That's pretty funny CC. But that can happen. Take this... I am a huge fan of FARSCAPE, and frankly, was never into the BUFFYVERSE at all. Everything about the characters and the show has no appeal to me, while I can admit, the pop culture references can be fun, I just get nothing from the show itself. As such, I was not into Whedon enough to follow him to a new show. I read the ASTONISHING run of his X-MEN so I know he was talented as a writer, but I wasn't so enraptured that I would tune into his "space western".
Cut to a few years later and a friend gifts me for Christmas the complete set of FIREFLY. "Uh... What's this for?" "You are a huge FIREFLY fan, right? Here's the whole series." "Dude... I'm into FARSCAPE. I've never seen FIREFLY." "Oh... Well it's a good show. You should check it out." And so the collection stayed in my locker for close to a year and half or more. Finally I decided to give it shot not knowing the cult following and man, instant conversion from the first episode.