WHOVIANS Unite! Canon needs us!

[Fried Gold]

*looks at conversation....backs away slowly*

 

[Lady Stormcrow]

Touché

 

[Noir]

Don't get it..

Yeah, Doctor Who is way more important than LOTR, what moral lesson has LOTR taught you that every other big epic hasn't?
The Dead Ringers said it best with there LOTR, Star Wars, and Potter sketch.

 

[Noir]

Or for more info on my feelings on LOTR see Randel's rant in Clerks. II

 

[Lord Valumart]

Or for more info on my feelings on LOTR see Randel's rant in Clerks. II

lol....man that was awesome and so truet:

 

[Lady Stormcrow]

Hey, I never said I dont like Doctor Who, I love it. I also love LOTR and Dead Ringers.
so...
I dont understand your point, lol
all I was saying was that I was unable to participate in the discussion merely on a basis of lack of expertise of the subject in question.

 

[Lord Valumart]

you do know you could just make something up, right? what the hell do you think the rest of us have been doing?

 

[Noir]

If you go by just what RTD is saying then no one will understand it.. "His" Universe really doesn't fit in that well in my mind, so we're here trying to fix it and while we are at it create a Expanded Universe like Star Wars has..


FYI guys. Wikipedia has been edited to say that some fans believe the Shalka Doctor is the real 9th Doctor and it links to this page, but its only in the Shalka Doctor section right now.

 

[Lord Valumart]

If you go by just what RTD is saying then no one will understand it.. "His" Universe really doesn't fit in that well in my mind, so we're here trying to fix it and while we are at it create a Expanded Universe like Star Wars has..


FYI guys. Wikipedia has been edited to say that some fans believe the Shalka Doctor is the real 9th Doctor and it links to this page, but its only in the Shalka Doctor section right now.

you edited didn't you?

 

[Lady Stormcrow]

Well, I guess with time travel it all gets a bit confusing. especially with the whole 'time lords exist out of time' thing. Because if they didnt..it wouldnt matter if they died..because they could travel to after that time, and rebuild the planet...but they'd already be dead...*brain explodes*

No wonder RTD killed them off

 

[Noir]

Hell, say you were one of the Doctors compagins XDD

I know I didn't spell that right..

 

[Fried Gold]

Well, I guess with time travel it all gets a bit confusing. especially with the whole 'time lords exist out of time' thing. Because if they didnt..it wouldnt matter if they died..because they could travel to after that time, and rebuild the planet...but they'd already be dead...*brain explodes*

No wonder RTD killed them off

I think the whole 'Time War' thing can pretty much explain any continuity headaches. Plus, there's always the Cardiff rift reset button that affects everyone except members of Torchwood.

 

[Noir]

Yeah I edited it yesterday night
and its still up..
which I geuss means people are buying it.

 

[Lord Valumart]

Yeah I edited it yesterday night
and its still up..
which I geuss means people are buying it.

i can only see the terror on the dr who forums with in the next few weeks

*noob34 has logged in*
torchie4: lol he was all in pain
noob34: hey guys, some guy changed the wiki...
steve: some guy did what?
noob34: changed the REG dr's wiki
torchie4: aw man thats just not on
*mattus has logged in*
*mattus has logged out*
*torchie4 has logged out*
steve: seriously he changed the wiki?
noob34: yeh
*torchie4 has logged in*
torchie4: i changed the wiki back
steve: yay

it'll be murder!!

 

[Lady Stormcrow]

I think the whole 'Time War' thing can pretty much explain any continuity headaches. Plus, there's always the Cardiff rift reset button that affects everyone except members of Torchwood.

It's a good move, baisically resetting the clock back to 'zero'.
Though theres a small part of me that hopes they'll bring the other time lords back. After seeing 'the parting of the ways', I cant help but think a second time war would be great television.

 

[Noir]

Yeah.. I know, but I found something out. When you link actually add a reference to something on Wiki people tend not to change it XDD

 

[Lord Valumart]

link us to the page you changed then....

 

[Noir]

It's a good move, baisically resetting the clock back to 'zero'.
Though theres a small part of me that hopes they'll bring the other time lords back. After seeing 'the parting of the ways', I cant help but think a second time war would be great television.

There has already been two Time Wars supposedly following one right after another, if you bring in a Third I doubt the universe would survive.

 

[Noir]

link us to the page you changed then....

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shalka_Doctor#Overview

 

[Lord Valumart]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shalka_Doctor#Overview

i see nothing about it there....

 

[Lady Stormcrow]

There has already been two Time Wars supposedly following one right after another, if you bring in a Third I doubt the universe would survive.

lmao, very well.

I shall just have to start a guerrilla time war

*pokes daleks with a pointed stick*

 

[Noir]

"Some fans of the series are starting to count the Shalka Doctor as the canon version of the Ninth Doctor and simply moving Eccleston up. [[1]]"

Look for that on teh page

 

[Max Shrek]

In the end, it's all stupid IMO. Canon, I mean. Doctor Who isn't science, it isn't history, it's a fun romp for the whole family, whether you're 8 or 80. It's funny, it's scary, it's silly, it's beautiful, it's emotionally touching, it's amazing. With some exceptions, most of the DW media put out is fantastic and IMO trying to figure out how exactly time works in the universe and when the UNIT stories took place and if the NAs where canon or if the Big Finish plays were... is missing the point. Doctor Who was made to get enjoyment out of sitting it and having a DAMN good time.

 

[Noir]

Yeah.. Well for me Doctor Who is a drug..
I gotta get it figured out.. its my life and I treat it as if it were a real universe..

 

[Noir]

In the end, it's all stupid IMO. Canon, I mean. Doctor Who isn't science, it isn't history, it's a fun romp for the whole family, whether you're 8 or 80. It's funny, it's scary, it's silly, it's beautiful, it's emotionally touching, it's amazing. With some exceptions, most of the DW media put out is fantastic and IMO trying to figure out how exactly time works in the universe and when the UNIT stories took place and if the NAs where canon or if the Big Finish plays were... is missing the point. Doctor Who was made to get enjoyment out of sitting it and having a DAMN good time.

....Cannocity adds a certain reality to the show though..