The Dark Knight What Will TDK's Rating / Certificate Be?

Ya I have not been a fan of Hostel or any of those flicks. So I have a feeling I would enjoy this movie. Especially since it is more of an anti-gore horror
 
Drexx said:
So the original writer/director is remaking his own film for American audiences? Sweet, saves me the time of reading subtitles. :o
Click to expand...
The original "Insomnia" (swedish, I think) was much better than Nolan's remake with Al Pacino and Robin Williams. Sometimes you miss out on a much better film by just waiting for the Hollywood remake. Anyway I can also understand some people's aversion for subtitles. To each his own.
 
A film is more powerful if you can really understand what they are saying. But it doesn't always hinder it look at City of God.

You didn't like Insomnia? Well I didn't see the original though
 
gwynplaine said:
The original "Insomnia" (swedish, I think) was much better than Nolan's remake with Al Pacino and Robin Williams. Sometimes you miss out on a much better film by just waiting for the Hollywood remake. Anyway I can also understand some people's aversion for subtitles. To each his own.
Click to expand...
I don't have a problem with subtitles at all. And I understand your sentiment about remakes.

But in this particular case, the original writer/director is coming back to do the entire thing again, but this time in America. If this were a different guy working on it, then I'd be more inclined to see the original. Since it's not, I think I'll just wait until this new version comes out.
 
CaptainClown said:
A film is more powerful if you can really understand what they are saying. But it doesn't always hinder it look at City of God.

You didn't like Insomnia? Well I didn't see the original though
Click to expand...
I completely agree with you and I liked Insomnia very much but I thought the original one was superior (mostly thanks to Stellan Skasgaard who's playing the Pacino part and who's fantastic). As for city of God I think it's a classic.
 
gwynplaine said:
The original "Insomnia" (swedish, I think) was much better than Nolan's remake with Al Pacino and Robin Williams. Sometimes you miss out on a much better film by just waiting for the Hollywood remake. Anyway I can also understand some people's aversion for subtitles. To each his own.
Click to expand...

I thought that Nolan's Insomnia was far better than the original. Then again I think the original is overstated, overrated garbage even before I saw Nolan's remake. Nolan added so many more layers and themes to it.
 
rory_bat said:
I thought that Nolan's Insomnia was far better than the original. Then again I think the original is overstated, overrated garbage even before I saw Nolan's remake. Nolan added so many more layers and themes to it.
Click to expand...
It's all a matter of taste my friend but I seem to remember that you interviewed Nolan and had a great interaction with him so you also might be a little biased there . Anyway, Pacino in Hooha mode, hamming it up was, once again to my taste, much less interesting and more predictable than Skasgard's haunted performance. As for Robin Williams he was wonderfully directed by Nolan and was superior than, I think, the swedish actor.
All in all I prefered the original (you shouldn't say it's garbage, you should say you didn't like it)but it is all very subjective and like I said the remake was pretty good too, which is very rarely the case.
 
Ya Pacino when he gets in HOOHA mode it really is a hit or miss whether or not his performance is good.
 
gwynplaine said:
It's all a matter of taste my friend but I seem to remember that you interviewed Nolan and had a great interaction with him so you also might be a little biased there . Anyway, Pacino in Hooha mode, hamming it up was, once again to my taste, much less interesting and more predictable than Skasgard's haunted performance. As for Robin Williams he was wonderfully directed by Nolan and was superior than, I think, the swedish actor.
All in all I prefered the original (you shouldn't say it's garbage, you should say you didn't like it)but it is all very subjective and like I said the remake was pretty good too, which is very rarely the case.
Click to expand...

Absolutely, it is all a matter of taste. When I say garbage I mean that purely in my opinion as with all of my other comments. Yes, I suppose that because Nolan is my favorite (living.... Hitchcock gets top honors) director and based on my interactions with him, I could be a bit biased. But, as I said before, I saw the original long before Nolan came along and disliked it very much so I don't think it has a lot to do with Nolan, just comes to down to personal preference. Yes, it Pacino is a bit crazy performance wise I'll agree with you there, though it was one of the times that I thought his approach fit. Oh well, to each his own. :cwink:
 
gwynplaine said:
Absolutely. He is a wonderful actor and I hope he gets another great part soon.
Click to expand...

He is doing far better than DeNiro as of late. Pacino is wonderful in The Insider and Simone (which thought was very underrated).
 
rory_bat said:
He is doing far better than DeNiro as of late. Pacino is wonderful in The Insider and Simone (which thought was very underrated).
Click to expand...
I didn't see simone, I'll check it out, but I completely agree with you for the insider, but that was already a long time ago. I hear he has a new project with De Niro, so we'll see.
 
I didn't like Simone. I think he is a great actor and I really would want to see him do an over the top character. Catch us all by surprise.
 
nolan and crew seem to have taken it up a notch in this one and w/ the entire cast saying how intense and scary ledger is....will TDK get a pg-13 rating? and / or will editing done the first cut from an R to a pg-13 hurt the film?
 
there IS a rating thread around here somewhere. but it's buried
 
Nolan has always said that he directs his Bat-films to be PG-13. Nothing more, nothing less.
 
I heard there was a rumor they were going to splice in stock footage from porno films into the movie during the editing process, so who knows.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

GoogleMe94
The Dark Knight Will it be too dark for the children?
11 12 13
Replies
310
Views
20K
Mitthrawnuruodo
Mitthrawnuruodo
X
Dragonball Rating
Replies
2
Views
1K
craigdbfan
craigdbfan
A
  • Locked
Rise of the Silver Surfer PG Rating: DISCUSSION
19 20 21
Replies
512
Views
30K
Lightning Strykez!
Lightning Strykez!
Two-Face
The Dark Knight What are your exceptions from "The Dark Knight"?
2
Replies
42
Views
4K
Two-Face
Two-Face
rohitiyer
The Dark Knight What aspects of The Dark Knight do you think will influence future films in Hollywood
2 3
Replies
55
Views
7K
jmc
J

Members online

Total: 8,557 (members: 7, guests: 8,550)

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,358
Messages
22,090,906
Members
45,886
Latest member
Elchido

Share this page

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"