Cast The JSA

[Wesley Dodds]

If there was a Justice Society Of America movie who would you want to see in it?

Alan Scott/Green Lantern- Robert Redford

​

I know its been said before but this really is just perfect casting.

Jay Garrick/The Flash- Bryan Cranston

Add some grey temples to his hair and he's just right.

Ted Grant/Wildcat- Dennis Quaid

In full-On Innerspace mode.

Michael Holt/Mr. Terriffic- Jamie Foxx

Foxx is a great actor and this'd be a really good comeback vehicle for him.

Courtney Whitmore/ Star-Spangled Kid- Dakota Fanning

You have no idea how much i wanted to choose Kristen Bell for this. Heres why i didnt:
Courtney should be the character the audience grows up with through the trilogy, She's the viewers way into the movie Rogue style. We're introduced to her as a little kid in the first movie and by the end of the third she's a young woman and renames herself StarGirl.
Unfortunately, Bells too old for what i'd want to see.

Karen Starr/PowerGirl- Rebecca Romijn

Perhaps not the best picture but they're identical when you really look at them.

Rick Tyler/Hourman- Colin Hanks
With Tom Hanks in a cameo as his dad Rex, The original Hour Man

Carter Hall/Hawkman- Russell Crowe

Search your feelings. You know it makes sense.

Pieter Cross/Doctor Midnite- Goran Visnjic

Albert Rothstein/Atom Smasher- Jason Segel

Again, another actor whose the spitting image of the part.

Phew!
Your turn...

 

[Wesley Dodds]

Jesse Chambers/Liberty Belle- Naomi Watts

 

[Wesley Dodds]

Jay Mohr as Sandy/Sandman

 

[WompuM]

This is really the wrong place for this. Corp, do your thang.

 

[Wesley Dodds]

Ha!

I'm going through old threads i made here and spotted this gem... Three months and ONE semi-reply?

That doesnt seem normal. What's the matter, folks? No JSA love?

 

[WompuM]

It's just not in the right forum, although I do find a lot of your choices very interesting.

 

[Wesley Dodds]

Thanks, Man.

That HAS to be the reason this thread's deader than dead. I can't believe for a second there arent any JSA fans on here.

Perhaps, a kind Mod could move it were it belongs?

 

[sethcohen]

that and i dont want jamie fox within 1000 yards of a JSA movie. or dakota fanning. or bryan cranston... all i can picture is tim watley the dentist or malcoms goofy dad

 

[Metamorpho1977]

William H Macy as Jay Garrick

 

[Metamorpho1977]

Robert Duvall as Jim Corrigan

 

[Wesley Dodds]

Nice.
I especially like the Duvall as Corrigan idea.

Also, THANK YOU for posting, Metamorpho1977! I was about to rename this thread "Cast The JSA: The LEAST popular thread on Superhero Hype!"

 

[Metamorpho1977]

No problem. I'm a big JSA fan. Moreso of the older team, but the new group is growing on me.

for Stargirl, I saw Taylor Swift. I've met Dakota Fanning a couple of times, her grandparents go to my church. That kid is a brat from what I've heard.

 

[cerealkiller182]

Flash- Bruce Greenwood
Green Lantern- Scott Bakula
Hawkman- Michael Fassbender
Wildcat- Sylvester Stallone
Dr. Fate- Alex Denisoff
Sand- Ewan McGregor
Hourman- Cole Hauser
Liberty Belle- Yvonne Strahovski
Damage- Jared Padelecki
Amazing Man- Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje
Mister America- Jeffrey Dean Morgan
Pat Dugan- Colin Ferguson
Citizen Steel- Brian Van Holt
Cyclone- Amanda Bynes
Ma Hunkle- Fionnula Flanagan
Magog- Jason Lewis
Mr. Terrific- Chiwetal Eiafor
Jakeem Thunder- Paul James
Doc Mid-Nite- Damian Lewis
Power Girl- Katee Sackhoff

 

[TheWatcher]

jeff dean morgan for wild cat!!!!

 

[mebedir]

cerealkiller182 great job, I only have issues with scott bakula, and stallone.

Stllone is totally type-cast
alan scott should be blonde

to be honest though I kind of think stallone looks like dark knight returns batman, with the old guy muscle and all- not saying I'd have him play it, but he has the look.

 

[sleepwalk]

Cereal-

While I admit that I'm not as thrilled about this selection as your Avengers and JLA/DCU collages (truly inspired,) I will say that the casting of Amanda Bynes as Cyclone is spot on. She's a pretty girl and quite the character but it seems hard for her to find roles that suit her. Maxine is a perfect fit.

 

[sleepwalk]

DDP (Darn Double Post)

 

[Steve Holt]

dennis farina for wildcat!!!

 

[cerealkiller182]

cerealkiller182 great job, I only have issues with scott bakula, and stallone.

Stllone is totally type-cast

Stallone is of limited ability, but when hes in his wheelhouse hes excellent

alan scott should be blonde

barely a reason. Not only is there hair dye but it wouldnt be incredibly odd for a guy with light brown hair to play the part

 

[Metamorpho1977]

William B. Davis AKA Cigarette Smoking Man from X-Files for the Spectre

He'd make a good Wesley Dodds too.

 

[TheWatcher]

I would want it to be set in the 30's
tone-watchmen+iron man,meaning slow motion shots,period piece,but not as dark,gruesome,etc,etc

 

[Webhead2006]

well arnt they from the 40s/50s and not the 30s?

 

[Changeling]

WW2 so like 30's/40's

 

[Eddie Dean]

Kurt Russell as Wildcat

 

[Metamorpho1977]

Kurt Russell as Wildcat

Kurt Russell is Magog