I had never played a Silent Hill game before but because I loved the Resident Evil remakes (and have gotten into that franchise big time) I figured I'd give Silent Hill 2 (remake) a shot. Went in with fairly medium expectations not knowing what I would get from it, and I also just replayed The Last of Us before this so my mind had a pretty fresh update on how great a videogame CAN be.
But I honestly was blown away by it and for me it's easily up there with the best games of this genre. While I've seen people debate what I consider fairly minor things (like overuse of mannequin enemies) I thought this game nailed pretty much everything. The characters are great - James is a fantastically nuanced protagonist, you have very memorable side characters like Angela or Eddie. The story is really good and the revelations of what actually happened towards the end really hit the spot. The setting is really strong with the foggy town of Silent Hill but also very memorable sections (and not a single bad one in there) and the atmosphere was creepy and unsettling. The soundtrack really helped make it feel special and the sound design (enemies in the distance, banging on doors, random breathing) made me feel paranoid through parts of the game.
I know some people wont be as positive as me because they have a fondness for the original, but I loved this game! Definitely goes up there among my favorite games I've played.