LoL.
Are you joking?
You do realize that your list of "good movies that speak to you personally" are far more popular, blockbuster type movies than Clockwork Orange and Pulp Fiction, right? Some people tend to pick films that challenge and engage them(like say, Clockwork Orange & Pulp Fiction) over action films where you pretty much leave your brain at the door. If you really think Pulp Fiction is stupid and pointless, I suggest you wait a couple of years, perhaps at least until you have to start shaving, and then try watching it again. It's one thing to not like a movie, it's quite another to dismiss it because you're a moron
Anywho...
The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou
Closer
The Big Lebowski
Reefer Madness
American Beauty
oy!
I was try to make a point, one that was missed apparently. Let me explain I have no problem respecting films that challenge people on an intellectual field. But as I recall this was a thread that describes our favorite films, not what we thought were the greatest films. What I am trying to say is SO WHAT??? so what if my favorite films are "more popular, blockbuster type movies". I used to go to Loyola Marymount University where the films school is very renouned and every one would routinely say that their favorite films were Citizen Cane and the Godfather. My friend, afilm major, told me once her favorite movie was the birth of a nation, and I couldn't believe what I was hearing. Don't get me wrong I like to be intellectually challenged and I can respect many classic films. But was that really the film she loved to watch over and over again that she derived so much enjoyment from. If it was then I was gravely mistaken as to the kind of person she was. And after much further questioning I found her favorite film was the princess bride. A far inferior film when compared to the others she listed off like a trained machine.
I tire of this. We should never check our brains at the door, but shouldn't we also enjoy what we are watching?
If I don't like a film the critics love and with good reason shouldn't I be able to say so without being insulted?
Are there somethings that are perhaps popular with cause? Things like Gone with the Wind? or The Godfather?
In defense of my list: Superman was one of the first films I ever watched and remembered, It made me want to aspire to be like him. Batman Begins was the story of a man who tries to affect change in an everyday realistic world and does it so as one of my childhood memories. Bourne is in my opinion an example of the moral conscience in the real world and how important it is. Braveheart is one of the best examples of manhood in cinema today. But for me the Matrix beats it all. Taking Christianity, Buddhism, Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, and just about every philosophy and political structure and rolling it into a very appealling action film. I film I can take meaning from and also enjoy.
Thats where I think the problem lies. In our attempt to get away from brainless crap we run toward boring crap. There has to be some sort of medium in between. Lets also be honest, we are on superherohype messageboards shouldn't we be able to state that we love superhero movies without being insulted for not liking that which is crtically acclaimed.
Bullet a couple of posts earlier says he hopes to see a lot of goodfellas and godfather. I love those films, but I hope to see a much more variety as everyone is different and not everyone cares what AFI or the academy awards tells us to like.
As for Kubrick and Tarantino, I really dislike their style. And I'm not sure it's psychologically healthy to always be watching those types of films. This is why I am surprised to see that people have put it on their favorite films. I never stated that I didn't respect those films, with the exception of Pulp Fiction that is. Tarantino is renouned for his great realistic characters....that I don't relate to one little bit. So which should I care about something that has no significance to me. So many guys I know tell me that the Godfather is the greatest film ever. Not for me. And if thats ignorance well then I welcome it.
But I come from a place where disagreement isn't ignorance.
edit: i forgot to add fight club and the departed to my list