Tim Burton/Schumacher Movies vs. 'B:TAS'

[TMC1982]

Batman/Bruce Wayne: Michael Keaton, Val Kilmer or George Clooney vs. Kevin Conroy

Robin/Dick Grayson: Chris O'Donnell vs. Lorne Lester

Alfred Pennyworth: Michael Gough vs. Efram Zimbalist Jr.

Commissioner James Gordon: Pat Hingle vs. Robert Hastings

Joker: Jack Nicholson vs. Mark Hamill

Penguin: Danny DeVito vs. Paul Williams

Catwoman: Michelle Pfeiffer vs. Adrienne Barbeau

Two-Face/Harvey Dent: Billy Dee Williams or Tommy Lee Jones vs. Richard Moll

Riddler: Jim Carrey vs. John Glover

Mr. Freeze: Arnold Schwarzenegger vs. Michael Ansara

Poison Ivy: Uma Thurman vs. Diane Pershing

Bane: Jeep Swenson vs. Henry Silva

I'm not going to bother having a Batgirl face off since Alicia Silverstone didn't play Barbara Gordon in Batman & Robin unlike Melissa Gilbert on the animated series.

 

[Two-Face]

My choices:

Bruce wayne/Batman: Kevin Conroy

Dick Grayson/Robin: Lorne Lester

Alfred Pennyworth: Michael Gough

Commissioner James Gordon: Robert Hastings

Joker: Jack Nicholson, Mark Hamill (can't choose)

Penguin: Danny DeVito

Selina Kyle/Catwoman: Michelle Pfeiffer

Harvey Dent/Two-Face: Richard Moll

Edward Nygma/The Riddler: John Glover

Victor Fries/Mr Freeze: Michael Anasara

Pamela Isley/Poison Ivy: Diana Pershing

Bane: Henry Silva

 

[El Payaso]

Batman/Bruce Wayne: Michael Keaton

Robin/Dick Grayson: Chris O'Donnell vs. Lorne Lester - Not sure, because as Dick, O'Donnell was good.

Alfred Pennyworth: Michael Gough

Commissioner James Gordon: Robert Hastings

Joker: Jack Nicholson

Penguin: Danny DeVito

Catwoman: Michelle Pfeiffer

Two-Face/Harvey Dent: Richard Moll

Riddler: Jim Carrey

Mr. Freeze: Michael Ansara

Poison Ivy: Diane Pershing

Bane: Henry Silva

 

[Brother Jack]

TAS wins for everything except best Penguin and Catwoman, and even that is debatable.

 

[returntovoid]

Batman/Bruce Wayne: Michael Keaton/Kevin Conroy (Both, I can't really decide...)

Robin/Dick Grayson: Lorne Lester

Alfred Pennyworth: Efram Zimbalist Jr.

Commissioner James Gordon: Robert Hastings (Post-Crisis Gordon is always better)

Joker: Jack Nicholson/Mark Hamill (Both, can't f***ing decide)

Penguin: Danny DeVito

Catwoman: Michelle Pfeiffer

Two-Face/Harvey Dent: Richard Moll

Riddler: John Glover

Mr. Freeze: Michael Ansara

Poison Ivy: Diane Pershing

Bane: Henry Silva

 

[Wesley Dodds]

I side with the animated series in all of the categories. I still hear most of those guys voices in my head when i read the comics.

 

[maenalus]

Keaton/ Conroy, easily

Michelle Pfeiffer, easily

Richard Moll, easily

John Glover, easily

Diane Pershing, easily

Michael Ansara, easily

As for the rest, I like the different interpretations equally.

Except I don't care about Robin or Bane, so no opinion on those.

 

[Doc Ock]

Batman/Bruce Wayne: Kevin Conroy

Robin/Dick Grayson: Lorne Lester

Alfred Pennyworth: Michael Gough

Commissioner James Gordon: Robert Hastings

Joker: Mark Hamill

Penguin: Danny DeVito

Catwoman: Michelle Pfeiffer

Two-Face/Harvey Dent: Richard Moll

Riddler: John Glover

Mr. Freeze: Michael Ansara

Poison Ivy: Diane Pershing

Bane: Henry Silva

 

[Cain]

Batman/Bruce Wayne: Kevin Conroy

Robin/Dick Grayson: Lorne Lester

Alfred Pennyworth: Michael Gough

Commissioner James Gordon: Robert Hastings

Joker: Jack Nicholson

Penguin: Danny DeVito

Catwoman: Michelle Pfeiffer

Two-Face/Harvey Dent: Richard Moll

Riddler: John Glover

Mr. Freeze: Michael Ansara

Poison Ivy: Diane Pershing

Bane: Henry Silva