Create your fav. collected edition

[Cobblepot]

For example:

Favourite Riddler stories, I'd see collected:

• #1 Secret Origins Special 1989 (Had a great little Riddler Short)
• Batman #452-454 "Dark Knight, Dark City"
• The Batman Adventures #10 "The Last Riddler Story"
• Batman # 362
• Batman # 171

OMG! Just googled and almost exactly those stories are named here:
http://goodcomics.comicbookresources.com/2007/10/13/365-reasons-to-love-comics-286/

But anyway, you guys get the idea!

 

[Cobblepot]

Double

 

[Lazlo Panaflex]

I would definitely like to see collected the classic early 80's work of Gerry Conway/Don Newton/Gene Colan hopefully with remastered coloring but sadly even Bat-historians seem to forget this period.

http://www.geocities.com/SoHo/Study/4273/saga/bat_thorne.html

 

[BubbaGump]

For me, this would be the greatest Two-Face TPB evah:

-Detective Comics #66
-Batman Annual #14
-Batman: Faces
-Batman #234 (?)
-Batman: Gotham Adventures #12
-The No Man's Land issue where Dent starts getting the hots for Montoya
-The NML issue where he puts Gordon on trial
-Gotham Central: Half a Life
-Batman B&W: Two of a Kind
-Batman Adventures #22
-Batman & Robin Adventures #2
-Batman #653

 

[Cain]

For me, this would be the greatest Two-Face TPB evah:

-Detective Comics #66
-Batman Annual #14
-Batman: Faces
-Batman #234 (?)
-Batman: Gotham Adventures #12
-The No Man's Land issue where Dent starts getting the hots for Montoya
-The NML issue where he puts Gordon on trial
-Gotham Central: Half a Life
-Batman B&W: Two of a Kind
-Batman Adventures #22
-Batman & Robin Adventures #2
-Batman #653

Not bad at all. I approve for the most part & since you're not only sticking to canonical tales for the sake of the character's history I'd suggest a definitive Two-Face TPB is nothing without an acknowledgement of Two-Face II (Paul Sloane). So I'd include his first appearance Batman #68 as well as Sloane's first post-crisis appearance by Mike Barr and Norm Breyfogle which is one of my favorite Harvey Dent/Two-Face stories Detective #580 & #581. I'd also add Detective #753 which is probably my favorite modern age (post-2000) Two-Face comic and features one of the greatest explorations of his psyche ever.

 

[Cobblepot]

I would definitely like to see collected the classic early 80's work of Gerry Conway/Don Newton/Gene Colan hopefully with remastered coloring but sadly even Bat-historians seem to forget this period.

http://www.geocities.com/SoHo/Study/4273/saga/bat_thorne.html

Oow man, loved those vampire stories! Memory lane...

 

[Spider-Kurt!]

I would definitely like to see collected the classic early 80's work of Gerry Conway/Don Newton/Gene Colan hopefully with remastered coloring but sadly even Bat-historians seem to forget this period.

http://www.geocities.com/SoHo/Study/4273/saga/bat_thorne.html

God yes!!! This era with those stories helped make me a fan for life! I unfortunately agree that nobody seems to give that era it's just dues.Maybe,hopefully someday DC will publish a collection after all.

 

[Cobblepot]

Anybody want's to take a stab at greatest stories by Grant & Breyfogle?

 

[Lazlo Panaflex]

Anybody want's to take a stab at greatest stories by Grant & Breyfogle?

Yeah there were a couple of good runs there that I've been buying all the issues for cheap at conventions.

 

[BubbaGump]

Not bad at all. I approve for the most part

Thank you, good sir.

Anybody want's to take a stab at greatest stories by Grant & Breyfogle?

All I know is that it wouldn't be complete without SOTB #13.

 

[Doctor Baywatch]

Doug Moench's 80s run. (Nocturna!)
Jones/Moench's 90s run.
Breyfolge / Grant everything.

I would prefer the OMNIBUS treatment.

 

[Cobblepot]

I'm going to look into some great Gordon stories, hope I can come up with a nice list.

 

[Nepenthes]

Batman 534 - The Green Ghosts of Gotham (1984)
Detective 589 - Brambles (1984)

Black Orchid pt.2 (1991)

LotDK 42 & 43 - Hothouse (1993)

Batman 529 - Tears of Blood (1996)

SotB Annual 5 - I was the Love Slave of a Plant Based Killer! (1997)

SotB 88
Batman 568
Detective 735 - Fruit of the Earth (1999)

Batman 612 - Hush: The Battle (2003)

Detective 797-799 - Low
(a back-up story in War Games issues, combined it would be about one issue length)

Gotham Cental 32 - Nature

Detective 832 - Stalked

 

[BubbaGump]

For me, this would be the greatest Two-Face TPB evah:

-Detective Comics #66
-Batman Annual #14
-Batman: Faces
-Batman #234 (?)
-Batman: Gotham Adventures #12
-The No Man's Land issue where Dent starts getting the hots for Montoya
-The NML issue where he puts Gordon on trial
-Gotham Central: Half a Life
-Batman B&W: Two of a Kind
-Batman Adventures #22
-Batman & Robin Adventures #2
-Batman #653

I got my wish.

http://www.dccomics.com/comics/?s=31&cm=9174

The issues in bold are the ones I listed, and are actually appearing in the TPB.

DETECTIVE COMICS #66, 68, 80, 187

BATMAN #81, 234, 527-528, 653

BATMAN: BLACK AND WHITE #1,

plus Two-Face's origin story from COUNTDOWN #29!