JewishHobbit
Avenger
- Joined
- Aug 4, 2003
- Messages
- 26,683
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 56
Another large week for me and partially of my own doing. Picked up two books I was question, one being X-Men and the other being Dial H. I was questioning Earth 2 but pretty much knew I was going to get at least the first issue so no shock there. On to the reviews starting with DC:
Earth 2 #1 - I honestly hadn't been reading any previews or interviews about this so I didn't really know what to expect. I thought it was essentially the New-52 JSA so I was surprised to see Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman front and center. I liked seeing Huntress as a young Robin and daughter of Bruce Wayne but she and Supergirl/Power Girl flew away for their own title, which I didn't buy. Maybe I'll try it another day but I doubt it. As for this issue itself I thought it was good. I was disappointed the big 3 were the main draw but the story ended up being good and the three of them biting the big one making way for the JSA (as shown with a young Jay Garrick in the end) really makes this interesting for me. I'm liking the first issue and will likely be back for the second provided I can make the finances work.
Dial H #1 - This one was a spirt of the moment try and I'm glad I did. I didn't know what the actual premise was but I read that the writer was nervous about it and I just felt compelled to help the guy out (wierd right? That was honestly going on in my head when I decided to buy it). It ended up being a pretty good read. The main character is an obese man who's let himself go due to having lost his job and girl. He's just had a heart attack and just isn't taking care of himself. He has a friend looking out for him who's apparently a drug dealer or something shady like that and it gets him in trouble. The obese man tries to help by calling the police in a phone booth and becomes a creepy but cool character and stops them. He does it again to become another character later on and we're getting the idea that he's becoming addicted to the power trips.
It was a very good issue and holds the bar of good Dark titles like Swamp Thing and Animal Man (and to a lesser degree, Justice League Dark). I'm not typically a fan of overly dark titles, resulting in my dropping Animal Man, despite the good quality, and Swamp Thing, though I've returned to it for now, but this premise has me curious enough to come back for a couple more issues to see where it goes. Good debut.
Swamp Thing #9 - As I said, I dropped this book but missed it and came back. I'm still not a fan of how dark it is (not my thing but it's what's to be expected) but the plot has been great. This seems like the conclusion to the first large arc and it was definately entertaining. I'm glad Abigail isn't stuck in this ugly bug creature form and I liked where the title went. I'm still a bit wierded out by Swamp Thing having horns or whatever but I can get used to it. The title is good, though the darkness still leaves a bad taste in my mouth, but it's good enough to keep me on for now.
X-Men #28 - I was questioning picking up this arc but figured I'd give it a shot. It didn't really wow me so I doubt I'll continue it. I guess I"ll probably call this one of the Adjectiveless X-Men skip arcs.
The premise is that there's a few straggler Skrulls from Secret Invasion. 3 of the 4 were deserters and just wanted to go home. The 4th was a loyalist and still wants to make the Earthers pay. They trick Pixie into taking them to get the objects needed for their escape from Earth but the loyal Skrull has other plans. Guest staring the Fantastic Four and Spider-Man.
Eh, not great. Bored. Moving on.
X-Factor #235 - While the cover is fantastic I was a little bored by the interior. Jamie and Havoc butt heads over how the team should handle the newest situation and Longshot is hurt while trying to read a video camera of a slain "local superhero." Jamie and Shatterstar then don not so subtle costumes and infiltrate the hero's team. It was fun but the story's only 2 issues long and I'm glad for that. David has a habbit of expanding the stories I don't care for for six or seven issues.
Defenders #6 - I'm torn on this issue. My love of the Immortal Iron Fist makes me cheer for the comic that focuses on Danny and the Immortal Weapons. I'm ticked though because of how most of them were just wiped off the map behind the scenes. The two biggest names, Fat Cobra & Prince of Orphans, are left alive (Davos also being absent) but we lose Dog Brother, Bride of Nine Spiders, and Tiger's Beautiful Daughter. Tiger and Dog Brother I'm indifferent about because they weren't that spectacular, but Bride of Nine Spiders was very interesting and had a lot of potential. She was wierd though so hopefully she'll be back. The biggest gripe though is Prince of Orphans going the "bad guy" route, having killed the 3 Immortal Weapons, 4 if Danny hadn't saved Fat Cobra. I guess I'll see how it all resolves but I really don't like the path Fraction's laying out for Aman.
