Marvel x DC: Voting game (NOT A FIGHT THREAD)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Mar 30, 2006
Messages
14,720
Reaction score
8
Points
33
corneillie-supes-spidey.jpg


Hosted by Venom.X

Popularity contest game where you vote for which side, Marvel or DC, you like more. All rounds are hosted only by me (Venom.X) unless stated otherwise. Rounds can involve characters, teams, story arcs, concepts, devices, writers, artists, etc...PM me any suggestions or requests.
Approved by TheCorpulent1

Results for Rounds 1-300
Spider-Man x Superman (winner)
Norman Osborn (Thunderbolts director) (winner) x Lex Luthor (post-presidency)
Iron Man (winner) x Batman
Doctor Octopus x Joker (winner)
Ms. Marvel x Wonder Woman (Diana Prince) (winner)
Lizard (winner) x Man-Bat
Hulk x Green Lantern (Hal Jordan) (winner)
Daredevil (winner) x Nightwing
Ghost Rider (Johnny Blaze)(winner) x Blue Devil
Arcade (winner) x Toyman
Secret Wars (winner) x Crisis on Infinite Earths
Mary-Jane Wattson-Parker (winner) x Lois Lane-Kent
The Classic Uncanny X-Men (winner) x The New Teen Titans
Black Cat (winner) x Catwoman (Selina Kyle)
Magneto x Black Adam (winner)
(TIE) Venom (Eddie Brock) x Bizarro (TIE)
Sandman (winner) x Clayface (Basil Karlo)
Tigra (winner) x Cheetah (Barbara Minerva)
Spider-Woman (Jessica Drew) x Batgirl (Barbara Gordon) (winner)
Ultron (winner) x Brainiac (Modern Age)
Bullseye (winner) x Deadshot
X-Men TAS x Batman TAS (winner)
Earth X series x Kingdom Come (winner)
Mephisto (winner) x Trigon
(TIE) Thanos x Darkseid (TIE)
Namor the Submariner (winner) x Aquaman (Orin)
Taskmaster x Deathstroke the Terminator (winner)
Hawkeye (Clint Barton) (winner) x Green Arrow (Oliver Queen)
The Clone Saga (in its entirety) x The Death of Superman/The Reign of the Supermen/The Return of Superman (winner)
Aunt May (winner) x Martha & Jonathan Kent
The Owl x The Penguin (winner)
Black Panther (winner) x Black Lightning
Edwin Jarvis x Alfred Pennyworth (winner)
Carnage (winner) x Doomsday
The Mandarin (winner) x Sinestro
War Machine (winner) x Steel
Deathlok (any one of them) (winner) x Cyborg
Sentry (Robert Reynolds) x Triumph (winner)
Black Tarantula (winner) x Hush
The Hand (winner) x The League of Assassins
Deadpool (winner) x Lobo
Arachne (Julia Carpenter) (winner) x Batwoman (The modern Katherine "Kate" Kane one)
Ben Reilly x Jean-Paul Valley (winner)
James "Bucky" Barnes (winner) x Jason Todd
Kree-Skrull War (winner) x Rann-Thanagar War
Jigsaw x Two-Face (winner)
Henry "Hank" Pym (winner) x Ray Palmer
Crossbones (winner) x Atomic Skull (Joseph Martin)
(TIE) Spider-Man: The Animated Series x Superman: The Animated Series (TIE)
Captain America, Iron Man, & Thor (winner) x Superman, Batman, & Wonder Woman
Nova (winner) x Blue Beetle (Jaime Reyes)
Miles Warren (winner) x Emil Hamilton
