It's pretty easy to see why this film has such a negative reception. Critically, it's a Lynch movie through and through and critic types are always going to be divided on him. Financially, it bombed because it was based on a cancelled television show that most people had given up on towards the end. And for fans of the show, I really can't imagine this is what most of them would have wanted from a continuation of the series, especially if they were unfamiliar with some of Lynch's other work.
For me though, I enjoyed it quite a bit. The series only ever hints at the dark underbelly of Twin Peaks, barely giving you even the briefest of glimpses at it. In contrast, this film shows it to you in the cold light of day. Not drowned out by 50's nostalgia, wacky characters, and oddball humor as it is in the show. Which doesn't make it
better than the show necessarily, just very different. I actually think the way the movie throws the darker elements in your face all the time isn't as effective as leaving that stuff to your imagination as this sort of omnipresent undercurrent that occasionally bubbles up like in the series. It gives the show a very creepy and sinister tone, even more so the film at times I think.
Unfortunately, just like the series getting cancelled, Fire Walk With Me was to be the start of a Twin Peaks film series that never came to fruition, so once again we're left with characters and plot points that are left unresolved by the end. This didn't affect my enjoyment of the movie really, it just makes me wish things had worked out differently.
It's not for everybody, but I really liked it.
4/5