World Spider-Man Elimination Game (Round 23 - Best Spidey Artists)

[Themanofbat]

Spider-Man Elimination Game (Round 23 - Best Spidey Artists)

Welcome to Round 23!

It's the same rules as before. You take a point off a character you don't like and put it on a character you do. The last character remaining with points wins! Also you can only post once every 60 minutes just to give everyone a chance.

Keith Pollard - 10
Ron Frenz - 10
Todd MacFarlane - 10
Eric Larsen - 10
Marc Bagley - 10
John Romita Jr. - 10
Ross Andru - 10
John Byrne - 10
Mike Deodato - 10
Mark Texiera - 10

For obvious reasons, both Ditko & Romita Sr. are not included, as they are beyond a shadow of doubt, THE best Spidey artists ever.

This Round was suggested to be played by various players until Quentin Beck returns and is by no means ANY disrespect to QB.

We wish him well and a speedy return to the Hype.​

 

[Themanofbat]

Keith Pollard - 10
Ron Frenz - 10
Todd MacFarlane - 10
Eric Larsen - 9 (-)
Marc Bagley - 10
John Romita Jr. - 10
Ross Andru - 11 (+)
John Byrne - 10
Mike Deodato - 10
Mark Texiera - 10

 

[Iceman]

For obvious reasons, both Ditko & Romita Sr. are not included, as they are beyond a shadow of doubt, THE best Spidey artists ever.

This Round was suggested to be played by various players until Quentin Beck returns and is by no means ANY disrespect to QB.

We wish him well and a speedy return to the Hype.​

You make it sound like QB has a terminal illness. Here's hoping that he gets back to full health as soon as possible.

Keith Pollard - 10
Ron Frenz - 10
Todd MacFarlane - 11 (+)
Eric Larsen - 8 (-)
Marc Bagley - 10
John Romita Jr. - 10
Ross Andru - 11
John Byrne - 10
Mike Deodato - 10
Mark Texiera - 10

 

[Iceman]

Keith Pollard - 10
Ron Frenz - 10
Todd MacFarlane - 12 (+)
Eric Larsen - 7 (-)
Marc Bagley - 10
John Romita Jr. - 10
Ross Andru - 11
John Byrne - 10
Mike Deodato - 10
Mark Texiera - 10

 

[Norman Osborn]

This Round was suggested to be played by various players until Quentin Beck returns and is by no means ANY disrespect to QB.

We wish him well and a speedy return to the Hype.
​

​

Is there actually something wrong with QB?

Oh and a little help....who drew that god awful cover whith Spidey and Electro and it looks like it's freaking snowing?

 

[Themanofbat]

Is there actually something wrong with QB?

Oh and a little help....who drew that god awful cover whith Spidey and Electro and it looks like it's freaking snowing?

Klaus Janson... not his best work.

He's better known for inking Frank Miller's original DareDevil work.

 

[Themanofbat]

Keith Pollard - 10
Ron Frenz - 10
Todd MacFarlane - 12
Eric Larsen - 6 (-)
Marc Bagley - 10
John Romita Jr. - 10
Ross Andru - 12 (+)
John Byrne - 10
Mike Deodato - 10
Mark Texiera - 10

 

[Electro UK]

Is there actually something wrong with QB?

Oh and a little help....who drew that god awful cover whith Spidey and Electro and it looks like it's freaking snowing?

The one where Spidey just looks fat with short arms? I hate that cover.

 

[Norman Osborn]

The one where Spidey just looks fat with short arms? I hate that cover.

No that's my wedding picture!!!

 

[Iceman]

Keith Pollard - 10
Ron Frenz - 10
Todd MacFarlane - 13 (+)
Eric Larsen - 5 (-)
Marc Bagley - 10
John Romita Jr. - 10
Ross Andru - 12
John Byrne - 10
Mike Deodato - 10
Mark Texiera - 10

 

[Themanofbat]

Keith Pollard - 10
Ron Frenz - 10
Todd MacFarlane - 13
Eric Larsen - 4 (-)
Marc Bagley - 10
John Romita Jr. - 10
Ross Andru - 13 (+)
John Byrne - 10
Mike Deodato - 10
Mark Texiera - 10

 

[WolfCypher]