Squirrel Girl x The Creeper (winner)
Luke Cage x Mr. Terrific (winner)
The Guardians of the Galaxy (winner) x The Legion of Superheroes
Young Avengers (Current roster) (winner) x Teen Titans (Current roster)
Joseph "Robbie" Robertson x Lucius Fox (winner)
Iron Fist (winner) x Bronze Tiger
The Vision x Martian Manhunter (winner)
The Villainous History of Dr. Doom (winner) x The Villainous History of Lex Luthor
J. Jonah Jameson (winner) x Perry White
Galactus (winner) x The Anti-Monitor
Civil War (winner) x Infinite Crisis
Ares (Marvel) x Ares (DC) (winner)
Captain Mar-Vell x Captain Marvel (winner)
Spider-Man: Chapter One x Man of Steel (winner)
(TIE) Thunderbolts x Suicide Squad (TIE)
Rogue (winner) x Vixen
Gravity x Booster Gold (winner)
The Supernaturals x Shadowpact (winner)
Scarlet Witch (winner) x Raven
Fantastic Four (winner) x Doom Patrol
Swamp Thing (winner) x Man-Thing
Spider-Man & Venom: Maximum Carnage video game (winner) x The Death & Return of Superman video game
Marvel Knights Spider-Man 1-12 x Batman 608-619 (winner)
She-Hulk (winner) x Power Girl
Cloak & Dagger (winner) x Hawk & Dove (Hank & Don Hall)
Kang the Conqueror (winner) x Vandal Savage
Scarecrow (Marvel) x Scarecrow (DC) (winner)
Wolf Cub x Timber Wolf (winner)
Mark Bagley's Spider-Man x Jim Lee's Batman (winner)
Quicksilver (winner) x Max Mercury
Mojo (winner) x Egg Fu (Chang Tzu)
Fin Fang Foom x Mr. Mind (winner)
Eye-Scream x Animal-Vegetable-Mineral Man (winner)
Spider-Ham (winner) x Captain Carrot
Mystique (winner) x Poison Ivy
Lady Deathstrike x Lady Shiva (winner)
Echo x Cassandra Cain (winner)
The Leader x Gorilla Grodd (winner)
Wolverine x Batman (winner)
(TIE) Daken x Damian Wayne (TIE)
Sinister Six x Rogues Gallery (winner)
Venom (MacDonald Gargan) x Bane (winner)
Karen Page x Sue Dibney (winner)
The Inhumans (winner) x The New Gods
The Weapon X Project (winner) x Project C.A.D.M.U.S.
Masterminds of Evil x Injustice League (winner)
The Ultimate Universe x The Wildstorm Universe (DC owned) (winner)
The Avengers (winner) x Justice League of America
Spider-Man & his Amazing Friends (winner) x Superfriends
Peter Parker (winner) x Wally West
Punisher (winner) x Hitman
"I'm the Juggernaut, *****!" (winner) x "I'm the goddamn Batman!"
Elektra (winner) x Talia al Ghul
Doctor Doom (winner) x The Joker
Storm (Queen of Wakanda, Bride of T'Challa) (winner) x Vixen
Black Panther (winner) x Mr. Terrific
Sabretooth (winner) x Cheetah (Modern Era)
Moonstone (winner) x Star Sapphire (Carol Ferris)
Quasar's Quantum Bands x Green Lantern's Power Ring (winner)
Latveria (winner) x Apokolips
Nova Corps x The Green Lantern Corps (winner)
Annihilation (winner) x Sinestro Corp Wars
Phoenix Force (winner) x Ion
Jean Grey x Starfire (winner)
Gambit x Grifter (winner)
X-Men Legends (winner) x Justice League Heroes
