I just saw a YouTube comment on New Rockstars breakdown for this episode that suggested the rat living inside SM-33’s head of being the actual captain, and the more I think about it, the more I’m now seriously considering this as an actual possibility.
I mean, when Jod asks SM-33 about At Attin the first time in this episode, after he says his usual “Can’t say I remember no At Attin”, smoke immediately starts coming from his head, most likely from the rat messing with his internal workings, almost like it was trying to stop him. In the very first episode, SM-33 was looking for the captain, meaning he wasn’t on the ship anywhere among the dead or else he would’ve spotted him, so there’s a possibility the captain might still be alive somehow, or he just doesn’t remember due to his memory being blocked by that command given to him. Either way, if he can’t remember anything pertaining to At Attin, including the captain and his identity, then of course he wouldn’t know what he looks like to recognize him.
I mean, as we’ve seen in this show so far, it likes to play with typical storytelling conventions/tropes and our expectations of what usually happens in tales like this. The planet of lost treasure being the actual home of the main characters that they have to get back to, Jod being a pirate who pretends to be a Jedi but isn’t actually a Jedi but can use the Force, etc. So, the equivalent of the parrot sitting on the Captain’s shoulder, the rat that’s with them all of the time, actually being the “lost” captain would not be entirely out of the question. And what better way to hide something than putting it in plain sight, right in front of us without realizing it, not unlike a certain planet holding a certain treasure right under everyone’s noses for our crew to find.
It sounds ridiculous, but I would not be surprised if this theory actually pans out.
