Children's Book About Dieting: Harmful or Helpful?

Well its a thin line between not wanting an obese child and not wanting an anorexic one. The books a bit too far though. The parents should be the one's to deal with this.
 
Harmful. Children aren't responsible for their diets anyway, and their metabolisms are high enough that they could literally eat anything and be fine, so long as they get the right amount of exercise. Basically, this shouldn't be "put your kid on a diet", it should be "kick your kid out of the house for the day so they run around outside".
 
Harmful. In fact I'd go as far as to say most dieting books are potentially harmful regardless of their target audience's age. A proper diet is one that's balanced around what you need, not want and no book can say exactly what you need to lose weight without the author examining you personally and custom writing a book.

These books also put immense pressure on people to conform to a weight standard that's almost arbitrary and fails to take into account virtually anything about a person's physique, metabolism, height, exercise level or capability or any other possible contributing factors to how weight gain and loss are achieved.

If you want to diet, here's all you need to know, in a general sense. Stay away from excessive amounts of anything unhealthy (salt, fat, sugar, etc). Focus on vegetables, fruits and exercise. Meat and junk food in low moderation and don't let anyone tell you how much you should weigh unless they're a qualified doctor or nutritionist.

Pretty much common sense stuff we all forget or never learn because schools fail at physical education. Children should only be on diets if they truly are obese and follow a diet from an aforementioned expert, not some book that tells you something without knowing anything about you.
 
Diet as a noun is okay. Diet as a verb is not.
 
True that. Going on a diet implies going off it at some point.
 
Yeah, if you want to lose weight going on a diet is not the way, changing your lifestyle is the way to do it.
 
I kinda like this. I only wish it were aimed at an older child; not 4-8. A young child should be aware of good vs bad foods but not put on a specific diet. But once said child is 12-13, hell yeah it's diet time. The parents should probably be on the same or a similar diet too. There're ways to handle this without giving the kid an eating disorder :up:

And diet really is the wrong word here. It's not necessarily about eating less but eating better.
 
agreed Spoons....we (as a society) should be promoting a culture of health and such but the book is a bit much

to be followed by 'Maggie's Low Self Esteem' and 'Maggies Boyfriend Hits Her Because He Loves Her'
 
I'm thinking about writing a children's book myself.

It's called "Nobody Likes a Fatty".

:)
 
Ill write a companion book

"Let's Hunt The Homeless.....like Deer"
 
Ill write a companion book

"Let's Hunt The Homeless.....like Deer"

Then we can team up to write a sequel to my best selling debut, "Go the **** to Sleep". :up:
 
Then we can team up to write a sequel to my best selling debut, "Go the **** to Sleep". :up:

literary gold

then the young adult series

Maggie Cuts Herself to Feel Alive

Maggie Experiments with her friend, Alexis
 
Is this book meant to be read by children or adults? Because last I checked, most children eat what their parents put in front of them. Little Susie doesn't control her diet; Mama Susanne is fixing her meals and giving her the snacks.
 
Little Susie will eat from the dog-bowl and like it!! [/Mama Susanne]
 
If your 6 year old has a muffin top, do you really think she'll find a good man? Come on, people.
 
How the hell does he find clothes? Steal them from bears?
 
You'd be shocked at the sizes they sell at some Big & Tall stores.

Also, you may have eaten one piece of pie too many if you have no choice but to shoot from the hip because your arms no longer reach high enough.
 
Eat whatever you want, whenever you want it. Exercise accordingly. ***** diet.
 
Eat whatever you want, whenever you want it. Exercise accordingly. ***** diet.

If people could discipline themselves like that, they wouldn't need to diet.
 
Eat whatever you want, whenever you want it. Exercise accordingly. ***** diet.

There's not enough time in the day for the amount of exercise you'd have to do after consuming 5,000 calories in 1 day. So your plan is flawed, though it would be a dream forsome people.
 
I like the idea. We have an epidemic of fat kids in America and the weak, ignorant parents (most of whom are fat as well) are to blame.

I don't think its going to help but I like the idea.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
201,141
Messages
21,906,719
Members
45,703
Latest member
Weird
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"