Okay, here's the thing about The Stand miniseries from 1994. It's really NOT bad for what it is. It's 17 years old, it was made-for-TV, it had a considerably low budget. These things are not the fault of anyone in particular.
When you're adapting a 1,000+ page book, you can't make a cinematic masterpiece, when 1) It's going to be over 6 hours, and 2) It's going to be on TV. If it's going to be 6 hours (which it should be), the budget for proper equipment is impossible. It was shot on 96 locations in 6 states with over 110 actors with speaking roles, and it was shot over 5 months. You can't expect Gone With The Wind.
And regarding Mick Garris... give him a break. Stephen King wrote the script for the miniseries, and was with Garris every step of the way during the production. King knew what he was doing, and was very enthusiastic about it (he even acted in the movie). If you listen to the commentary on the DVD, King loved the miniseries.
Secondly, because of its made-for-TV budget, the movie was shot on 16mm. They couldn't afford 35mm, which is the film used for almost all movies. 16mm is what makes the movie look crappy. It has no style or fancy cinematography. Really, "cinematography" is virtually non-existent in this miniseries. There aren't any amazing camera angles or intriguing lighting, and most of the shots of characters speaking are simple close-ups from the shoulders up.
In other words, any time you try to adapt a 1,000+ page novel into a 6 hour TV movie, and you're only given 5 months to do it, it's destined to fail.
So, having said that, this new Hollywood version from WB might not be better. I'm not sure how Steve Kloves could write a better script since Stephen King himself already wrote a script (and you would think that King of all people could adapt his own material), and I'm really pumped about David Yates directing.
This is what I'm excited about:
- The possibility of making it R-rated.
- More freedom from the studio.
- A bigger budget.
- A better director.
- Better cinematography. This is the important one, because the miniseries didn't have it.
As far as the cast goes, you can't get much more epic than the combined effort of Gary Sinise, Ruby Dee, Ed Harris, Kathy Bates, Rob Lowe, and so on. I loved that cast.
Even as I finish writing this, I have to give props to Mick Garris, honestly. That dude had a monumental task, and the pressure must've been incredible.