Which Hulk Is Stronger? (2008 or 2003)

[Anubis Raptor]

11,000,000 pounds..............thats amazing!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Spade]

Can we stop responding to one another with JPEG's?

 

[Scooter]

I wonder how much force it takes to rip an gamma powered chow in half.

I don't really wonder.

 

[Arc-Light]

I wonder how much force it takes to rip an gamma powered chow in half.

I don't really wonder.

About 4 million lbs of force per square meter.....

 

[Midnight Black]

Does anyone ELSE have something intelligent to say...please it can be anything.....just as long as it is not this junk.


[*shut your windows, lock your doors....they're here, they're here......HATERS*]

 

[ironwez20]

after looking at some videos of 03 hulk i have to say why people are complaining , 03 hulk was a mess imo , yeah hes stronger but he wasnt lethal , or wasnt hulk like and yes imma say it again the guy looked like shrek so what, i really dont care if you guys call me troll, 08 hulk in every aspect was way better, fans hated the 03 hulk movie atleast some of them did and we had alotta complaints, now we get this perfect reboot and i see some people looking over thier shoulders and saying how 03 hulk had a beter cast and a better hulk, 03 hulk had cool moments in it but it was a mess of a movie, hulk freakin fights abomination in this movie and in 03 hulk he fights absorbing jellyfish daddy, wow i think 03 woulnt even no what to do if he had those sonic cannons on him.

 

[Scooter]

Wow, that was all one sentence.

 

[Anubis Raptor]

When the Hulk becomes stronger based on his emotions (2008) it is closer to the comic. He doesn't grow to a maximum of 15 ft. Instead he becomes stronger from within. So it seems more of a internal/mental thing. I'm not saying growing larger is a dumb idea because IMO it was brilliant! If you look at it this way, there is no limit to his strength in this film because he doesn't grow to a maximum level. This gives him (08) more of an edge because he doesn't have a LIMIT.

 

[C. Lee]

As a true Incredible Hulk fan (means i have read the comics) i totally dismiss the Chinaman's version( i did see it, and it was crap), but it is funny that since 08 version NEVER FIGHTS A TANK, then how in the hell would we know if he cant throw it. We i mean some of you need to move on, and forget the 03 version for good. The Incredible Hulk 08 is the only version there is.

You have been sent a warning. Do not call anyone by a racist term again. Stop with the picture and gif jabs at people who do not share your opinion.

 

[Tyrinus]

after looking at some videos of 03 hulk i have to say why people are complaining , 03 hulk was a mess imo , yeah hes stronger but he wasnt lethal , or wasnt hulk like and yes imma say it again the guy looked like shrek so what, i really dont care if you guys call me troll, 08 hulk in every aspect was way better, fans hated the 03 hulk movie atleast some of them did and we had alotta complaints, now we get this perfect reboot and i see some people looking over thier shoulders and saying how 03 hulk had a beter cast and a better hulk, 03 hulk had cool moments in it but it was a mess of a movie, hulk freakin fights abomination in this movie and in 03 hulk he fights absorbing jellyfish daddy, wow i think 03 woulnt even no what to do if he had those sonic cannons on him.

More than likely jumped miles away avoiding the pansyness of being brought to his knees.

 

[ironwez20]

Wow, that was all one sentence.

wow your stupid did you see the comments and periods.

 

[ironwez20]

More than likely jumped miles away avoiding the pansyness of being brought to his knees.

excuse me , yes he was brought to his knees but pansyness yea right. Hulk 08 found out away to beat the cannaons and didnt we say that hulk 03 needs a running start to jump that high.

 

[Sava]

excuse me , yes he was brought to his knees but pansyness yea right. Hulk 08 found out away to beat the cannaons and didnt we say that hulk 03 needs a running start to jump that high.

no, watch the scene with Talbot in the house, after throwing Talbot at someone, he jumps away, without running.

 

[Lexar128]

no, watch the scene with Talbot in the house, after throwing Talbot at someone, he jumps away, without running.

We don't really see how far or how high.

 

[Sava]

We don't really see how far or how high.

who gives a s**t, if he can jump short distances, he can do long ones too, he's the hulk, all he needs is strength, he has that.

 

[Crowforge]

I'd have liked if they had just toned down the growth not get rid of it as they seem to have done. Maybe just have it show up in the last fight.

Stronger or not the fights were better in this hulk because he seemed to be challenged. And his attitude was better as he seemed reluctant to fight at first which feels more like the hulk I know.

An aside, I could have done with less of Roth's body,that was supposed to be a soldier?

 

[Anubis Raptor]

Can someone find out how much force it takes to crack pavement/ground??

I bet whoever finds it will be in awe........

 

[November Rain]

As for the people saying 03's hulk needed a run up, after he breaks out of the hulkbuster unit, he visits his family home and gets hit by grenade or something.

In that scene he jumps about four miles, in fact he doesnt even realise how much strength he has in his legs because while in the air he stumbles as he's over projected himself.

Great piece of cgi by the way and a great feat of leg strength. He doesn't need any sort of run up to do a jump.


proof is one minute into this scene

 

[November Rain]

I don't post here very often (mostly because I have so many accounts with so many different websites that I can't keep up with all the usernames and passwords ughh) Anyway I just got back on here and this conversation intrigued me. I did watch the 2003 HULK movie more than 4 times and I will say that the tank throwing feat was VERY strong....BUT I must also add that no one on here seems to be mentioning the 08 INCREDIBLE HULK throwing a boulder the size of himself at more than a 45 degree angle up into the sky...

