Destructicus
Civilian
- Joined
- Jul 14, 2005
- Messages
- 411
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 11
Okay I'm making this thread to express my opinions about X3, this is what I thought they did right, what I thought they did wrong, and what they should have done. I dont know if there is a thread like this already, I didn't check. If I jump around in the scenes of the film I'm sorry.
The Good
1. I liked the idea of Rouge losing her powers at the end of the movie. It showed the end of the relationship she could of had with Bobby because it might of been what she wanted, but not what Bobby wanted. Her losing her powers could mutate the serum so the next mutant she touches she could get the permanent flight and super strength. Her losing her powers could make her end up leaving the X-mansion and going back home. She could think she was normal and if the movie is timed right could end up in New Orleans to celebrate martigraw with her friends. This could tie Gambit into the fourth film, if a fourth film is on the way. Rouge losing her powers could start a developing relationship with her and Mystique if they retell that story arc.
2. Most people are angry about Professor Xavior dieing, but this could be a blessing and a curse. Think about your xistory, each X-Man has died atleast once. Wolverine, Jean, both have died several times to name a few. Professor X dieing could get a few of the psychics involved in getting him back from the astral plane. Those of you will know about the Astral plane from past X-Men comics, and from the game X-men Legends. Having the likes of Emma, Psylocke(even though she was killed), and a reborn Jean diving into the astral plane to bring back Professor X would work for me.
3. Like Professor X dieing, Scott Summers movie situation is the same way. What we didn't see is if he really died. If everyone remembers Bishop then you will know that Bishop can go back and foreward in time. Bishop saved Scott before he was killed and brought him back to the X-men. This could also be a huge easter egg for Apocalyps. In the fourth film Bishop could show up at the X-Mansion and then prove that he is telling the truth about the up in coming age of apocalyps by bring Cyclops back. But we also have to remember that we still never saw Cyclops die. Jean could of just sent him somwhere, same with Professor X. After the credits Professor X talked to Dr. Moira either trying to tell her where he is or just comunicating from the dead.
4. The scene with Jamie Madrox did give me a few laughs. I did want a bigger scene with MultipleMan, but I had to settle with what I got with him and I wasn't disapointed.
5. Jean dieing at the end of the movie was a staple in the era of the Pheonix. The myth of the pheonix is that it never dies and is just reborn into another stage of its life. Jean died once, then came back, and now will be reborn once again with her good side being triumphant.
The Bad
1. Okay Angel was a disapointment in this film to the extreme. I wanted so much more from our winged friend it wasn't funny. I expected so much out of Angel, but I was denied. He should of had more lines then "no I cant do this," it sounded like he was resisting molestation from his father, it was pathetic.
2. The relationship between Professor X and Juggernaut should of been atleast mentioned. There was no que from Magneto or X that Cain Marco and Xavior that they were related.
3. Juggernaut being a mutant was stupid. This movie was what a good 2 hours long and they couldn't spend what five maybe six minutes explaining how he got his powers, even if it was comic relief I would of been happy.
4. Collosus should of atleast had a Russian accent.
I know that more of this movie pissed me off but I will post more later.
What should of Happened
1. Angel Should of gotten more time onscreen then he did. He should of told the XMen right before they left in the jet that his father was on the island of Alcatraz and he was going to go with them. This could of left open a scene where Angel got his wings burned off by Pyro. To ensure that Apocalyps was coming in the fourth film everyone knows that Angel is on of the four horsemen of the apocalyps. Cuttout the scene in the begining where angel was cutting off his wings and then at the end of the movie farther off the credits we could see a scene where Apocalypse gives angel his new wings.
2. It would of taken a mere change of lines said by Ian, Jones and Stewart to talk about the relationship between X and Marco. It would of been true to the fans and would of gave The Juggernaut more prestige then he had. When Magneto and Pyro found Juggernaut, right when Pyro said "Cain Marco" Magneto could of said no need to read on I know all about this one. He could of ripped the door off and said " Mr. Marco, been a long time hasn't it", then Juggernaut could of said somthing comical or serious or a mix of both. Then the fans would understand a little more about Juggernaut's history, even just a little piece. Then when the X-men and the broutherhood arrive at Jean's house as Xavior rolls past Juggernaut, Marco could of stood in X's way and said hold on I got a few bones to pick with you Charles. Then Xavior could of said a few things then Magneto could of told Juggernaut to step aside and let the man pass. This would of been better then the man for hire Juggernaut that everyone never liked.
3. The least they could of done is make Juggernaut not a mutant. If we all know our xistory Cain Marco got his powers from the Crystal of Cyratok while in the Military with his step brother Charles. The cave fell down on Cain and he then dug his way out, that took years to accomplish. It could of been explained in a flashback only what 15 minutes long. Then the scene when he hit his head could of been replaced with Kitty trying to tackle Juggernaut and then coming out of his back holding a crystal, Juggernaut then turns to the boy and he kicks him in the balls. Juggernaut falls down and then is left in the room or he could of just kept running and then hit his head on the wall. Comic relief and staying true.
