ANTHONYNASTI said:I disagree with the OP.
The BB score was fine for the movie, but ultimately held little resonance and was ultimately forgettable IMO. One of the film's weaker elements. Elfman's score is vastly superior. As are many, many other great scores. Someone who claims the score for BB as the best score ever, even if they didn't necessarily mean it in some epistemological sense, obviously has not seen many movies, or at least hasn't heard many great scores.
strider said:Im working on my master in music performance and I can tell you that Elfman's scores were mainly fanfares that are not entirely difficult to come up with...Yes they are memorable and note wrothy but non the less werent every original of different from other heroic fan fare music.
Zimmerman and Newton-Howard are not only leading film composers but respected classical musicians. The BB is far superior in structure, music motives and uses more advanced harmony. They weret trying to give batman a theme per say...it was music to fit emotions, memories and certain elements of the movie...
strider said:I perfer the BB score over pervious Batman scores.
El Payaso said:This really sounds like you just-
Exactly. That I can agree with.
kakarot069 said:I love this score a lot as well... I love it SOOO much more than any other DC score out there right now.
I disagree... while the B89 soundtrack has the nostalgic feel to it, the new soundtrack gives it a more modern feel to it and at the same time gives it a very dark feel to it.Damiean Dark said:BB is sooo forgetable and at the end of the day soundtracks are made to be remembered and B89 Elfmans theme will always be remembered as THE Batman theme.
Are you talking about a score or a theme? BB didn't really have a theme. Which is something you can complain about, sure. But your post really doesn't address the quality of the score as a whole.jeffsbaker said:The Batman Begins score is not memorable enough. I think we need a poll: Which Batman music do you like best?
IMHO Batman and every other superhero movie needs a tremendous superhero score of heroic fanfare. You need to be able to just hang out with your friends and be able to remember the music and hum it and your friend says, Hey, your humming Batman.
The original 1989 Batman theme has a few notes that are memorable in that way.
strider said:Im working on my master in music performance....
CConn said:Are you talking about a score or a theme? BB didn't really have a theme. Which is something you can complain about, sure. But your post really doesn't address the quality of the score as a whole.
TempleFugit said:The score for Batman Begins, in my opinion, is better than Elfman's, as well as one of the best I've ever heard. As a major in music as well, I'm here to tell you that Elfman's was very simple and cliche, while Zimmer/Howard created ''moods'' in their music that were simply haunting.
In fact, the BB score HAUNTS me in my sleep. Late at night, I hum ''Molossus'' in my head... I hum Track 12 - the title escapes me - as well as Track 2. I swear to god, I have to get OUT OF MY BED and pop in the CD, or else I won't sleep. The soundtrack is.... a part of me. Being a music person, I'm not ashamed to admit that, lol. It's just brilliant all across the board. You could hear the first track, the tenth track, and then the twelfth, and you could swear that they were from three different movies if you hadn't seen BB.
As pieces of music, NOT related to a movie, they are brilliant classical pieces as well.
Elfman's score was very ''predictable''. I always knew where it was going. I dare say that anyone could've written it. The Animated Series had better music than B'89, in my opinion.