IGN's Top 25 Comic Book Movies

[Visualiza]

I'm surprised Amazing Spider-Man is so high. I don't think it should be.

Agreed. Seems that this movie is one of those that critics and the media were exceedingly generous towards. Reminds me of the exceptionally high praise Warrior received last year. Not a bad film by any stretch, but it was so very average in every facet, save for Hardy's performance. Still, I could see why it was received the way it was. The difference here is that I thought TASM was a particularly bad film, but it happens. Seems that there's one or two every year.

 

[Anno_Domini]

I'm surprised Amazing Spider-Man is so high. I don't think it should be.

Agreed. Overall, it's a great list, though, but obviously some choices make you scratch your head in confusion.

 

[TheIrishAvenger]

Amazing Spider-Man higher than Spider-Man 2?

 

[flickchick85]

The placement of TASM is actually one things I DO agree with for the most part.

 

[def28]

Isnt that a random member blog list not IGNs official?

Last I checked IGN rates Spidey 2 up pretty high on all there lists. No way ASM is on IGN's list above it. They rated it a 6/10 when it came out.

 

[marvelrobbins]

Thor and Cap higher than X-men?
First Class higher than X2?
The Amazing Spider-Man higher than Spider-Man 2? I like amazing spider-Man more than
Rami Trilogy but I am in minoirty
The Dark Knight rises so high and rated higher than batman Begins?

 

[def28]

Pretty sure its just an IGN members opinion. Anyone can blog there.

I dont think their list has came out yet, or if even if they have an updated list coming.

 

[Anno_Domini]

Thor and Cap higher than X-men?
First Class higher than X2?
The Amazing Spider-Man higher than Spider-Man 2? I like amazing spider-Man more than
Rami Trilogy but I am in minoirty
The Dark Knight rises so high and rated higher than batman Begins?

How is that so shocking? Besides a huge fanbase, TDKR is rated higher critically than Batman Begins.

 

[TheGuy]

Thor and Cap higher than X-men?
First Class higher than X2?
The Amazing Spider-Man higher than Spider-Man 2? I like amazing spider-Man more than
Rami Trilogy but I am in minoirty
The Dark Knight rises so high and rated higher than batman Begins?

Yes.

 

[TheForgotten]

X-Men: First Class is WAY too high. And Dredd should easily be on the list!

 

[S. Grundy]

Dredd was pretty boring, and really had none of the spirit of the comic. I mean there was no satire in it, at all.

 

[Mace Dolex]

Dredd was pretty boring, and really had none of the spirit of the comic. I mean there was no satire in it, at all.

Yeah it should've had that sadistic satire of the first Robocop but the writers missed the boat on that one, and yet the studio scratches their heads as to the low box office.

 

[TheForgotten]

Dredd's tone and style easily outmatches a fourth of the comicbook films on IGN's list. Rocketeer? Spider-Man? X-Men: First Class? I found Dredd to a very over-the-top, self aware, hilarious action film that provided enough character developement and twists to be more than just a popcorn blockbuster. Sadly not everyone saw it this way.

And the last reason why Dredd flopped is because the "writers missed the boat" and gave it no sadistic satire.

 

[def28]

Dredd was ****ing awesome, thought it was one of the best this year.

 

[JeetKuneDo]

metacritic scores:​

Spider-Man 2 (2004): 83 out of 100
The Dark Knight (2008): 82 out of 100​

Spider-man (2002): 73 out of 100
Batman Begins (2005): 70 out of 100!​

Metacritic can GTFO.

IMDB:

Batman Begins: Ratings: 8.3/10 from 339,090 users
Spider-Man: Ratings: 7.4/10 from 206,231 users

RottenTomatoes:

Batman Begins: Average Rating: 7.7/10
Reviews Counted: 259
Fresh: 220 | Rotten: 39

Spider-Man Average Rating: 7.6/10
Reviews Counted: 215
Fresh: 192 | Rotten: 23

So apparently over 300,000 people on IMDB and over 200 reviewers are DC fanboys too.

Agree here, disagree there: It's like with any list, hey?

Eh, I don't think it's that serious. Folks can have anything they want on their lists as far as I'm concerned. Just as long as I know what mine is, that's all I need.

Anyone who doesn't put The Dark Knight on their list at all can't be taken seriously. In my opinion. I can barely name 25 comic book movies, let alone not include The Dark Knight among them. Get real.

I'm fascinated by our continued attempts to "prove" quality in art and to prove other people "wrong" about things they like. This thread is yet another example of how bad we fail every single time we try it. At best, we can muster a "pretty good list overall"....if the list agrees with our personal taste. Naturally our ego tells us that "What I like is good...what I don't like is bad". So any list which agrees with us is a "good list".

Sometimes we use a popular vote like IMDB...but does anyone use that list to guide their opinion of what movies are "better" than others? Do we all "admit" that Shawshank Redemption is the best movie ever made?

Then we turn to "experts" (critics). Yet another method we don't agree with. They say Vertigo is the greatest movie ever made. (They used to say it was Citizen Kane) http://www.cnn.com/2012/08/02/showbiz/uk-hitchcock-greatest-film-poll/index.html Everyone agree with that? They are the "experts" we must agree with, right?

It tells you all you need to know about art that each list is different...each method for determining "best/better" comes up with a different result. Those things don't exist in art. No one can find them because they aren't there to be found.

I used to do this myself...but I finally realized that good and bad, superior and inferior do not exist in art. The best comic book movies I've ever seen are Kick Ass, Watchmen, and Mystery Men...three-way tie for #1. That's just the way it is for me. No other list or opinion is relevant to me just like my opinion is not relevant to anyone else. How can a "list" or "critics consensus" make me feel different when I watch these movies?

But it's true. Kick-Ass the movie is much better. Superman the Movie is better than any Superman comic ever published. Christopher Nolan and Tim Burton improved Batman, Catwoman, Penguin, Joker et al.

Those are nice sentiments...but there is no way to prove any of it. I know I prefer the comic version of Batman big time. I think Nolan made him into a wimp. The Nolan Batman has to go if they plan to put Batman into the JLA movie.

...plus Batman has one of the most iconic costumes of all time...would be nice if someone would be brave enough to use it. The pulled it off with Spider-man so Batman should be no problem.

 

[S. Grundy]

Dredd's tone and style easily outmatches a fourth of the comicbook films on IGN's list. Rocketeer? Spider-Man? X-Men: First Class? I found Dredd to a very over-the-top, self aware, hilarious action film that provided enough character developement and twists to be more than just a popcorn blockbuster. Sadly not everyone saw it this way.

And the last reason why Dredd flopped is because the "writers missed the boat" and gave it no sadistic satire.

Those three movies are way better than Dredd.

 

[TheForgotten]

Those three movies are way better than Dredd.

Meh. I guess it's all a matter of opinion. I personally loved Dredd. One of my favorites of 2012 and one of my favorite superhero films.