4. Just one scene of Collosus saying "Myn throwing arm is just fine comrade" would of solved this problem real fast.
This is only my opinion, but I think I run a fair game and all of my demands could of spaned in the time frame they had. What do you think.
The Good
1. I liked the idea of Rouge losing her powers at the end of the movie. It showed the end of the relationship she could of had with Bobby because it might of been what she wanted, but not what Bobby wanted. Her losing her powers could mutate the serum so the next mutant she touches she could get the permanent flight and super strength. Her losing her powers could make her end up leaving the X-mansion and going back home. She could think she was normal and if the movie is timed right could end up in New Orleans to celebrate martigraw with her friends. This could tie Gambit into the fourth film, if a fourth film is on the way. Rouge losing her powers could start a developing relationship with her and Mystique if they retell that story arc.
2. Most people are angry about Professor Xavior dieing, but this could be a blessing and a curse. Think about your xistory, each X-Man has died atleast once. Wolverine, Jean, both have died several times to name a few. Professor X dieing could get a few of the psychics involved in getting him back from the astral plane. Those of you will know about the Astral plane from past X-Men comics, and from the game X-men Legends. Having the likes of Emma, Psylocke(even though she was killed), and a reborn Jean diving into the astral plane to bring back Professor X would work for me.
3. Like Professor X dieing, Scott Summers movie situation is the same way. What we didn't see is if he really died. If everyone remembers Bishop then you will know that Bishop can go back and foreward in time. Bishop saved Scott before he was killed and brought him back to the X-men. This could also be a huge easter egg for Apocalyps. In the fourth film Bishop could show up at the X-Mansion and then prove that he is telling the truth about the up in coming age of apocalyps by bring Cyclops back. But we also have to remember that we still never saw Cyclops die. Jean could of just sent him somwhere, same with Professor X. After the credits Professor X talked to Dr. Moira either trying to tell her where he is or just comunicating from the dead.
4. The scene with Jamie Madrox did give me a few laughs. I did want a bigger scene with MultipleMan, but I had to settle with what I got with him and I wasn't disapointed.
5. Jean dieing at the end of the movie was a staple in the era of the Pheonix. The myth of the pheonix is that it never dies and is just reborn into another stage of its life. Jean died once, then came back, and now will be reborn once again with her good side being triumphant.
The Bad
1. Okay Angel was a disapointment in this film to the extreme. I wanted so much more from our winged friend it wasn't funny. I expected so much out of Angel, but I was denied. He should of had more lines then "no I cant do this," it sounded like he was resisting molestation from his father, it was pathetic.
2. The relationship between Professor X and Juggernaut should of been atleast mentioned. There was no que from Magneto or X that Cain Marco and Xavior that they were related.
3. Juggernaut being a mutant was stupid. This movie was what a good 2 hours long and they couldn't spend what five maybe six minutes explaining how he got his powers, even if it was comic relief I would of been happy.
4. Collosus should of atleast had a Russian accent.
I know that more of this movie pissed me off but I will post more later.
What should of Happened
1. Angel Should of gotten more time onscreen then he did. He should of told the XMen right before they left in the jet that his father was on the island of Alcatraz and he was going to go with them. This could of left open a scene where Angel got his wings burned off by Pyro. To ensure that Apocalyps was coming in the fourth film everyone knows that Angel is on of the four horsemen of the apocalyps. Cuttout the scene in the begining where angel was cutting off his wings and then at the end of the movie farther off the credits we could see a scene where Apocalypse gives angel his new wings.
2. It would of taken a mere change of lines said by Ian, Jones and Stewart to talk about the relationship between X and Marco. It would of been true to the fans and would of gave The Juggernaut more prestige then he had. When Magneto and Pyro found Juggernaut, right when Pyro said "Cain Marco" Magneto could of said no need to read on I know all about this one. He could of ripped the door off and said " Mr. Marco, been a long time hasn't it", then Juggernaut could of said somthing comical or serious or a mix of both. Then the fans would understand a little more about Juggernaut's history, even just a little piece. Then when the X-men and the broutherhood arrive at Jean's house as Xavior rolls past Juggernaut, Marco could of stood in X's way and said hold on I got a few bones to pick with you Charles. Then Xavior could of said a few things then Magneto could of told Juggernaut to step aside and let the man pass. This would of been better then the man for hire Juggernaut that everyone never liked.
3. The least they could of done is make Juggernaut not a mutant. If we all know our xistory Cain Marco got his powers from the Crystal of Cyratok while in the Military with his step brother Charles. The cave fell down on Cain and he then dug his way out, that took years to accomplish. It could of been explained in a flashback only what 15 minutes long. Then the scene when he hit his head could of been replaced with Kitty trying to tackle Juggernaut and then coming out of his back holding a crystal, Juggernaut then turns to the boy and he kicks him in the balls. Juggernaut falls down and then is left in the room or he could of just kept running and then hit his head on the wall. Comic relief and staying true.
4. Just one scene of Collosus saying "Myn throwing arm is just fine comrade" would of solved this problem real fast.
This is only my opinion, but I think I run a fair game and all of my demands could of spaned in the time frame they had. What do you think.