Ultimate Avengers (winner) x Brainiac Attacks
"The Alien Costume Saga" x "The World's Finest" (winner)
"Hulk" x "Titans" (winner)
"New Exiles" x "Booster Gold" (winner)
MAX x Vertigo (winner)
"Secret War" x "Identity Crisis" (winner)
Joe Quesada (winner) x Dan DiDio
Rick Jones (winner) x Jimmy Olsen
The Impossible Man (winner) x Mr. Mxyzptlk
Stilt-Man (winner) x Kite-Man
The Invaders x Justice Society of America (winner)
Next Avengers: The Heroes of Tomorrow x Justice League: The New Frontier (winner)
The Death of Captain America (winner) x The Death of Superman
"World War Hulk" x "World War III" (52) (winner)
Benjamin Grimm (The Thing) (winner) x Hal Jordan (Green Lantern)
Squadron Supreme (winner) x Champions of Angor
Loki (winner) x Black Adam
Heroes for Hire x Birds of Prey (winner)
Dr. Strange (winner) x Dr. Fate
The Spider-Mobile x Krypto the Superdog (winner)
Marvel Knights x The Outsiders (winner)
Songbird (winner) x Silver Swan
(TIE) Mysterio x Mirror Master (TIE)
Electro (winner) x Dr. Light
Eddie Brock's motivations against Spider-Man (winner) vs. Tommy Elliot's motivations against Batman
Vermin x Killer Croc (winner)
Apocalypse x Darkseid (winner)
Onslaught x Imperiex (winner)
X3: The Last Stand (winner) x Superman Returns
Miguel O'Hara x Terry McGinnis (winner)
Spider-Man: Web of Shadows (winner) x Mortal Kombat vs. DC Universe
"New Ways to Die" x "Batman R.I.P." (winner)
BND Villains x The International Club of Villains (winner)
The Comraderie of Captain America & Iron Man x The Comraderie of Superman & Batman (winner)
The Vulture x The Penguin (winner)
Abomination (winner) x Doomsday
Thor (winner) x Superman
Norman Osborn x Lex Luthor (winner) Redux
The Uncanny X-Men (winner) x The Teen Titans Redux
Ultron (winner) x (The "Real") Brainiac Redux
Rick Jones (as A-Bomb) (winner) x Jimmy Olsen (as Mr. Action) Redux
Thunderbolts (Current + "Dark Reign) (winner) x Suicide Squad Redux
The Big 3 x Trinity (winner) (Round 50 Redux)
Red Hulk x Red Robin (Current) (winner)
"The Amazing Spider-Girl" x "Blue Beetle Vol. 3" (winner)
The Reinvention of MacDonald Gargan x The Reinvention of Thomas Blake (winner)
Noh-Varr x Kon-El (winner)
Nova (winner) x Green Lantern (Hal Jordan)
The Train Scene (Spider-Man 2) (winner) x The Kryptonite Continent Scene (Superman Returns)
"The Death of Gwen Stacy" (winner) x "The Killing Joke"
Tombstone x Solomon Grundy (winner)
"Ultimate Power" (winner) x "DC/Wildstorm: Dreamwar"
"Weapon X" story x "The Dark Knight Returns" (winner)
"Marvels" x "Watchmen" (winner)
Steve Rogers (winner) x Superman
Sentry (winner) x Ultraman
(TIE) Iron Man x The Dark Knight (TIE)
Cloak & Dagger (winner) x Harley Quinn & Poison Ivy
Sabretooth (winner) x Killer Croc
Wilson Fisk (winner) x The Black Mask
Gorilla-man (winner) x Congorilla
Loki (Current Form) (winner) x Morgaine Le Fey
