lets post all the things from all 3 movies that don't matc hthe comicbooks!

[DarknessOfDeath]

hmm ... hard choice. hmmm

i'll take my chances

 

[Nell2ThaIzzay]

hmm ... hard choice. hmmm

i'll take my chances

Your avatars recently... they are really...



I was thinking about it...

Why the **** would Marsden complain? Sure, he had a small role, but he spent most of it making out with ****ing Famke *****!

Marsden pwned the **** out of all of us with that role.

 

[Kevin Roegele]

jean grey isn't a doctor
beast was never in the presidents cabinet
mystique isn't scaley and naked
iceman is too young
toad, plain and simple
senator kelly's death
deathstrike
stryker
rogue's hair
the original x-men
jason, stryker's son, aka the comicbooks mastermind
xjet instead of the blackbird
storm, jean and scott as teachers
rogue's powers
storm's powers minus her control of them in x3
cyclops' age compared to jean's
the way the phoenix was handled

Please stop.

 

[windriderx]

Please stop.

hey hey hey!!!!!! this thread was made to show everyone complaining about x3 that none of the movies mimicked the comicbook and that alot of libeties were taken. if you quote my whole post are if you read it you would have seen that!

 

[windriderx]

Please stop.

i personally love all 3 movies and would change very little!!!!

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

Your avatars recently... they are really...



I was thinking about it...

Why the **** would Marsden complain? Sure, he had a small role, but he spent most of it making out with ****ing Famke *****!

Marsden pwned the **** out of all of us with that role.

I hope your not just referring to ... my avvy? ... lol.

 

[DRob]

It would be very nolstalgic if the original X-men(Cyclops, Iceman, Angel, Beast, and Jean Grey/Marvel Girl)were together in the first movie.
Only if fan-boy dreams came true.

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

Here's one of my old manips... damnit... Jean is caught in between scott and warren heh

 

[shadow king]

juggernaut is not a mutant and is charles's half brother.
beast would do anything to reverse his mutations he always has tried
jean was not that strong as a child and the pheonix is a celestial being.
logan didnt kill pheonix she turned from dark pheonix to pheonix after either scot or logan showed her an extreme act of love or sumat n nothin
why did they have to use the bridge to get to the island why not a metal container or cars or anything but a huge bridge it was just silly

 

[Mistopurr83]

jean grey isn't a doctor
beast was never in the presidents cabinet
mystique isn't scaley and naked
iceman is too young
toad, plain and simple
senator kelly's death
deathstrike
stryker
rogue's hair
the original x-men
jason, stryker's son, aka the comicbooks mastermind
xjet instead of the blackbird
storm, jean and scott as teachers
rogue's powers
storm's powers minus her control of them in x3
cyclops' age compared to jean's
the way the phoenix was handled


well here are some i thought of to show people that the movies have never really mimicked the comics. if you can think of anymore post them.

this thread is also not a thread to complain in, but just to show how the first 2 movies, along with the 3rd, never was comicbook correct and many liberties were taken.

All true. I could add more to that list but I don't have time at the moment. Maybe I'll do an edit later. It's one of the many things I don't like in a movie adaptation that doesn't stay faithful but tries to recreate everything as if the comics never existed.

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

So your telling me that Jean was never a Dr.? ... what the hell was she wearing the white Dr. coat for then? -sighs-

 

[PowersOfMind]

But all the stuff listed is secondary. I thought she was a doctor? My father said she was a doctor in the comics?

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

I thought she went to medical school and stuff... I mean... she was gonna stick a needle in Logan's arm...

 

[November Rain]

i don't understand the point of this thread, there are countless variations.

I mean what comic do you even begin to start basing your references on.

besides, differences isn't necessarily a bad thing

 

[Mr. Credible]

i think brett ratner would have given us a much more faithful xmen film had he not had to go off of singer's first 2 movies.

 

[BMM]

i think brett ratner would have given us a much more faithful xmen film had he not had to go off of singer's first 2 movies.

Somehow, I doubt it.

 

[windriderx]

I thought she went to medical school and stuff... I mean... she was gonna stick a needle in Logan's arm...

she was in the movies not the comic

 

[Mistopurr83]

jean grey isn't a doctor
beast was never in the presidents cabinet
mystique isn't scaley and naked
iceman is too young
toad, plain and simple
senator kelly's death
deathstrike
stryker
rogue's hair
the original x-men
jason, stryker's son, aka the comicbooks mastermind
xjet instead of the blackbird
storm, jean and scott as teachers
rogue's powers
storm's powers minus her control of them in x3
cyclops' age compared to jean's
the way the phoenix was handled

Now I'm ready to add onto that list.

Leech isn't a normal looking kid with no hair
Callisto is not an attractive black woman with superspeed powers and 2 eyes
Bolivar Trask is not black
Artie is a not a normal looking kid
Iceman has never dated Rogue or Kitty
Juggernaut is not a mutant
Pyro is no american kid with brown hair and he was never a student at Xavier's
Magneto's hair is not white b/c he's old
Rogue's history was destroyed and was made too young
Wolverine is not a 6 ft tall guy with amnesia
Wolverine should know Deathstrike and Sabretooth
Gyrich has never been killed
Storm and Jean are opposite heights or their comicheights

Got any more?

P.S. All of the deviations mentioned on this thread lies on the fault of a guy who didn't do his homework here. Those of you who kept up with the news for last six years know who that is.

 

[XCharlieX]

lol and i loved the majority of these alterations.

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

Jean makes an interesting Dr.

 

[PowersOfMind]

Still holding on to Jean being a doctor. It's all right, she does look like she'd make an interesting doctor.

Dr. Jean Grey has a much better ring to it.

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

Which do you prefer?

"I believe you've already met Dr. Jean Grey."

or

"I believe you've already met Jean Grey."

I prefer: "I believe you've already met Dr. Jean Grey."

 

[Angry Sentinel]

Wow this thread was a lot of fun

Jan got the fun started by tossing guantlet and letting the pawns go first

Windriderx... Uuum, went first...

Elijya, shows us his true feelings about the World that hates and fears... comic book fans

Nell stood his ground about Rogue and Cyclops. Dang it Nell I'm gonna change your mind about movie Cyke one of these days, lol

The Batman posted comments that were longer than 2 lines ... you guys must've gotten him riled up!

Kurosawa made his usual appearance, and didn't even go ape nuts, talk about role reversal.

... And guess whose side I would choose

*takes toys and comic books and offers them up as a burnt sacrifice*

 

[PhoenixRising]

So your telling me that Jean was never a Dr.? ... what the hell was she wearing the white Dr. coat for then? -sighs-

Jean was a Dr. in the movies, but not in the comics.

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

yeah... I know.