3rdstone
Original Manhunter
- Joined
- Mar 16, 2011
- Messages
- 3,488
- Reaction score
- 2,927
- Points
- 103
One of our finest exports.
To be fair to Lynch's adaptation, he was forced to cut the movie down and didn't get the option of splitting it into 2 movies. So they did have about 5.5 hrs to tell the story, which helps a lot in streamlining it.One thing i gotta hand it to Villaneuve and the screenwriters for is really doing a great job of streamlining this supposedly very complicated and convoluted source material into a REALLY straightforward story. Part 2 is even way more straightforward than part 1 and i would also argue just overall more palatable for general audiences.
Theres more humor in this one and more naturalistic acting from almost all of the actors as opposed to part 1 where it felt like everyone (except jason mamoa) was so stoic and talking in colloquialisms, the acting and dialogue in this part felt a little more…modern to me? To an extreme degree mind you, but subtly. I feel like that may have been a subtle change on Villaneuve’s part to make sure audiences had an easier time digesting this one.
Would be amazing if the movie can pull that off. In that case, we'll definitely see Dune Messiah / Part 3 a few years down the line. Especially with Legendary mostly financing.Projected to open with $80M domestic + $90M foreign.
![]()
‘Dune: Part Two’ Will Dust Off The Box Office With $170M Global Debut – Preview
'Dune: Part Two' to see $170M global box office opening.deadline.com
Certainly looking better than Part One... which, of course, had that wacky, staggered theatrical/Max streaming release.Would be amazing if the movie can pull that off. In that case, we'll definitely see Dune Messiah / Part 3 a few years down the line. Especially with Legendary mostly financing.
I actually thought Villeneuve and the writers were the stars in the first film. Some great quotes in that first film and I just thought that script was pretty great. Now I actually went and checked and it seems that both Dune 1 and 2 had 3 writers but just not the same ones, for the sequel they changed 1 of them. Dune 2’s script didn’t stand out at all to me, on the contrary some parts weren’t great at all.One thing i gotta hand it to Villaneuve and the screenwriters for is really doing a great job of streamlining this supposedly very complicated and convoluted source material into a REALLY straightforward story. Part 2 is even way more straightforward than part 1 and i would also argue just overall more palatable for general audiences.
Theres more humor in this one and more naturalistic acting from almost all of the actors as opposed to part 1 where it felt like everyone (except jason mamoa) was so stoic and talking in colloquialisms, the acting and dialogue in this part felt a little more…modern to me? Not to an extreme degree mind you, but subtly. I feel like that may have been a subtle change on Villaneuve’s part to make sure audiences had an easier time digesting this one.
When I watched Dune 1 i actually thought that It could’ve very well been the foundation for the next great trilogy, one up there with the best like LOTR. That’s how highly I thought of the first film.The more nuanced takes are what I'm paying most attention to. Not because I don't believe the film is great, but because it seems like people want to so desperately call every new event film the next "lord of the rings, empire or dark knight". Obviously not saying it can't be that, but there's so much hyperbole out there. I hope I love it! I adore films like this. But I see people saying part 2 makes part 1 better similar to Two Towers with Fellowship. Again, I very much was a fan of dune part 1, but I still find fellowship of the ring to be a more engaging stand alone experience even without two towers.
How would you say the action is in part 2?When I watched Dune 1 i actually thought that It could’ve very well been the foundation for the next great trilogy, one up there with the best like LOTR. That’s how highly I thought of the first film.
I don’t agree with Dune 2 making 1 better at all. And yes Fellowship is better and so is the Two Towers in a direct comparison. If I had to rate them it would be something like this and this is exclusively with these 2 franchises in mind without rating anything else in the same way.
Fellowship - 8.5 / Dune - 8
Two Towers - 9 / Dune 2 - 7