Thank you Dog Lips for your assistance.
I have disqualified the following votes from Darthphere.
Assassin 2, ATMA Weapon, Captain Marvelo, Roachman and Tallyman.
I have disqualified the following votes from jaguarr
morgana
kypade and Tangled Web made their votes known so minus 1 from Darthphere and 2 from jag.
That makes it 44 Darthphere to 46 jaguarr.
Now comes the tricky part,
Roughneck, Sabertooth, All Star Superman, BadgerPhil, BatBrain all voted 4 times and above.
If I discount all of them Darthphere wins by 1 vote.
If I include all of them, jaguaar wins by 1 vote.
Since no one has responded, I have no choice but to declare them both winners.
So congrats Darthphere and jaguarr, you have been chosen by your peers as the 2006 Hype Community Poster of the Year.
I know I totally ripped this from Not Jake but I could just edit it.
Congrats guys.