The Machine doohicky plot is finally starting to interest me, 6 issues in.
Avengers vs. X-Men #3 - I don't know, about on par with the previous issues. Not bad, not good. Cap randomly decking Wolverine and planning on dropping him in the Antarctic due to his unpredictableness was just poor writing in my opinion. It felt VERY unCap-like and it took me out of the story. I was excited for this event but so far I'm bored. Bendis delivered an alright first issue, Aaron failed last issue, and Brubaker was somewhere between them for issue 3... none of them that fantastic. Oh well, we'll see where it all goes.
Avengers Academy #29 - This issue was just mediocre for me. Gage doesn't have any sort of grasp on X-23's character and how the kids are handled is stupid. The X-kids are not prisoners but if they try to escape attack them and stop them?! I just don't like how that was handled in the slightest. I honestly hope the X-Kids just kick the living crap out of everyone and leave but that won't happen. I think detaining children against their will by force "for their own good" is a bit too underhanded for the Avengers and make them look about as bad as the rest of the event has made both them and the X-Men look. The whole event has so far just made both sides appear rediculous and out of character.
Honestly, the only part I liked about the issue was Sebastian Shaw and all he does. I thought the scene with the book was slick and I loved the homage of the last page. I'll be back for the remainder of this tie-in but am eager for it to be finished already.
Age of Apocalypse #3 - I'm not seeing myself sticking with this for much longer. I'm interested in the return of dead AoAers but the plot just isn't doing it for me. I find Jean and Sabretooth to be boring and none the humans save Prophet are interesting. The one character I saw in this issue that made me excited was Abyss and he died before he was able to be resurrected.
I'm honestly bored of this title and with having to cut some fat I think this book will be one of them. I might give it another issue or two to pull me in but we'll see.
Best and Worst of the Week
Best: Dial H - As a complete shocker, I realized that I enjoyed this book the most this week. Now granted, it was a pretty crappy week so it didn't have much competition. It was a solid debut though and worth a read for anyone willing to try new stuff. It's new reader friendly... give it a shot.
Worst: Age of Apocalypse - I'm just very indifferent about this book and this issue did nothing to change my mind.
Earth 2 #1 - I honestly hadn't been reading any previews or interviews about this so I didn't really know what to expect. I thought it was essentially the New-52 JSA so I was surprised to see Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman front and center. I liked seeing Huntress as a young Robin and daughter of Bruce Wayne but she and Supergirl/Power Girl flew away for their own title, which I didn't buy. Maybe I'll try it another day but I doubt it. As for this issue itself I thought it was good. I was disappointed the big 3 were the main draw but the story ended up being good and the three of them biting the big one making way for the JSA (as shown with a young Jay Garrick in the end) really makes this interesting for me. I'm liking the first issue and will likely be back for the second provided I can make the finances work.
Dial H #1 - This one was a spirt of the moment try and I'm glad I did. I didn't know what the actual premise was but I read that the writer was nervous about it and I just felt compelled to help the guy out (wierd right? That was honestly going on in my head when I decided to buy it). It ended up being a pretty good read. The main character is an obese man who's let himself go due to having lost his job and girl. He's just had a heart attack and just isn't taking care of himself. He has a friend looking out for him who's apparently a drug dealer or something shady like that and it gets him in trouble. The obese man tries to help by calling the police in a phone booth and becomes a creepy but cool character and stops them. He does it again to become another character later on and we're getting the idea that he's becoming addicted to the power trips.
It was a very good issue and holds the bar of good Dark titles like Swamp Thing and Animal Man (and to a lesser degree, Justice League Dark). I'm not typically a fan of overly dark titles, resulting in my dropping Animal Man, despite the good quality, and Swamp Thing, though I've returned to it for now, but this premise has me curious enough to come back for a couple more issues to see where it goes. Good debut.
Swamp Thing #9 - As I said, I dropped this book but missed it and came back. I'm still not a fan of how dark it is (not my thing but it's what's to be expected) but the plot has been great. This seems like the conclusion to the first large arc and it was definately entertaining. I'm glad Abigail isn't stuck in this ugly bug creature form and I liked where the title went. I'm still a bit wierded out by Swamp Thing having horns or whatever but I can get used to it. The title is good, though the darkness still leaves a bad taste in my mouth, but it's good enough to keep me on for now.
