Your Favorite and Least Favorite Scenes and Moments (All the Spoilers)

Favorites:

-Darth Vader's final scene
-The entire last act of the movie

Least favorite:

-The scene where the pilot gets his head sucked on by a creature. I thought that segment was really stupid and a clumsy way to show Saw's weirdness

 

Favorites...

- Vader and Krennic
- Vader's rampage
- The final 10 to 15 minutes with the Star Destroyers getting pushed into the shield, Jyn and Cassian dying etc.
- The destruction of the Holy City on Jedha.

 

Death Star being used for the first time destroying the city and the final battle come to mind. Also all the Vader scenes.

 

Vader Vader and Vader lol.

When you first see Vader you can just see the entimidation that he crates on people and I thought JEJ voice sounded just fine.

The last part when he goes crazy and kills all of those people you can fell the hory that those guys are going though and I was not suspecting that and when it first started and the doors are opeing part I was like oh my this is going to be vader I couldn't belive it. May be my favorite part of any star wars movie ever.

 

Favourites--

- Vader's rampage.
- Vader's first scene.
- The whole final battle/third act. The ground troops really felt like they were in a war. The Star Destroyer being rammed through the other one. Oh, and and the Rebel ships jumping into hyperspace... Then Vader's Star Destroyer jumps in and obliterates them.
- Tarkin. Loved him in this.
- Red and Gold Leader.
- "Hope".
- Riz's death. Something so random about it, but in a good and brutal way. Like something out of Saving Private Ryan. Also loved him calling in fake attacks on the Imperial signals, and mustering his courage to get the cable to the ship.
- "Did you know that wasn't me?!" "... Of course".
- Bail and Mothma's scene.
- Jyn, Cassian and K-2S0's deaths.

Leasts--

- Anything with Saw.
- The general boring and plodding nature of the first act/first half.
- The overly shallow depth of field was often distracting and hard to look at.

 

Favorite Scenes:

Jyn watching Galen's message didn't think I'll tear up had to hold back
Death Star first attack
Tarkin taking control of the Death Star
all the episode 4 set up the "Hope" reveal was greatness didn't think they would show her

VADER, VADER , VADER!!!!!!!!!!!

when he reveals himself via His Red Light sabre was phenomenal
and when he waste all those rebel troops with ease OMG

Least Favorite:

The Score was forgettable really disappointed with it
Saw was not what I expected and too little of him
I thought the new Droid K-something was too sarcastic in some scenes
Vader's intro while I loved his scene with Krenic wished we would have seen him being taken out the chamber
2nd act was so slow
even thought it's a common theme in all these movies but how worthless is the stormtroopers "armor"

 

I'm starting to think it's not even an armor. Just an uniform.

 

Favorites:
K-2
Vader's rampage
the last third

Least favorites:
CGI Tarkin and Leia
Vader's choke pun
the first half

 

Favourites
The appearance of the ATAT
Dark Vaders choking on ambition line and his rage unleashed
Seeing the bureaucracy of the empire, particularly after the first test of the Death Star

Least favourites
CGI Grand Moff. Really they should have just recast him
The predictable bit about her dad's nickname for jyn.
Her mother getting fridged. Yawn

 

Well, that is exactly what Luke says in ANH "Huh? Oh, the uniform.".
Even though Chirruts fight scenes were awesome it is hard to imagine that him hitting a stormtropper over the head with a staff is enough to knock them out while they are wearing helmets.

 

The best scene was hands down Vader's massacre at the end.
That would be followed by Chirrut vs. the stormtroopers on Jedah and the appearance of the AT-ATs.
Most of K-2's scenes were gold too

 

I watched the original last night before seeing Rogue One this morning. It made me appreciate the last scene so much more.

 

The way you just see the glow of his light sabre before anything else is pure badass.

 

- All the death scenes of the main heroes
- the city destruction scenes
- the beginning, origin story
- Vader laying down the law
- All K-2 scenes!
- the aliens were all fun the look at
- the blind dude and his friend
- the jedi city scenes
- space jumps were cool
- Jyn watching her father's hologram

 

Oh and the Leia scene is literally life itself.

 

There is so much good in the last 20, I can't say yet. Need another showing. I LOVE the Death Star firing.

 

Pretty much sums it for me. Although I LOVED CGI Tarkin and Leia.

 

1. Vader at the end.
2. The Space battle.
3. The concurrent land battle.
4. Jyn sending out the plans.
5. K2SO's final moment.
6. Jyn and Andor sharing their final moment.
7. Chirrut's final moment.
8. Riz's final moment.
9. The ship (the Hammerhead?) pushing the two star destroyers into each other.
10. Jyn's seemingly last look at Andor after Krennic shoots him before she continues the mission.

No least fav moments.

 

LOVED just about every scene with K-2 lol Really too bad he couldn't be worked into the newer films

 

Top 5 favorite moments

1. Vader's rampage on the Rebels / Escape

2. Retrieving the plans ground/space battle

3. Vader putting Krennic in his place by force cocking him

4. Jyn & Rogue One

5. K-2So all scenes

 

There's something special about the "May the force be with you Rogue One". I really like it when the force comes off as something spiritual so I'm glad to see that return in these new films.

 

Top 3
1. Vader's rampage.
2. Chirrut walking through the battlefield to reach the master switch.
3.Tarkin stealing Krennic's moment of triumph.

 

Best:
Vader (of course).
The effects for making the old characters reappear was a success.
Princess Leia's adoptive father being a really clever cameo, linking back to the prequels, and preparing the ground for the appearance of Leia.
The emotional moments carrying a real punch.
The Destroyers looking like models.


Worst:

Some elements of the plot are clumsy.
Vader talks a bit more than necessary.
Some of the deaths are beautiful and carry a punch, while others are there just to show that the character is, indeed, dead.