Keith Pollard - 10
Ron Frenz - 9 (-)
Todd MacFarlane - 13
Eric Larsen - 4
Marc Bagley - 11 (+)
John Romita Jr. - 10
Ross Andru - 13
John Byrne - 10
Mike Deodato - 10
Mark Texiera - 10

 

[Iceman]

Keith Pollard - 10
Ron Frenz - 8 (-)
Todd MacFarlane - 14 (+)
Eric Larsen - 4
Marc Bagley - 11
John Romita Jr. - 10
Ross Andru - 13
John Byrne - 10
Mike Deodato - 10
Mark Texiera - 10

 

[JackSkellington]

Keith Pollard - 10
Ron Frenz - 7 [-]
Todd MacFarlane - 14
Eric Larsen - 4
Marc Bagley - 12 [+]
John Romita Jr. - 10
Ross Andru - 13
John Byrne - 10
Mike Deodato - 10
Mark Texiera - 10

 

[WolfCypher]

Keith Pollard - 10
Ron Frenz - 6 (-)
Todd MacFarlane - 14
Eric Larsen - 4
Marc Bagley - 13 (+)
John Romita Jr. - 10
Ross Andru - 13
John Byrne - 10
Mike Deodato - 10
Mark Texiera - 10

 

[Kirk Langstrom]

Pollard 6
Frenz 10
Mcfarlane 14
Larsen 4
Bagley 13
Junior 10
Andru 14 (+)
Byrne 9 (-)
Deodato 10
Texiera 10

 

[Kirk Langstrom]

No Gil Kane?

By virtue of his work on the infamous "Drug issues", the co-creation of Morbius, and The Death Of Gwen/Goblin, Kane has brought more to the Spider-Man mythos than Byrne, Deodato, and Texiera COMBINED.

No offense to him or his fans, but i have no idea why Byrne would even be on this list. Certainly not due to his lackluster work on Chapter One, and the re-vamp....

Oh well.

 

[Themanofbat]

No Gil Kane?

By virtue of his work on the infamous "Drug issues", the co-creation of Morbius, and The Death Of Gwen/Goblin, Kane has brought more to the Spider-Man mythos than Byrne, Deodato, and Texiera COMBINED.

No offense to him or his fans, but i have no idea why Byrne would even be on this list. Certainly not due to his lackluster work on Chapter One, and the re-vamp....

Oh well.

You know, I knew I was forgetting someone...

 

[Themanofbat]

Pollard 10
Frenz 6
Mcfarlane 14
Larsen 3 (-)
Bagley 13
Junior 10
Andru 15 (+)
Byrne 9
Deodato 10
Texiera 10

 

[WolfCypher]

Pollard 10
Frenz 5 (-)
Mcfarlane 14
Larsen 3
Bagley 14 (+)
Junior 10
Andru 15
Byrne 9
Deodato 10
Texiera 10

 

[Kirk Langstrom]

You know, I knew I was forgetting someone...

Lol. Well, maybe we can do ANOTHER round of artists, and Gil can be on that one....Gil, Sal Buscema, etc.,...

Anyway;

Pollard 10
Frenz 5
McFarlane 14
Larsen 3
Bagley 14
Junior 10
Andru 16 (+)
Byrne 8 (-)
Deodato 10
Texiera 10

 

[WolfCypher]

The tally is now

Pollard 10
Frenz 5
Mcfarlane 14
Larsen 3
Bagley 14
Junior 10
Andru 16
Byrne 8
Deodato 10
Texiera 10

 

[Mister J]

Keith Pollard - 10
Ron Frenz - 5
Todd MacFarlane - 14
Eric Larsen - 2 (-)
Marc Bagley - 14
John Romita Jr. - 10
Ross Andru - 17 (+)
John Byrne - 8
Mike Deodato - 10
Mark Texiera - 10

 

[Kraven]

Keith Pollard - 10
Ron Frenz - 5
Todd MacFarlane - 15 (+)
Eric Larsen - 2
Marc Bagley - 14
John Romita Jr. - 10
Ross Andru - 17
John Byrne - 7 (-)
Mike Deodato - 10
Mark Texiera - 10

 

[Ebil Gig]

Keith Pollard - 10
Ron Frenz - 4 (-)
Todd MacFarlane - 15
Eric Larsen - 2
Marc Bagley - 14
John Romita Jr. - 10
Ross Andru - 18 (+)
John Byrne - 7
Mike Deodato - 10
Mark Texiera - 10