Here are my comparisons for these two feats:

03 HULK
Army tanks weigh about 60 tons or 120,000lbs (if it's an abrams main battle tank) which is on the larger side of us army tanks. size is 30' x 12' x 7.5' (though this is hollow for the most part inside)

He didn't actually pick up the tank, like reaching down and picking up a barbell by grabbing the sides or bottom. Instead he grabbed the turret (barrel) and leaned and used momentum and inertia to spin the tank around himself (like a hammer throw).

After about 3-4 spins he let loose and the tank looked like it travelled(realistically here) about .5 to .75 mi away...just over the ridge behind him. If you think it was farther than that, seriously go out on a highway stand at a mile marker and look how far the next one is down the road(if you can even see it).

08 INCREDIBLE HULK
The SOLID ROCK/BOULDER that he basically grabbed off the face of the mountain in 08 TIH was about the size of himself, so I'll say the diameter of the boulder was about 8.5ft. That's 321.5 cu.ft of solid mass(volume of sphere is 3/4 x pi(3.14) x 76.77(which is the radius (4.25ft) to the third power) .

Steel is generally regarded at a weight of 500lbs per cubic foot. With a volume of 321.5 cu.ft., if this rock were solid steel it would weigh 160,500lbs. Given that this rock, depending on the elements involved ie granite, micah etc...might not be completely solid I will deduct my calculation by 20%(32,100lbs) so now the rock weighs approx 128,400lbs.

If you watch the scene in TIH he is uber pissed at the storm, grabs this huge boulder, lifts it like it weighs 20lbs to the normal man and throws it into the sky, I would say at least 50+ mph against gravity.

I am not saying that either Hulk or The Incredible Hulk is stronger than the other, but look at some hard evidence and facts of mass, and volume of different objects and how he lifts and throws or slams or tears apart those objects and you get an idea of which one has the higher strength(and higher rage). IMHO, they should both be the same strength because they are both HULK.

Dude, 03's hulk lifted ripped off a much larger piece of rock than himself and threw it into the lake in ang lee's hulk because his father was growing out of the top of it.

Similar angle, much bigger heavier piece of rock than himself (probably weights double 08's hulk) and chucked it into the centre of that massive lake.

So your rock throwing feat is pretty mute.

 

[CainMarko]

I'll have to go back and review that footage...

but did you see my other post with the article on the force it would take to rip a car frame in half? 11,000,000 lbs of force per sq. meter...2003 Hulk didn't exibit anywhere NEAR that level of strength. Neither did Abomination in 08 hulk. Only Superman in SR exerted close to that level of strength out of any superhero movie ever made, when he lifted the kryptonite island. There is NO way that the boulder/absorbing dad at the end of HULK 2003 weighed 11,000,000 lbs, not even close. (if the boulder is 25ft in diameter, which would be a sphere which it wasn't, it would have a volume of 4609 cu.ft. multiplied by 500(wt of steel per cubic foot) = 2,304,500lbs...but then again the rock wasn't a sphere it was tall and thin so deduct about half of that figure = 1,152,250lbs.)

So your whole argument is pretty moot

 

[ironwez20]

im seeyin the movie again today, ill take some notes and see if this hulk can compare to the other.

 

[November Rain]

I'll have to go back and review that footage...

but did you see my other post with the article on the force it would take to rip a car frame in half? 11,000,000 lbs of force per sq. meter...2003 Hulk didn't exibit anywhere NEAR that level of strength. Neither did Abomination in 08 hulk. Only Superman in SR exerted close to that level of strength out of any superhero movie ever made, when he lifted the kryptonite island. There is NO way that the boulder/absorbing dad at the end of HULK 2003 weighed 11,000,000 lbs, not even close. (if the boulder is 25ft in diameter, which would be a sphere which it wasn't, it would have a volume of 4609 cu.ft. multiplied by 500(wt of steel per cubic foot) = 2,304,500lbs...but then again the rock wasn't a sphere it was tall and thin so deduct about half of that figure = 1,152,250lbs.)

So your whole argument is pretty moot

Ang's hulk pulled the turret end of a tank off. I'm fairly accurate in saying that a tank is built with more rigidity than a police car.

Let's no go crazy throwing arbitrary figures around.

YOu said the new hulk was strong for throwing a piece of rock, when ang's threw one with bigger dimentions in the same way.

you say the new hulk is strong because he ripped a car in half while ang's ripped a top end of a tank off.

So I don't know where your basis of analysis stands at.

 

[Cosmic]

I like the fact that light artillery weapons can actually hurt the Hulk, or at least slow him down. It was cool seeing him go up against tanks in 03, but it's more interesting if he's not completely unstoppable against conventional weapons. He looked like he was really hurting when they opened up the .50 cals on him!

 

[rodhulk]

This is the most ridiculous thing I've read in this fun fantastical comparison. This kid believes its harder to throw a forklift than a tank. You know, cause forklifts are heavier than tanks and all.

1) You only addressed one point and said it was the most ridiculous thing in this thread..........

OK................

.. then why didn't you address my other points like 08 Hulk destroying vehicles alot easier than 03 Hulk or 08 Hulk taking the same/similar calibre weapons fire that hardly make him flinch (and not knock him down) at his baseline strength when 03 Hulk, who already had gotten stronger with his rage, was hurt and knocked down by one single tank blast (the same calibre of weapons fire as on 08 Hulk)????????????


Now that is 'ridiculous' from your line of thinking.

 

[rodhulk]

I like the fact that light artillery weapons can actually hurt the Hulk, or at least slow him down. It was cool seeing him go up against tanks in 03, but it's more interesting if he's not completely unstoppable against conventional weapons. He looked like he was really hurting when they opened up the .50 cals on him!

Sorry but I didn't see him get hurt in the fashion you're saying. Only the sonic canons had some effect but so did the foam in the 03 version. Both Hulk's, however, were able to eventually break out/destroy both the foam and sonic canons.