X-Men #28 - I was questioning picking up this arc but figured I'd give it a shot. It didn't really wow me so I doubt I'll continue it. I guess I"ll probably call this one of the Adjectiveless X-Men skip arcs.
The premise is that there's a few straggler Skrulls from Secret Invasion. 3 of the 4 were deserters and just wanted to go home. The 4th was a loyalist and still wants to make the Earthers pay. They trick Pixie into taking them to get the objects needed for their escape from Earth but the loyal Skrull has other plans. Guest staring the Fantastic Four and Spider-Man.
Eh, not great. Bored. Moving on.
X-Factor #235 - While the cover is fantastic I was a little bored by the interior. Jamie and Havoc butt heads over how the team should handle the newest situation and Longshot is hurt while trying to read a video camera of a slain "local superhero." Jamie and Shatterstar then don not so subtle costumes and infiltrate the hero's team. It was fun but the story's only 2 issues long and I'm glad for that. David has a habbit of expanding the stories I don't care for for six or seven issues.
Defenders #6 - I'm torn on this issue. My love of the Immortal Iron Fist makes me cheer for the comic that focuses on Danny and the Immortal Weapons. I'm ticked though because of how most of them were just wiped off the map behind the scenes. The two biggest names, Fat Cobra & Prince of Orphans, are left alive (Davos also being absent) but we lose Dog Brother, Bride of Nine Spiders, and Tiger's Beautiful Daughter. Tiger and Dog Brother I'm indifferent about because they weren't that spectacular, but Bride of Nine Spiders was very interesting and had a lot of potential. She was wierd though so hopefully she'll be back. The biggest gripe though is Prince of Orphans going the "bad guy" route, having killed the 3 Immortal Weapons, 4 if Danny hadn't saved Fat Cobra. I guess I'll see how it all resolves but I really don't like the path Fraction's laying out for Aman.
The Machine doohicky plot is finally starting to interest me, 6 issues in.
Avengers vs. X-Men #3 - I don't know, about on par with the previous issues. Not bad, not good. Cap randomly decking Wolverine and planning on dropping him in the Antarctic due to his unpredictableness was just poor writing in my opinion. It felt VERY unCap-like and it took me out of the story. I was excited for this event but so far I'm bored. Bendis delivered an alright first issue, Aaron failed last issue, and Brubaker was somewhere between them for issue 3... none of them that fantastic. Oh well, we'll see where it all goes.
Avengers Academy #29 - This issue was just mediocre for me. Gage doesn't have any sort of grasp on X-23's character and how the kids are handled is stupid. The X-kids are not prisoners but if they try to escape attack them and stop them?! I just don't like how that was handled in the slightest. I honestly hope the X-Kids just kick the living crap out of everyone and leave but that won't happen. I think detaining children against their will by force "for their own good" is a bit too underhanded for the Avengers and make them look about as bad as the rest of the event has made both them and the X-Men look. The whole event has so far just made both sides appear rediculous and out of character.
Honestly, the only part I liked about the issue was Sebastian Shaw and all he does. I thought the scene with the book was slick and I loved the homage of the last page. I'll be back for the remainder of this tie-in but am eager for it to be finished already.
Age of Apocalypse #3 - I'm not seeing myself sticking with this for much longer. I'm interested in the return of dead AoAers but the plot just isn't doing it for me. I find Jean and Sabretooth to be boring and none the humans save Prophet are interesting. The one character I saw in this issue that made me excited was Abyss and he died before he was able to be resurrected.
I'm honestly bored of this title and with having to cut some fat I think this book will be one of them. I might give it another issue or two to pull me in but we'll see.
Best and Worst of the Week
Best: Dial H - As a complete shocker, I realized that I enjoyed this book the most this week. Now granted, it was a pretty crappy week so it didn't have much competition. It was a solid debut though and worth a read for anyone willing to try new stuff. It's new reader friendly... give it a shot.
Worst: Age of Apocalypse - I'm just very indifferent about this book and this issue did nothing to change my mind.