The DC Heroes Eliminations (round 3)

[Kitsune]

Zatanna +
Firestorm -

1 Zatanna 14
2 Elongated Man 3
3 Firestorm 7
4 Phantom Strager 16
5 Mister Miracle 10
6 Flash 14
7 Animal Man 15
8 Plastic Man 19

 

[Obi-Ron]

Zatanna +
Elongated Man -

1 Zatanna 15
2 Elongated Man 2
3 Firestorm 7
4 Phantom Stranger 16
5 Mister Miracle 10
6 Flash 14
7 Animal Man 15
8 Plastic Man 19

 

[Stallion9979]

Flash +
Elongated Man -

1 Zatanna 15
2 Elongated Man 1
3 Firestorm 7
4 Phantom Stranger 16
5 Mister Miracle 10
6 Flash 15
7 Animal Man 15
8 Plastic Man 19

 

[Kitsune]

Zatanna +
Firestorm -

1 Zatanna 16
2 Elongated Man 1
3 Firestorm 6
4 Phantom Stranger 16
5 Mister Miracle 10
6 Flash 15
7 Animal Man 15
8 Plastic Man 19

 

[Aristotle]

Phantom Stranger +
Elongated Man -

#1 Zatanna 16
#3 Elongated Man 0
#4 Firestorm 6
#5 Phantom Stranger 17
#6 Mister Miracle 10
#8 Flash (Jay Garrick) 15
#9 Animal Man 15
#10 Plastic Man 19

 

[Stallion9979]

Flash +
Firestorm -

1 Zatanna 16
2 Firestorm 5
3 Phantom Stranger 17
4 Mister Miracle 10
5 Flash 16
6 Animal Man 15
7 Plastic Man 19

 

[The Man of Steel]

Zatanna -
Plastic Man +

1 Zatanna 15
3 Firestorm 6
4 Phantom Stranger 17
5 Mister Miracle 10
6 Flash 16
7 Animal Man 15
8 Plastic Man 20

 

[Aristotle]

My post seems to have been missed, as was Stallion's. Stallion, I'd killed Elongated Man already, so you still have a negative to give someone.

Pending that, here's what the rankings look like.

#1 Zatanna 15
#4 Firestorm 6
#5 Phantom Stranger 17
#6 Mister Miracle 10
#8 Flash (Jay Garrick) 16
#9 Animal Man 15
#10 Plastic Man 20

 

[Iceman]

plastic Man +
Firestorm -

#1 Zatanna 15
#4 Firestorm 5
#5 Phantom Stranger 17
#6 Mister Miracle 10
#8 Flash (Jay Garrick) 16
#9 Animal Man 15
#10 Plastic Man 21

 

[Obi-Ron]

Zatanna +
Plastic Man -

#1 Zatanna 16
#4 Firestorm 5
#5 Phantom Stranger 17
#6 Mister Miracle 10
#8 Flash (Jay Garrick) 16
#9 Animal Man 15
#10 Plastic Man 20

 

[Aristotle]

Stallion's negative on Firestorm hasn't been added.

Adjusted:
#1 Zatanna 16
#4 Firestorm 4
#5 Phantom Stranger 17
#6 Mister Miracle 10
#8 Flash (Jay Garrick) 16
#9 Animal Man 15
#10 Plastic Man 20

Somehow we're already two points short. Damn.

 

[Stallion9979]

people and basic math....help us Jeebus!!!

 

[Kitsune]

Stallion's negative on Firestorm hasn't been added.

Adjusted:
#1 Zatanna 16
#4 Firestorm 4
#5 Phantom Stranger 17
#6 Mister Miracle 10
#8 Flash (Jay Garrick) 16
#9 Animal Man 15
#10 Plastic Man 20

Somehow we're already two points short. Damn.

We've been 2 point short for a while now. Last time I tried to correct for that kind of thing I had someone ignore me, and I'm not exactly sure where to put those points... I'd put them in Zatanna, but that's not really fair.

 

[Aristotle]

Let's just leave it. I might have time to go back and try to rejigger this whole thing, but not now.

 

[The Man of Steel]

Plastic Man +
Zatanna -

#1 Zatanna 15
#4 Firestorm 4
#5 Phantom Stranger 17
#6 Mister Miracle 10
#8 Flash (Jay Garrick) 16
#9 Animal Man 15
#10 Plastic Man 21

 

[Kitsune]

Firestorm-
Zatanna +

#1 Zatanna 16
#4 Firestorm 3
#5 Phantom Stranger 17
#6 Mister Miracle 10
#8 Flash (Jay Garrick) 16
#9 Animal Man 15
#10 Plastic Man 21

Actually I suppose depending on how anal you get this should be

Zatana 17
Plastic Man 20 because man of steal voted early.... but honestly I think 5 minutes is probably a good cutof point.

 

[Kingfish]

alright, i was bored so i went through and fixed it. heres the new total. watch the math people.

#1 Zatanna 17
#2 Firestorm 4
#3 Stranger 17
#4 Miracle 10
#5 Flash 16
#6 Animal man 15
#7 Plastic man 21

 

[Iceman]

Firestorm-
Zatanna +

#1 Zatanna 16
#4 Firestorm 3
#5 Phantom Stranger 17
#6 Mister Miracle 10
#8 Flash (Jay Garrick) 16
#9 Animal Man 15
#10 Plastic Man 21

Actually I suppose depending on how anal you get this should be

Zatana 17
Plastic Man 20 because man of steal voted early.... but honestly I think 5 minutes is probably a good cutof point.

My vote is the same as ManofSteel's so scores are unchanged after my vote.


#1 Zatanna 16
#4 Firestorm 3
#5 Phantom Stranger 17
#6 Mister Miracle 10
#8 Flash (Jay Garrick) 16
#9 Animal Man 15
#10 Plastic Man 21

I'm not sure if ManofSteel actually knows about the rule as he's been early and been corrected so many times

 

[Iceman]

#1 Zatanna 16
#2 Firestorm 4
#3 Stranger 17
#4 Miracle 10
#5 Flash 16
#6 Animal man 15
#7 Plastic man 22


Edited to reflect Kitsune's post.

Edit 2: I meant Kingfish

 

[Kingfish]

animal man +
stranger -

zatanna 16
firestorm 4
stranger 16
miracle 10
flash 16
animal man 16
plastic man 22

 

[Aristotle]

Phantom Stranger +
Animal Man -

#1 Zatanna 16
#4 Firestorm 4
#5 Phantom Stranger 17
#6 Mr. Miracle 10
#8 Flash (Jay Garrick) 16
#9 Animal Man 15
#10 Plastic Man 22

 

[Dedpool]

Firestorm +
Mr. Miracle -

#1 Zatanna 16
#2 Firestorm 5
#3 Phantom Stranger 17
#4 Mr. Miracle 9
#5 Flash (Jay Garrick) 16
#6 Animal Man 15
#7 Plastic Man 22

 

[Sparta*]

Red Tornado is gone already?! damn you all lol jj I like Jay and Phantom Stranger more anyway

Jay +
Mr. Miracle -

#1 Zatanna 16
#2 Firestorm 5
#3 Phantom Stranger 17
#4 Mr. Miracle 8
#5 Flash (Jay Garrick) 17
#6 Animal Man 15
#7 Plastic Man 22

 

[Stallion9979]

delete

 

[Stallion9979]

Flash (Jay Garrick) +
Firestorm -

#1 Zatanna 16
#2 Firestorm 4
#3 Phantom Stranger 17
#4 Mr. Miracle 8
#5 Flash (Jay Garrick) 18
#6 Animal Man 15
#7 Plastic Man 22