The Dark Knight Forum Choice

[Hunter Rider]

Ok guys it came to my attention that a few were upset with the choice to sticky the Nolan Realism thread and i gave my reasons and listened to your views.....I re read over it all and my reasons didn't satisfy me.

So what i am saying is that i always said that this mod gig wouldn't be a ego trip or any of that crap so i am flat out admitting i was wrong in my judgment to sticky it and the ppl complaining had valid points and so i took that into consideration and un stuck it.

No offense to The Batman who did a great job bringing the topic to the fore.

An idea i had was rather than having a lot of stickies at the top how about we have just 1 that contains links to all the important topics like Joker's main thread,the main Dent thread,the Batcycle thread etc....?

This worked in misc movies for big upcoming movies,it means that if a poster wants to make a general post about say the Batcycle they don't have to rely on the search they can just go into the stickied thread and find the link to the Batcycle thread

Thoughts ?

 

[The Redux 714]

One big sticky, with all important serious TDK topics inside?

Sounds good, however it could get messy within the thread. But, it'd be less messy than cluttering up the main board. I'm for it.

 

[itsthebatman]

Sounds good to me. Big of you to admit a mistake.
Just one concern: will it be easy enough to find those linked threads, did it work ok previously?

 

[Hunter Rider]

All the threads will be put in by me and it will be closed for posting,submit them to me via PM and i will add them so it will be a one post thread purely to collect all the important topics in one easy post for simple access.

It would look like this

http://forums.superherohype.com/showpost.php?p=10931607&postcount=1

 

[Baba Ghanoush]

You got my support.

 

[Mister J]

An idea i had was rather than having a lot of stickies at the top how about we have just 1 that contains links to all the important topics like Joker's main thread,the main Dent thread,the Batcycle thread etc....?

At first mention, this seemed kinda messy, but after checking out the link and actually seeing the setup, I think that'll work just fine.

 

[raybia]

Ok guys it came to my attention that a few were upset with the choice to sticky the Nolan Realism thread and i gave my reasons and listened to your views.....I re read over it all and my reasons didn't satisfy me.

So what i am saying is that i always said that this mod gig wouldn't be a ego trip or any of that crap so i am flat out admitting i was wrong in my judgment to sticky it and the ppl complaining had valid points and so i took that into consideration and un stuck it.

No offense to The Batman who did a great job bringing the topic to the fore.

An idea i had was rather than having a lot of stickies at the top how about we have just 1 that contains links to all the important topics like Joker's main thread,the main Dent thread,the Batcycle thread etc....?

This worked in misc movies for big upcoming movies,it means that if a poster wants to make a general post about say the Batcycle they don't have to rely on the search they can just go into the stickied thread and find the link to the Batcycle thread

Thoughts ?

I like the idea. But if it doesn't work then,


"WE HAVE TO GO BACK!"




Raybia

 

[itsthebatman]

At first mention, this seemed kinda messy, but after checking out the link and actually seeing the setup, I think that'll work just fine.

Yep, that swayed my vote alright.

 

[Cain]

I do something similar in a forum I mod at with a movie index. You'll find it makes modding a lot more easier and less time consuming. Makes the forum look more organized too. Too many stickies is never a good thing it just gets too cluttered.

 

[thedarks0ldier]

I like that idea

General, count me in

 

[SolidSnakeMGS]

Its a good idea, but its all about organization.

Perhaps you should make it alphabetical, say for example you'd have a header that says 'Joker', and underneath all of the topics relating to that.

Realism, with the several topics associated with that after.

http://forums.superherohype.com/showpost.php?p=10931607&postcount=1

Looks good, but I'd put more spaces between the subjects, but remove the spaces between the subject and the respective links, if that makes any sense.

 

[Two-Face]

Batman: Nice.

 

[AndrewGilkison]

It works for me.

 

[Comic Book Boy]

Thanks for unsticky-ing that thread, and good idea about the collected thread.

 

[Comic Book Boy]

Another board, Toonzone, has a collected thread for all the BTAS episode talkback, Hunter Rider, click the link to see what the collected thread can look like:
http://forums.toonzone.net/showthread.php?t=39984

Hopefully that can inspire you about what this collected sticky thread could be.

 

[Hunter Rider]

Thanks for the Link CBB,i'll look into it

Good idea on the Alphabetical order Snake

I'll leave this as it is for ppl to have their say and then on Monday i'll make the sticky

 

[JStorm]

Hunter, can you make me a sticky?

 

[SuperHeroHype]

Personally, I'm not a big fan of how some of the spoiler boards here have had so many stickies. I definitely say put the links in one sticky.

 

[FCEEVIPER]

Alphabetical order sounds good.

Maybe the Member of the Sons of the Batman forum can be unsticked after a couple of weeks.

 

[Steelsheen]

brilliant upon brilliant idea Hunter.

 

[kytrigger]

I think the one main sticky link is a good idea. Other than that, maybe sticky just TDK FAQ thread (if there is even one right now) and just sticky a new thread for something major for a week or something (like when we know the trailer is coming out) sinc ethat will specifically bring a lot of people to the boards and many of them probably won't even look in the general thread you create.

 

[Nepenthes]

sounds good. should help keep it to one thread per topic.