I would have enjoyed Bale and Routh, I think. The only challenge would be to get them in the same universe... wait... I think I got it.
Non MCU way to do the DCEU
Phase I: 2 years
Crisis On Infinite Earths Trilogy
- Shot all at once Lord of the Rings style
- Used to build up a full and vital coherent world with tons of variation and lots to explore further
- Main arcs: New Unknown Superman, Bale Batman, Gadot Wonder Woman, New Idris Elba Lantern, Gustin Flash, Momoa Aquaman, Harewood Martian Manhunter
- Supporting arcs: Amell Arrow, Cress Black Lightning, Benoist Power Girl, New Alexandra Daddario Zatanna, Kevin Conroy Old Man Bruce, George Newbern Superman Beyond,
- Movie 1: Starro and supporting cast (and some League members) as antagonist
- Movie 2: Legion of Doom as antagonists
- LoD includes Bald EisenLex, Tom Welling Bizzaro, Strong Sinestro, Murphy Scarecrow and more used for very specific purposes.
- Movie 3: Big broughaha of alternate univeres. Earth 3 (Keaton's Owlman especially) is the antagonist, though he works for/by the Anti-Monitor. One Barry dies that the other may live.
Phase II: 4 years
Green Lantern Trilogy
- Also shot all at once, John Stewart as main character
- Movie 1: Hallalax, Manhunters and Sinestro/Mongul as villains
- Movie 2: Sinestro Corps with Star Sapphire and Atrocitus as villains
- Introduces Guy and Simon as alternate lanterns
- Movie 3: War of Light lite, essentially
- Introduces Jessica and Kyle as alternate lanterns
Hawkgirl Trilogy
- Also shot all at once. EPIC love story.
- Movie 1: Hath Set in ancient Egypt, Greece, Japan and Thanagar, happy ending w/cliffhanger
- Movie 2: Renaissance, Knights, Cowboys, World War II with JSA vs Vandal Savage, sad ending
- Movie 3: Modern Day, Justice League crossover, vs Thanagar, happy/sad ending
Still do Batman, Superman and Wonder Woman on TV
- Six Seasons and a movie!
Justice League: Darkest Night
- One shot big giant teamup that digs up graves and tests everyone in the DCU
Phase III: 5 years
Suicide Squad as a TV series, companion to Batman on HBO
Door open for all sorts of series for any B-list JLAers, Black Lightning, Black Canary, Vixen, Atom, Shazam, etc on any network, even the CW
Flash
- One series not shot all at once, but released every other year
- Movie 1: Rogues, Die Hard in a City
- Movie 2: Reverse Flash, The Matrix meets Back to the Future
- Movie 3: Doctor Alchemy, Full Metal Alchemist god-like Die Hard on a Planet
Teen Titans
- Yearly series ala Harry Potter
- Movie 1: Despero and the original 5
- Movie 2: Trigon with the full lineup
- Movie 3: Deathstroke with Jericho, Ravager and Judas Contract
- Movie 4: HIVE with Cheshire, Fearsome Five and Queen Biyalia
- Movie 5: Blackfire and Psimon make comic relief Doctor Light a legit threat
- Movie 6: Brother Blood makes a deal with Klarion
- Movie 7: The Light conspiracy finally unveiled
New Gods
- One off 'risky' movie
- Wild and trippy Inception meets Clash of the Titans
Aquaman Trilogy
- Shot at Once, literally 'underwater Lord of the Rings'
- Avatar-level mo-cap and FX
- Movie 1: Orm, King Shark, Mera and the Battle for the throne and his people
- Movie 2: Revenge of the Black Manta
- Movie 3: Atlantis (instead of Amazons) Attack, Big JL Crossover
Phase IV: 6? years
Trinity Trilogy
- Armed with development and knowledge and pathos from the TV shows, a movie series *about* Batman, Superman and Wonder Woman together
- Final Crisis inspired, lots of guest spots from other characters
- Movie 1: BatmanSuperman comic's Supergirl storyline with Lex and later Darkseid corrupting her, killing Bats
- Movie 2: Batman coming through the ages, Superman/Wondy rel'p, Anti-life makes world haywire
- Movie 3: Batman/Superman public enemies, Wondy: Bride of Darkseid, Superman wishes for a happy ending
Nightwing
- Mid-budget action film, lots of crime and simple grit and punching
- John Wick meets The Raid
- Sequels made based on popularity
- Villains like Blockbuster, Dudley Soames, Lady Vic, Shrike and etc
Dark League
- Justice League Dark with Magic, another one-off 'risky' movie
- Swamp Thing, Constantine and Zatanna are the 'trinity' here
- Let Gillermo Del Toro go crazy, and then just use magic to fix the continuity later
Justice League: Zero Hour
- Eclipso as big bad, big fallout from Dark League where whole Universe teams up against the apocalypse
- Use this to reup contracts and replace actors who want/need out, and then keep it rolling into Phase V with fresh blood and moar stories.