The trailers for the movie were totally misleading - I was expecting this to be a quasi-fantasy movie based on them, so I was surprised when the movie turned out to be a lot more grounded in reality than I thought. In fact, there was really no fantasy at all in the movie - just about everything in it was set in the real world. It was also a lot more melodramatic than the trailers made it look, and very religious in nature, which the trailers also completely skipped. Not that I minded any of that, it's just that the trailers had me expecting a completely different type of movie.
Without giving anything away, I'd describe the movie as a philosophically religious, autobiographical melodrama, which makes it sound more pretentious than it was. It was definitely an emotional rollercoaster ride as well. This quote from Rotten Tomatoes sums it up pretty well too: "A mash up of fable, religious allegory, visual 3D feast, Animal Planet special, drama and comedy."
That said, this movie was pure art - in the visuals, the sound & music, the directing, the storytelling & pacing, etc. The night-time scenes especially were some of the best visual stuff, holy crap! I recommend seeing this movie on a screen as large as possible, like IMAX, just for them!
This movie made me fear and fall in love with the ocean at the same time, at how powerful the waves could be, yet serene at other times.
Something else about the trailers I have to mention, is that they made the tiger look like it was just part of one scene, when it actually had an extremely large role in the movie, on the level of a pivotal character. And in that aspect, I thought the tiger did extremely well as an "animal actor" - it was the best use and display of an animal yet in any kind of movie. Speaking of which, I loved how this movie played up the world of the animal kingdom, from typical zoo animals to sharks & dolphins and other things from much deeper in the ocean. That stuff was brilliantly awesome and the way that Ang Lee manipulated the audience into feeling awe, fear, or curiosity of animals was amazing!
I feel like I could dissect this movie in all sorts of ways like that. From the way it used the animals, to the visuals, to the theological & philosophical questions it posed, everything was just multi-layered. This definitely deserves at least a Best Pic nom if not the win, and I'm not just saying that lightly. This film transcended multiple levels and hit me on both emotional and intellectual wavelengths, which most films rarely do for me (it's usually one or the other, not both). I have to hand it to Ang Lee, he did something fantastic here that I'm guessing most people probably won't realize until later on.
I rate this film 11/10!
Btw, as a frame of reference, I'm 29 and would affiliate myself as "religious", so I guess I was in the film's demographic.
