Marvin
Avenger
- Joined
- Jun 22, 2003
- Messages
- 19,564
- Reaction score
- 1
- Points
- 31
I think this might be the best way to play it. I don't hate Goyer as much as some, but sometimes he takes things too far and makes them needlessly complicated.
The Clark Kent persona is part of the Superman story. An important part. The fact is, and even Goyer knows this judging by MOS's ending, that it can't be removed from the story. It just can't. It's a part of every Supes story in some capacity. The same with his flying, Lois Lane, etc. He can give some explanation, but there's no need to explain everything. Maybe Smallville just keeps the secret out of fear/respect or something. The military wouldn't give the public any details about an alien invasion. The general public doesn't know anything. Most people haven't seen Supes close up.
And forget about facial recognition software and crap like that. No need to get into it. There have and always will be people that take issue with the Kent disguise. Coming up with some complicated explanation wouldn't solve these issues. Those people would just pick apart every explanation made because they can't accept it and never did. Whatever. Forget about them. They'll probably still see the movie for Batman or the action or whatever. So there's no need to make the Kent disguise appeal to them.
This is a movie with Superman in it. There are some core pieces of him that must remain. If Goyer doesn't want to make a Superman movie, then he shouldn't.
I personally can't look at some of the criticism MOS took and think the film tried to explain "everything"
I mean just look at the subtle exposition on his powers and what it's reduced us to arguing over lately(sun based/atmosphere based). The problem is the producers can't win. They skim over some things people will complain, they indulge in others, then other people complain about over indulgence..Why even bother.
The irony is at the end of the day it's all there. This movie did present a double identity that did demand the audience suspend it's disbelief, right down to big give aways such as an easy trail back to the kent farm for anyone with the brains to look for it. What has that wrought? Pages of people arguing over the sense of it all
All fans can do is speak for themselves, which is all well and good but the way it's presented is as such: "the producers should listen to me because..."