If Batman had a Sinister Six who would be in it?

[zeptron]

I picked

1. Joker
2. Penguin
3. Two-Face
4. Riddler
5. Scarecrow
6. Poison Ivy

 

[david icke]

I would go for...

1. The Joker
2. Two-Face
3. Catwoman
4. Ras Al Ghul - he would form the group
5. Scarecrow
6. Zsaz

a not so sinister six...

1. The Cluemaster
2. The Eraser
3. Egghead
4. Crazy Quilt - he would form the group
5. Maxie Zeus
6. The Signal-man

 

[Spider-Kurt!]

Ra's Al Ghul or Hush in the Dr.Octopus leader role

Catwoman in the Sandman relunctant former villian/hero role

Two-Face and the Joker in the classic villians with a grudge role (Electro and Vulture)

Scarecrow or the Riddler in the mind ***** Mysterio role

Clayface for Kraven and then another Clayface to replace the original as with Hobgoblin



BONUS Sinister Seven
Bane replacing Venom

 

[The Villain]

1 Mad Hatter
2 Penguin
3 Killer Croc
4 Joker
5 Bane
6 Mr Freeze

t:

 

[Sonic1002]

Joker
Hush
Scarecrow
Penguin
Freeze
Killer Croc

 

[Kevin Roegele]

Here is what I would suggest based on which characters have been known to co-operate together. The Joker would unbalance the team as he is Batman's arch enemy. Two-Face is only half villain. Mr Freeze is a loner and isn't a bad guy in the traditional sense anyway.

BANE is the kind of mastermind who would put such an operation together.

THE MAD HATTER for the technology aspect.

KILLER CROC is dumb muscle.

SCARECROW adds something different is has been known to be a team player.

THE PENGUIN adds brains and money and other resources, and he has been known to colaborate.

POISON IVY is the seductress andher powers over people and plants make her extremely, well, powerful.