The Dark Knight Rises Your opinon on TDKR thus far

CJ

Sidekick
Joined
May 4, 2008
Messages
4,169
Reaction score
1,718
Points
78
The Dark Knight Rises arrives in Theaters next July. From what little pics we've seen so far, casting news, and other info we've gathered, what is your opinion on the movie at the moment? Optimistic? Pessimistic? Neutral?

I personally am both optimistic and pessimistic.

Pros:

-I am excited to see how Nolan wraps up his Batman trilogy. He said in an interview once (I don't have the link, sorry) that he and his staff are working on making this Batman as "epic as possible"

-There is a rumor that Bane wants to do Batman's job better than him. He sees Gotham as a prize. This sounds like a very intriguing premise. I hope this rumor is true.

-Bane possibly being a mirror to Bruce Wayne. This sounds very interesting.

-I loved Tom Hardy and Joesph Gordon-Levitt in Inception (though the movie itself failed to meet my very high expectations) So their inclusion in the TDKR is great news.

-If Nolan does have Bane "Break the bat" in this film, then Bats final battle with Bane at the end of the film should be a very exciting scene.

Cons:

-I know it's in my signature already, but. Anne Hathaway. She just annoys the heck out of me. I've never found her to be that good of an actress. I think Marion Cotillard would've been a much better choice for the role. She has the Catwoman look to her (short black hair. I don't care if an actress is "sexy" in the role, I just want her to LOOK the part, and Marion definitely does, IMHO) she also seems to be in the age range Catwoman should be.

Another thing that bugs me about Hathaway's inclusion is I'm so used to seeing her everywhere. I see her on Late Night talk shows, Oscar Red Carpets, Interviews, Movies, Magazine covers. She's everywhere. So when she is onscreen, I won't be able to believe she is Selina Kyle/Catwoman. I will just be seeing Anne Hathaway. :dry:

-This one worries me even moreso than Hathaway's inclusion in the film. The emphasis on studio-shooting. TDK looked gorgeous because (pretty much) everything was real. There was very little studio-shooting, except maybe in the interrogation scene, Gambol's death scene, and the makeshift Batcave.

Apart from the Iceland stuff, the filming of Batman Begins relied heavily on studios, and while I did enjoy Batman Begins very much when I first saw it in 2005, looking back on it now and comparing it to TDK, some of it looks very.. cheap. There's a few CGI exterior shots (When the inmates are freed, there's an overhead shot of the city, and it just looks awful. Very bad CGI.) So does the scene when Batman has Flass hanging upside-down, the scene when Batman crawls away from Scarecrow after getting gassed and calls for Alfred. The monorail explosion at the end. I don't want to see a bunch of CGI'd exterior shots, and I don't want to see a bunch of sets either. I'd like this to be filmed on-location like TDK was.

-I heard that James Newton Howard will not be involved in the Soundtrack. Hans is a talented composer, no doubt about that, but what made TDK have such an excellent sound was their collaboration together. I hope his omission from the soundtrack won't have a negative impact on the score.

-Lastly, this is more of a small nitpick than a real concern, but Bane's arms looked a little tiny in that pic from the Official Site. Bane should look ripped. His arms should be HUGE.
 
Last edited:
I suspect Anne will rock. Anne agrees.
 

Attachments

  • anne-hathaway-f-you-paparazzi-13145554.jpg
    anne-hathaway-f-you-paparazzi-13145554.jpg
    33.5 KB · Views: 66
Casting is great. Bane look is cool. He's not bodybuilder size but I'm not complaining, Hardy looks fine.

I love the look of BB, more sets are nice as far as I'm concerned. So little info, can't speak on much else unless we just mention rumors. As far as those are concerned, the idea that Bane was trained by Ra's and is lowered into the pit which serves as his venom...in conjunction with the rumor that LoS is somehow involved with Bane and Talia taking over Gotham all sounds really mediocre if not flat out awful. Sounds really forced and cheesy like a really bad one shot. Do not want.
 
All we've seen is one official picture, and some set pics. We don't even know the complete story yet. I think I'll wait a little while longer before making a decision.
 
Last edited:
Both Nolan Batman movies have been awesome. My fear is more that it won't get the credit it deserves because it may not be as great as the second one was with Heath Ledger's Joker and will be more on par with the first movie, and that is the way it will end before being rebooted for some dumb reason.
 
How can I provide an opinion? All what I heard was the cast of TDKR by WB and a TEASER image of Bane. If I provide an opinion, whether good or bad, it would be biased.
 
Neutral for me so far. I think it will be difficult for them to match the quality of BB/TDK, but I am going to keep an open mind.
 
I have doubted Nolan before with TDK, I won't make that mistake I think it'll be a really good end to his trilogy.
 
So far I'm loving everything, I hope the film is more personal, darker and grander than TDK.
 
The title: Hate it, but whatever. It's just a title.
The cast: Excellent.
Bane and Catwoman: Great choices.
First photo of Bane: Orgasm.
 
What are my opinions?

I think it's going to be amazing. I love everything about it so far. Only thing I didn't like at first was the title, but now it's really grown on me. I love it. I love this movie already. I can't wait to see it.
 
I'll wait until we at least have something of substance.. like.. you know.. a trailer, before I form an opinion on the direction the movie is going. I can't even fairly judge Bane's appearance at this point, knowing that the Joker looked quite a bit different from the first image we were given of him.
-Lastly, this is more of a small nitpick than a real concern...
That seemed to have been the case with all of your "cons."
 
Optimistic; Nolan has picked a villain who will provide Batman with a physical and mental challenge, in addition to the GPD TRYING TO take him down. He's also touching back on the philantrophic side of Bruce which is nice too.
 
It's hard to weigh in on this. With all the expectations I had for TDK through the virals, I thought there was no way it could live up to my expectations. It ended up exceeding my expectations as far as epic films go. So as much as I want to say that there is no way that TDKR can live up, I always trust in Nolan. And until he proves me wrong, that's what I'm going with..
 
Neutral, and only because Talia might still be in it.
 
The title: Hate it, but whatever. It's just a title.
The cast: Excellent.
Bane and Catwoman: Great choices.
First photo of Bane: Orgasm.

This but I don't hate the title.
 
Overall very excited. My only concern now is Hathaway. I didn't like the idea of her when she was announced and still don't like the idea of her months later. A decent promo shot could put paid to that, of course.
 
i'am ofcourse optimistic about the project.

But i really hope it goes like BB the style and stuff,because BB is still my favorite Batman film.

I think Bane will be a part of the leauge of shadows after seeing the mask
 
I have no problem with Hathaway, I only have a problem with Catwoman. I've never loved her a s a character. Plus, she isn't the kind of character you can devote a small amount of time to. This is Nolan's last bang and I won't Bruce Wayne to get as much attention as possible. However, Nolan always proves me wrong when I express fears about characters, so I'll remain optimistic.

I also don't like the focus on interior on-set shooting.


Everything else I love. I love that they've included Bane and a young Ra's Al Ghul, I love the snippets of the plot that we know so far, I love that this will be a conclusion to the story.
 
Even though it's ridiculous to have a real opinion at this point...

Let me put it this way: For the first 23 years of my life, when I said "the trilogy", it was clear I meant Star Wars, after The Dark Knight Rises is released, that's going to change.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"