Supergirl Should "Miss Martian" appear in Supergirl?

[Mysteryman]

If the writers feel she can serve the ongoing story, then bring her in.

 

[metaphysician]

I would say that, if they are going to use Miss Martian? It'd be dang silly to make her into a Green Martian. You'd be giving up a huge amount of dramatic potential, in exchange for not much of anything.

 

[DigificWriter]

With what they established regarding the White Martians, there's no way for them to bring her in without making her a member of the Green.

 

[metaphysician]

Why not? We don't exactly have evidence for the White Martians being Chaotic Evil at a biological level. All you need is some White Martians who go "dude, maybe genocide is wrong?", and then have one of their kids get put into stasis or otherwise sent to safety.

 

[Rorschach2012]

Miss Martian could be a fantastic parallel for Supergirl

 

[zenith16]

I would say that, if they are going to use Miss Martian? It'd be dang silly to make her into a Green Martian. You'd be giving up a huge amount of dramatic potential, in exchange for not much of anything.

oh i think you miss under stood what I said I said they could make her the bi product of a mixture of parents white martains that were aopposed to the genocide and green. thus making her bi racial. the easy to say bi racial for some of us in north America is kid that are mixed ifand when when don't use the words bi racial. I'm just saying if the Genocidal side of the white martians represent the nazi's and in reallife any that's like the nazi's can't stand other race and even more sure those race's mixing with their own imagine what the white martian's will be like if there was bi racial martian who father was green and mother was a white martian? hell it could a green mother and white martian father.

like with in my family of my fathers side, who's married white women and my cousin's from my tree sets of uncle's also there actor plays captain cold Went worth Miller who's biracial. there's also Vin Diesel and his twin brother(the latter not a actor) who are bi -racial cause they are both from a black parent and an Italian mother.

and there's what Tay Digg's said about his child who is the bi product of his Latina wife and Tay Digg's him self a black man

1. Taye Diggs: I Want My Son To Choose His Racial ...
   
   www.marlonwayans.tv/taye-digs-son.htmlCached
   
   Actor Taye Diggs, best known by his role in Private Practice, hit back after his comments about his son’s mixed race set off a firestorm on social media.

The controversy started after he told The Grio that he considered his son mixed instead of black, saying ‘I think when you [call biracial people black] you risk disrespecting half of who they are’.

This comment wasn’t well received in social media. Twitter users even asked Diggs if he was ‘afraid’ or ‘scared’ that people would think of his son as black.

and hank could relate to her and the fact white martians will have even more of a reason to want her and what the half of anti genocide half of the white martian stood wiped out of existance. Cause the white genocidal side were trying to rid the planet of the greens . and yes we'd have the parallel to how miss martian was sent to earth by her parents similar to super girl but for different reason's.

it's would be interesting to see.

 

[Kelly]

Let's leave personal opinions of posters out of the discussion please....

YES, a post has been deleted.

 

[Webhead2006]

ya no need to totally change miss martian story to still do it. They could always have a new younger white martian doesnt feel the same hate to the greens and wants to turn away from the whites.

 

[zenith16]

ya no need to totally change miss martian story to still do it. They could always have a new younger white martian doesnt feel the same hate to the greens and wants to turn away from the whites.

Well some thing erie happen in my local news I'll show that in second below.
I'm just throwing out idea's and it's better to me then making her for it(for Genocide in any is just plan disturbing) and then deciding to change later cause hank won't go for it.and nether will the audience keeping the same way or making her mixter the white martian tyhat were for the genocide will want her and jo'nn distroyed if she was against.

now as mentioned earlir this weas strangly in my local news about other Genocides beside the well known Holocaust .

thic link leads to a video and written article bbut I'm putting up the written half in quotes. hmm maybe it'll give the writers further idea's (yeah I'm aware they don't check out this forum)

• 
  Genocide should be compulsory learning in Quebec high schools: advocate

CTV Montreal
Published Wednesday, February 10, 2016 8:04PM EST

Last Updated Wednesday, February 10, 2016 10:51PM EST A group hoping to make the study of genocide compulsory in Quebec high schools made its pitch before the National Assembly Wednesday.

“Students are graduating from grade 11 not even knowing what the word genocide means nor knowing anything about former genocides,” said Heidi Berger of The Foundation for the Compulsory Study of Genocide in Schools.

Berger regularly speaks to Quebec students about how her family was persecuted during the Holocaust – how her grandfather and uncle were killed – and about her late mother's resolve to educate young people.

“Right now a teacher does not have to teach genocide if they don't want to,” she said. “I think Quebec can set a great example by being one of the first places in Canada to make this compulsory.”

Also passionate about making genocide study compulsory is Montreal's Armenian community.

