM and he'll create the tripods of War Of The Worlds. You give Stephen Sommers ILM and he'll give you Van Helsing.
Kosinski fall the former category. He "gets" VFX and i'm sure that he'll definately deliver with Tron .

what is wrong with the effects in I Robot. the translucence effect on the robot was amazing.![]()
I hope so. Im already sold in going to IMAX 3D to see this movie
what is wrong with the effects in I Robot. the translucence effect on the robot was amazing.![]()
More specifically, Weta were employed to render the Silver Surfer. It's unusual to find this effort being labelled "mediocre or outright bad".With ILM and WETA it's more about the fact that they their creations have made a huge impact on the audience. Lately look at their work.
WETA obviously has the LOTR movies , King Kong and of course Avatar.
ILN regained their "lost" status with their work on the POTC sequels and afterwards getting the photorealism right with Transformers and Iron Man.
And fanboys always believe in absolutes
Hence why they always focus on the positive things of ILM and WETA and always forget the mediocre or outright bad stuff that ILM and WETA also created.
*snip*
And Weta did also work on the 2nd Fantastic Four movie

TRAILER WAS AMAZIINNGG!!!!!!!!
this is the most badasss looking disney movie ever made!!
it gave me goosebumps....
it was shown in 3d too, but i didnt care i was too concentrated on the awesomenesss!
cant wait to see it again online!!!!!
![]()