• Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.

Watership Down (Netflix)

AResistor

Sidekick
Joined
Oct 12, 2018
Messages
1,217
Reaction score
622
Points
78
Great actors, but wtf were they thinking with the animation? Just really hoping the animation is better in the final product despite the late release of the trailer.....



It reminds me of animatics or PS2 cutscene graphics....
 
I love how they always cast Kehaar with actors who will totally ham it up and leave beak marks all over the scenery.
 
Great actors, but wtf were they thinking with the animation? Just really hoping the animation is better in the final product despite the late release of the trailer.....



It reminds me of animatics or PS2 cutscene graphics....


I mean it's an overseas international production. They probably can't afford to get Star Wars Rebels/Clone Wars level production.
 
I mean it's an overseas international production. They probably can't afford to get Star Wars Rebels/Clone Wars level production.

One would think for a Christmas release with big name cast though they'd want the animation to similarly be on par.

I think/hope though with the interest in it and the blowback just being over the animation that they might/hopefully work more on it so the animations is cleaner upon release.
 
I know it's a remake, but is this supposed to be the first realistic CGI-looking fully animated tv movie?
 
I’ve yet to see the original one. But I was really disappointed when I saw the animation for this one.

These made me think it would look better than what we’ve seen in the trailer...


 
This is the BBC version and there's nothing wrong with the animation, it looks brilliant. The original film from the late 1970s was a classic piece of work too.
 
Vaguely (loose term here, given how vivid the film is) remember watching the 1978 movie when my mom brought it home on VHS thinking it was a cutesy little rabbit cartoon and being rightly traumatized by it at the tender age of 6-ish, so I've been putting off watching this adaptation for at least a good week. That said, I finally got around to watching it today and I have to say that it's actually pretty solid. The story itself was overall pretty grounded (aided by the 'realistic' animation) and less like a fever dream like the cartoon, although there are a few sequences that manage to channel some level of surrealism. The voice acting is great and the character designs I generally liked, especially in how they managed to differentiate the rabbits enough to generally be able to fairly easily determine who is who. The non-rabbit creatures (humans included) suffered the most from lack of design/animation quality, especially the dog (which is unfortunate due to its role in the story), and most of the fight scenes didn't quite register because of the janky movements.

Overall, definitely more a case of substance over style for this one. I don't remember enough about the actual story from the movie nor know about the novel that originated this story in the first place to make any real comparisons, so people with more experience there can probably speak to whether this is a good retelling on par with those, but I liked it.
 
Animation/visual style is so crucial to how the story is being told.

The story at its core is still a great one. And the voice cast here is great. So this is worth watching but the visual approach really hampers the delivery of the story. The animation is not expressive, the look is clunky and downright ugly in the night scenes, it can be hard to tell the rabbits apart at night, there is very little imagination or poetry to how the visuals are presented (as compared to the original animated movie, which really nails this aspect and making the rabbits come alive visually)...

The trailer was pretty awful and makes this look worse than it is. The actual series does a good enough job of presenting the story that you get sucked into it and you're reminded why it's a classic book. But it's just a shame that the animation couldn't express the story in a new way or really add anything to the experience. The older movie is much better in that regard.
 
Oh this is out now?
 
Yeah, it's been out for a couple weeks now on Netflix.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"