Hydro-Man x Mr. Freeze (winner)
Tiger Shark x Black Manta (winner)
Emma Frost x Selina Kyle (winner)
Marvel's Brian Michael Bendis x DC's Grant Morrison (winner)
Earth X Venom x Kingdom Come Power Girl (winner)
Cyclops (winner) x Robin (Tim Drake)
The Thing (winner) x Cyborg
Nightcrawler (winner) x Beast Boy
Pete Wisdom x John Constantine (winner)
Doctor Octopus (Otto Octavius) (winner) x Captain Cold (Lenard Start)
Doctor Doom (winner) x Darksied
Beetle (winner) x Firefly
Shriek (winner) x Livewire
Absorbing Man x Metamorpho (winner)
Super-Skrull (winner) x Amazo
The Watcher (winner) x Metron
Mephisto (winner) x Neron
The Infinity Gauntlet (winner) x The Anti-Life Equation
Earth X Captain America x Kingdom Come Superman (winner)
Golden Age Captain America, Namor, and the Human Torch (winner) x Golden Age Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman
Spider-Man's Identity Crisis (winner) x Superman Red/Blue
Venom (Eddie Brock) (winner) x The Parasite (Rudy Jones)
The Sinister Six (winner) x The Secret Six
Spider-Man & Johnny Storm (winner) x Wally West & Kyle Rayner
Stingray x Aquaman (Arthur Joseph Curry) (winner)
The Whizzer (Robert Frank) x The Flash (Jay Garrick) (winner)
Mr. Sinister (winner) x Mongul
Eugene "Flash" Thompson (winner) x Pete Ross
The Fantasticar x The Batmobile (winner)
Invisible Woman (winner) x Wonder Woman
The Odinforce and Mjolnir (winner) x The Power of Shazam
Ragnarok x Bizarro (winner)
Doppelganger (winner) x Composite Superman
"House of M" x "Infinite Crisis" (winner)
Scarlet Witch's Effects on Reality (House of M and afterwards) (winner) x Superboy-Prime's Effects on Reality (Infinite Crisis and afterwards)
"Secret Invasion" (winner) x "Final Crisis"
Queen Veranke (winner) x Libra
The Death of Janet Van Dyne (Secret Invasion) x The "Death"(?) of Batman (Final Crisis) (winner)
Dark Reign (As of January 2009) (winner) x Faces of Evil
The Spider-Man 60's theme song (winner) x The Batman 60's theme song
Wolverine x Wildcat (winner)
Wolverine (Daken) x Wildcat (Tommy Bronson) (winner)
X-23 x Batgirl (Cassandra Cain) (winner)
Wakanda (winner) x Themyscira
The Wedding of Black Panther & Storm x The Wedding of Green Arrow & Black Canary (winner)
The Green Goblin (Harry Osborn) x Two-Face (winner)
"Maximum Carnage" x "The Death & Return of Superman" (winner)
Betty Brant-Leeds (winner) x Lana Lang-Ross
Reed Richards (winner) x Brainiac 5
The Leader (winner) x Ultra-Humanite
The Mandarin x Ra's Al Ghul (winner)
The Professor Hulk x Superman (winner)
Steve Rogers (winner) x Batman
Storm x Wonder Woman (winner)
Bone Claw Wolverine x Lobo (winner)
Ben Reilly x Kon-El (winner)
Jubilee x Tim Drake (winner)
Quicksilver x Wally West (winner)
The Silver Surfer (winner) x Kyle Rayner
Elektra x Catwoman (Selina Kyle) (winner)