“There are many genocides but students don't understand what are the steps leading to that, so there is a big need for that,” said Aram Elagoz or the Armenian National Committee of Montreal.

The National Assembly will now study the petition and Berger has been promised a sit down with Education Minister Pierre Moreau.

Mount Royal MP Anthony Housefather spoke in the House of Commons last week in advance of Wednesday’s motion, saying, “It is essential that students across Canada be educated about all of the genocides of human history. So that never again becomes a reality.”

“I got a standing ovation from all three parties when I brought it up,” he said Wednesday.

Any eventual change would begin with grade 11 students, both in English and French schools.

“I would like to see all genocides covered, not only the Holocaust but the Armenian genocide and the Rwandan genocide,” said Berger.

 

[04nbod]

Of course as Supergirl may need some female superhero friends like Miss Martian, Starfire, Raven, Wonder Girl, XS, etc.

I would think this will be in Season 2.

I want some Babsgirl but DC are weird with their Bats.

 

[Kelly]

Well some thing erie happen in my local news I'll show that in second below.
I'm just throwing out idea's and it's better to me then making her for it(for Genocide in any is just plan disturbing) and then deciding to change later cause hank won't go for it.and nether will the audience keeping the same way or making her mixter the white martian tyhat were for the genocide will want her and jo'nn distroyed if she was against.

now as mentioned earlir this weas strangly in my local news about other Genocides beside the well known Holocaust .

thic link leads to a video and written article bbut I'm putting up the written half in quotes. hmm maybe it'll give the writers further idea's (yeah I'm aware they don't check out this forum)

• 
  Genocide should be compulsory learning in Quebec high schools: advocate

This is very weird to me since so many feel that Canada is far ahead of the US in education, etc.

I have been teaching World Geography, Pre AP World Geography and AP Human Geography for years, and genocide has been a part of my curriculum since year 1 back in the 90's....we cover Genocide from all perspectives, from the earliest to those happening now. The word "genocide" was not a part of anyone's vocabulary until after the Holocaust, so many of those mass murders into the 1,000s were simply seen as a part of war, civil war or otherwise, not genocide because the word was not used. Now that it its, in the US it is used to describe everything from the death of Native Americans here in the Americas, to Sudan.

My students IMMEDIATELY called what happened to the "Green Martians" genocide, and saw the similarities of the internment camps.

 

[Mysteryman]

This is very weird to me since so many feel that Canada is far ahead of the US in education, etc.

I have been teaching World Geography, Pre AP World Geography and AP Human Geography for years, and genocide has been a part of my curriculum since year 1 back in the 90's....we cover Genocide from all perspectives, from the earliest to those happening now. The word "genocide" was not a part of anyone's vocabulary until after the Holocaust, so many of those mass murders into the 1,000s were simply seen as a part of war, civil war or otherwise, not genocide because the word was not used. Now that it its, in the US it is used to describe everything from the death of Native Americans here in the Americas, to Sudan.

My students IMMEDIATELY called what happened to the "Green Martians" genocide, and saw the similarities of the internment camps.

That is good television for you.
When a strong idea is well expressed, people get it.

 

[zenith16]

This is very weird to me since so many feel that Canada is far ahead of the US in education, etc.

I have been teaching World Geography, Pre AP World Geography and AP Human Geography for years, and genocide has been a part of my curriculum since year 1 back in the 90's....we cover Genocide from all perspectives, from the earliest to those happening now. The word "genocide" was not a part of anyone's vocabulary until after the Holocaust, so many of those mass murders into the 1,000s were simply seen as a part of war, civil war or otherwise, not genocide because the word was not used. Now that it its, in the US it is used to describe everything from the death of Native Americans here in the Americas, to Sudan.

My students IMMEDIATELY called what happened to the "Green Martians" genocide, and saw the similarities of the internment camps.

truth be told it's only in some things it seems that way. but in alot of other ways we are the same .
we do take the time to observe thing'a better but in truth were's not that different at all . And there still alot we don't always know.

we're no different from you people down south of us and even though there are times when we just make different chose's we still have alot of same problems we still have school bullying and we've had alot or shooting's up here that have escalated from the time I graduated high school ,both domestic from people from other country's visiting here and our education system still needs to be improved up on cause we've been slipping as well.

the world may put at as higher but other times it's not really as it seems.

and it's good your student saw the connection about the interment camps.

I hope it's explored more with in the show of super girl especully if mismartain shows up and she makes her stance against ones for genocide. there alot to explore there and why it started for mars. alot from out own history to draw from as well.

 

[Boy Scout]

That is good television for you.
When a strong idea is well expressed, people get it.

Well, I mean, the similarities and parallels were obvious.