I can't talk from much experience as I just signed up a week or so ago. I only added The Darkness and BioShock about 3 days (Thursday) before BioShock actually came out, and they still shipped both games on Monday. Granted they didn't arrive until Thursday, but so far I am really liking it. The fact that sold me on GameFly over GottaPlay is that once you rent a new game and decide you want to buy it you can click on "Keep It" and buy the game from them. They will also ship the original case and manual for whatever game you get. Right now I can keep BioShock for $49.99 if I wanted to. Add to that the fact that most games you rent from them have a section for walkthroughs, cheats, etc. and I really can't complain. I may try GottaPlay to see if they are faster, but for all the features I get right now I think it's great.