Namor x Aquaman (Orin) (winner) Redux
Kate Bishop (Hawkeye) (winner) x Roy Harper (Red Arrow, Arsenal)
The Scorpion (MacDonald Gargan) (winner) x Doctor Light (Arthur Light)
The Scorpion (Carmilla Black) x Doctor Light (Kimiyo Hoshi) (winner)
Penance (winner) x Risk
Deathlok (Michael Collins) x Firestorm (Jason Rusch) (winner)
Vision (Current) (winner) x Red Tornado
"Hulk Vs." x "Wonder Woman: The Animated Movie" (winner)
Hulk (winner) x Wonder Woman
Spider-Man's Villains (winner) x The Flash's Rogues
The Deadly Foes of Spider-Man (Sinister Syndicate) (winner) x The Superman Revenge Squad
The Death of Aunt May (winner) x The Death of Jason Todd
Robbie Rider x Kilowog (winner)
Ego the Living Planet (winner) x Mogo
Worldmind x The Guardians of the Universe (winner)
Howard the Duck (winner) x Ambush Bug
Hammerhead (winner) x Bruno Mannheim
The Hobgoblin (Roderick Kingsley) (winner) x The Black Mask
Krakoa the Living Island (winner) x Dinosaur Island, the Centre
Ant-Man (Eric O'Grady) x The Atom (Ryan Choi) (winner)
Lily Hollister (winner) x Jezebel Jet
Morbius the Living Vampire x Solomon Grundy (winner)
Werewolf by Night (winner) x Blue Devil
Hellstorm x The Demon (winner)
Dracula (winner) x Frankenstein
"Archie Meets the Punisher" (winner) x "Superman vs. Muhammad Ali"
Moon Knight x Nightwing (winner)
Spider-Woman (winner) x Batwoman
The Death of Jean Grey (Dark Phoenix Saga) (winner) x The Death of Barry Allen (Crisis on Infinite Earths)
Purple Man (winner) x Dr. Psycho
Captain Universe x Captain Atom (winner)
Havok (winner) x Lightning Lad
Polaris (winner) x Saturn Girl
Vulcan (winner) x Superboy-Prime
Shang-Chi x Karate Kid (winner)
Luke Cage & Iron Fist (winner) x Green Lantern & Green Arrow
Aunt May x Alfred Pennyworth (winner)
Elektra: The Movie (winner) x Catwoman: The Movie
"Howard the Duck" (winner) x "Steel"
Radioactive Man (winner) x Dr. Phosphorous
Swarm x Parasite (Rudy Jones) (winner)
Arana x Blue Beetle (Jaime Reyes) (winner)
Tarantula (Anton Miguel Rodriguez) (winner) x Killer Moth/Charaxes (Drury Walker)
X-Men Evolution x Batman Beyond (winner)
“The Dark Phoenix Saga” (winner) x “The Judas Contract”
Sentinels (winner) x Manhunters
(TIE) Shuma-Gorath x Starro (TIE)
(TIE) Songbird x Black Canary Redux (TIE)
Mysterio (Quentin Beck) x The Riddler (winner)
Ares x Hawkman (Your Preferred Incarnation) (winner)
Anita Blake Series x Fables (winner)
Dr. Doom (winner) x Lex Luthor
Mr. Fear x Scarecrow (winner)
Marvel Girl (Rachel Summers) x Supergirl (Kara Zor-El) (winner)
The Fantastic Four (winner) x Justice Society of America
Noh-Varr (Captain Mar-Vell) x Freddy Freeman (Shazam) (winner)
Madelyn Pryor (winner) x Blackfire
Hercules (winner) x Aretmis
The Wedding of Peter Parker & Mary-Jane Wattson x The Wedding of Clark Kent & Lois Lane (winner)
Stan Lee (winner) x Julius Schwartz

