Who's hotter? Bootylicious Rogue or cutie-pie Kitty Pryde?

[xmenfilesfan05]

VERSUS

In my mind it's pretty simple. Ellen is a cute girl, but she kind of has the facial features of a doll. Anna, I think, has grown up enough that she can be compared next to Famke, Rebecca, or Halle...she's stood beside them and looked great, so let's stop calling her a girl! Ha ha...

 

[HighVoltage]

This Thread Is For All Ages?

 

[GNR]

I would do 'em both in a heartbeat.Especially Anna with those amazing legs and hips.Mmm,mmm,good.

 

[storyteller]

Kitty looks 12 and that aint a good thing. Who bangs a 12 year old?(and isnt a sick freak or 12-15 themselves). Like banging a preschooler.


Rouge has as much as an ass as ian is straight.

 

[GNR]

She looks much older than 12 buddy.SHe could pass for 17 or 18.I'm 19 so it's okay for me to be saying that.

 

[GNR]

Kitty looks 12 and that aint a good thing. Who bangs a 12 year old?(and isnt a sick freak or 12-15 themselves). Like banging a preschooler.


Rouge has as much as an ass as ian is straight.

Are you serious?You have got to be joking.

 

[storyteller]

Yeah i'm frekin serious about rouge, and yeah i knows she's older then that, just saying in these shots, she looks too young.

So unless you can prove me wrong i'll keep both my opinions.

 

[Aiden]

Because I'm young I think its okay for me to say Kitty

 

[Dark Carnage]

For a white girl, Anna's bangin! I can't stand those Marykate & Ashley bean pole chicks, Eat something! People always hating on full figured women, give me Beyonce over Lindsey Lohan anyday.

Anna forever!

Yeah, I wasn't even talking about her body. Anna is average looker, Rogue is meant to be a stunning southern beauty. It has nothing to do with her body (though Rogue is meant to have a fantastic one). The idea is you are meant to look at Rogue's face and go "Wow, I'm in love." Not "Well, I guess she could be pretty. If you like that sort of thing."

And by the way, would anyone chose Lohan over Beyonce?

 

[Slim_X]

Both are hot .

 

[storyteller]

Yeah, I wasn't even talking about her body. Anna is average looker, Rogue is meant to be a stunning southern beauty. It has nothing to do with her body (though Rogue is meant to have a fantastic one). The idea is you are meant to look at Rogue's face and go "Wow, I'm in love." Not "Well, I guess she could be pretty. If you like that sort of thing."

And by the way, would anyone chose Lohan over Beyonce?

I guess if they dont like black chicks..................

 

[blind_fury]

double post...I'm a spaz.

*kills himself*

 

[blind_fury]

I guess if they dont like black chicks..................

who cares about color? ass is ass.

 

[The Caped Knight]

Rogue Rules .

 

[Halcohol]

I voted for Kitty, just because she's not the classical beauty... she's the girl next door. Sure, she's a LITTLE boyish, but eh. I don't know, something about Anna's lips and teeth...

And I WOULD have taken Lindsay Lohan before she went all Olsen-style on us. Back when she had some t!ts on her... not that I'm knockin Beyonce at all, but she's a little tall for me.

 

[blind_fury]

Because I'm young I think its okay for me to say Kitty

Keep telling yourelf that! lol!

 

[KenK]

It's hard to tell whether or not Rogue's got junk in the trunk, or if she's just got MAAAADDD birthing hips. Either way, I'm in luv! Anna's sexy bottom lip is enough to sway my vote in her favor.

 

[KenK]

Anyone thinking Rogue and Kitty might be wearing each other's outfits? Rogue's bustin' outta hers, and Kitty's shoulderpads put Janet Reno to shame!

 

[neemer5]

Alls I can say is Baby Got Back:

I'd definitely say Anna. She's sexy as Hell in Squid and the Whale. Ellen page looks like a pre-teen boy.

Plus Anna Paquin isn't hurting on top, either:

(This photo was from 25th hour, which came out before X2)

 

[moop501]

Ellen looks and walks like a chimpanzee in this shot/scene.

 

[intensity]

Anna Paquin, but not by much... I used to have a little school boy crush on her when she was in Fly Away Home, and I was very infatuated w/the fact that she'd be playing Rogue- but I don't really think she suits the character. Dye her hair blonde and she'd be Paige Guthrie/Husk/Hayseed. Nothing special, just a pretty face.
Ellen is very cute, don't get me wrong, but she is just too young looking. I think that her and Bobby are in a forced relationship- plus I think Iceman is portrayed as a tool in the movies.

I'd much rather go with Kea Wong. She's got style, a skin tone, great hair, a beautiful smile... plus she is portraying my favorite superhero ever.

 

[KenK]

Ellen looks and walks like a chimpanzee in this shot/scene.

I think she's just doddling, 'cause she doesn't want to train. Probably woke her up at the buttcrack o' dawn.

 

[blind_fury]

Ellen looks and walks like a chimpanzee in this shot/scene.

She's an awkward teenager. Not yet a confident woman. Suits the character fine.

 

[Gamma Warrior]

Alls I can say is Baby Got Back:

I'd definitely say Anna. She's sexy as Hell in Squid and the Whale. Ellen page looks like a pre-teen boy.

Is that from X3?

 

[Mary]

Is that from X3?

No..it's from X2..