MattBearPig
Civilian
- Joined
- Mar 9, 2008
- Messages
- 704
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 11
Will they put this out in Blu-ray?
It was my #1 movie of 2007.
I saw this tonight, a beautifully crafted and moving film. after the 1st 10 minutes i was concerned it was gonna be pretentious with all the philosophical "meaning of life" voice over stuff, however we soon find Chris McCandless was a decent, just quirky, young guy who didn't think the way most ppl choose to live life was "wrong".... he just didn't think it was for him.
The back and forth from the magic bus to his journey to that point is inspiring, sad, funny, warm, lonely, uplifting and ultimately tragic.
The way you see Chris' discovery of himself and of life through his travels is interestingly paralleled by what others learned from him and how he touched many along the way.
His discovery in the end was simple and yet in search of his identity and meaning beyond the everyday he had to pay a price, yet he lived more in those 2+ years than most of us will in our lifetime, so was it a fair trade ? I guess only the real Chris McCandless can answer that.
Emile Hirsch was extraordinary, we all know "Dark and edgy" is the critics choice but i found this character to be one i will think of long after Daniel Plainview and Anton Chigurh have been stowed away into the same vault as Lecter and co....Yes the man was real but he wasn't a famous man, so it took a wonderfully gauged performance from Emile to show us who Chris McCandless was, he didn't shy from the fact at times he came off as selfish in his dogged pursuit of life, yet he was also a fun, quirky, smart and kind guy who was interested in seeing beyond lifes basics.
I enjoyed all of the support characters he met along the way, Rainey and Jan were my favourites though. It felt like Chris could have found his place with them if he'd allowed himself, the second time in particular was great, the scenes with him and Tracy were done beautifully.
Sean Penn's direction is perfect, he never allows anything to slip into schmaltz but he gets every drop of emotion he can out of the movie and it's pivotal scenes, the way he keeps it restrained at points and opens up at others is superbly gauged and he makes full use of the structure of the narrative.
He also fully utilizes the amazing scenery on show throughout Chris' journey, capturing the utter beauty of the vast American landscape. The cinematography is some of the best ive seen.
For me this was a better movie than either NCFOM or TWWB and the best movie of 2007.
10/10
I had a feeling you would really like it. I have yet to see DDL performance in TWBB and I did love Bardem in NCFOM, but I thought this performance was in line if not better then Bardem, and i'll be suprised if DDL was better as well. Of course this is just my opinion, but there was just something about this performance that I loved. It's like you said this is a performance you'll talk about for a while, hell I watched it last Tuesday and im still raving about it....I might watch the film again tommorow.
You completely nailed Emile's character he was selfish but there was something that was endearing to him. Some many great scenes in this film....that scene where he eats the poisionous plant, and he realizes that he is more or less dead the emotions he goes through...tremendous acting! What did you think of Hal Holbrock's scenes? For as little as he had, I thought he was great as well.
Im with you best film of the year![]()
So, I finally saw this yesterday, simply amazing! Emile's performance was unbelievable, the kid is an incredible actor, with a long bright award filled future a head of him. The fact that this, and Gone Baby Gone, the two best movies of 07 IMO got no love during Award season is remarkable.
Overall I'll give 8.5 or 9/10.
The final show of the real Chris McCandless was just eerie. This is definitely one of those movies that just stays with you for a long time after you watch it.
Have you seen Gone baby Gone? If not, rent it! I'm sure you'll recommend it to your friends.
I may watch this again, in a day or so. Hirsch definitely deserved a nomination.