Rounds after Round 300 can be found here.
Round 435
Robert Downey, Jr. as Tony Stark/Iron Man x Heath Ledger as The Joker
ironman.jpg

HeathJoker.png
 
Last edited:
Superman. I prefer a hero who knows how to be a hero to a bumbling idiot making deals with the devil and unmasking because his feelings of hopeless inadequacy causes him to seek out manipulative, conniving, evil, scheming bastards of father figures. I mean, there are enough mo'fackies like Peter Parker in real life. There are not nearly enough Clark Kents.
 
Superman, but only by a little bit now. Neither of them are all that appealing to me anymore. Joe Kelly and Greg Rucka are really the only writers who get me excited for Supes.
 
I can't believe I'm saying this but superman takes this one with the current spidey.
 
A couple of years ago I would've said Spidey, no contest. But right now, I'm going to go with Superman. I'd go into a whole rant about One More Day, but Aristotle said it perfectly.
 
Even under current status Spidey will always be my fave.
 
I never thought I would say this but; Superman.

The Spider-Man I loved died recently.
 
Geez, you'd think Spider-Man's comics would be selling less with the nearly universal panning he's receiving here...
 
General masses = dopes. We don't really represent the masses here :p
 
Superman. I prefer a hero who knows how to be a hero to a bumbling idiot making deals with the devil and unmasking because his feelings of hopeless inadequacy causes him to seek out manipulative, conniving, evil, scheming bastards of father figures. I mean, there are enough mo'fackies like Peter Parker in real life. There are not nearly enough Clark Kents.
Wow. Why so emotional about all this, hmm? Actually, given Clark's normal upbringing by midwest, God-fearing parents being a hero should come, well, more naturally. Now, Peter, on the other hand, as you kindly mentioned above, has his issues. And he's intelligent enough to be aware of them, as well as readers of the comic book world are aware that, yes, Peter has some daddy issues. Not to mention the @##holes he went to school with that bullied him that greatly contributed to his self-confidence...I guess what I'm driving at is that despite his many faults, Peter fights for what is right. And with far less power than Superman. Given Peter's lack and Clark's godlike powers, I'd say the real hero is Peter. Sure, Supes could beat Spidey in a fight. Everyone knows that. But as for who the is the more courageous hero, well, you tell me.
 
Superman. I prefer a hero who knows how to be a hero to a bumbling idiot making deals with the devil and unmasking because his feelings of hopeless inadequacy causes him to seek out manipulative, conniving, evil, scheming bastards of father figures. I mean, there are enough mo'fackies like Peter Parker in real life. There are not nearly enough Clark Kents.
Wow. Why so emotional about all this, hmm? Actually, given Clark's normal upbringing by midwest, God-fearing parents being a hero should come, well, more naturally. Now, Peter, on the other hand, as you kindly mentioned above, has his issues. And he's intelligent enough to be aware of them, as well as readers of the comic book world are aware that, yes, Peter has some daddy issues. Not to mention the @##holes he went to school with that bullied him that greatly contributed to his self-confidence...I guess what I'm driving at is that despite his many faults, Peter fights for what is right. And with far less power than Superman. Given Peter's lack and Clark's godlike powers, I'd say the real hero is Peter. Sure, Supes could beat Spidey in a fight. Everyone knows that. But as for who the is the more courageous hero, well, you tell me.
 
Wow. Why so emotional about all this, hmm? Actually, given Clark's normal upbringing by midwest, God-fearing parents being a hero should come, well, more naturally. Now, Peter, on the other hand, as you kindly mentioned above, has his issues. And he's intelligent enough to be aware of them, as well as readers of the comic book world are aware that, yes, Peter has some daddy issues. Not to mention the @##holes he went to school with that bullied him that greatly contributed to his self-confidence...I guess what I'm driving at is that despite his many faults, Peter fights for what is right. And with far less power than Superman. Given Peter's lack and Clark's godlike powers, I'd say the real hero is Peter. Sure, Supes could beat Spidey in a fight. Everyone knows that. But as for who the is the more courageous hero, well, you tell me.

Still Superman.
 
It has nothing at all to do with their respective power sets. What Peter was made to do in One More Day was downright disrespectful to the character.
 
The contest was rigged in Superman's favor in the first place. He's meant to be the inspiration to all heroes. Peter was built to be a relatable everyman. It only makes sense that Superman is more heroic overall.
 
Spider-man

Only because OMD/BND Spider-man doesn't exist to me.
 
The contest was rigged in Superman's favor in the first place. He's meant to be the inspiration to all heroes. Peter was built to be a relatable everyman. It only makes sense that Superman is more heroic overall.

It's not hard to be heroic when your virtually invulnerable and have almost every power there is. Supes is way to convenient and they often have to use stupid plot devices to give his villians any chance. He's always been extremely boring and often silly to me. Spidey goes up against badguys way more powerful than himself almost all the time. I personally find that far more heroic and inspirational.
 
Superman died in Infinite Crisis. So it's Spider-Man by default.
 
I find that Superman goes toe to toe with plenty of villains that can give him trouble, power-wise. Hell, just the last issue of Superman/Batman was Superman fighting about 4 people that were all trained by the government, and powered with Kryptonite, to best him in each area (Flight, strength, speed, etc). That issue ended with the reveal of All-American Boy, a Doomsday with Kryptonite bones protruding instead of the regular ones the original Doomsday had.

In any case, in the end, this is a popularity contest as stated in the opening post, and after OMD/BND Spidey's popularity is a bit waning.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
200,560
Messages
21,760,206
Members
45,597
Latest member
Netizen95
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"